Software
Houzz Logo Print
dreamstained

Non-sharp Cacti?

11 years ago

Hello. We are the very not graceful cats of Dreamstained, who would be covered in cacti thorns should Dreamstained buy a cacti. We like to sun on the window next to the plants, and occasionally we scent mark plants with our faces. We also have poor spatial comprehension and sometimes end up with a face full of C&S instead of making contact with the plant. At least one of us is dumber than a box of hammers, and routinely runs right into solid objects, but we're both very cute. Dreamstained would like to know if there are any cacti we could possibly not cause complete travesties to ourselves with, as the winters here are cold, so any sort of cacti she could own would need to be unable to stab us. Thank you for any advise you have. We'll be off eating the spider plant if you need us.


Comments (29)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There's a type of cacti that Richard has that has papery spines. Can't recall the name but if you do a search for papercut and oldstumpy1, it may bring up his post about it.

    there are also spineless cacti but you need to watch out for glochids on some types.

    How about some nice epiphytic cacti? For a hanging basket. Or some Hatiora/Rhipsalis?

    although, I'm pretty sure the kind of Rhipsalis I have would just be a tasty snack for those guys.

    Dreamstained (6a) thanked laticauda
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Thank you, Laticauda, I will have to look into some things to see if I can find Oldstumpy's plant. :)

    I'd love a hanging basket, but i'm not permitted to alter the ceiling, or make any holes in the walls, so I don't know how I would actually get one to hang, alas.

    Fortunately so far the cats would much rather chew on the spider plant than bother the succulents any. Kitty #2 only ever bites cat grass actually. Kitty #1, has bitten down on a PVN leaf but it apparently was not to her liking because she's never repeated the act, and sticks to chewing up spider plant instead, lol. Then again.. if the Rhipsalis resembles the right texture to either of them, that might happen as well.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You don't have to keep them in hanging baskets. MaNY people keep the holiday cactuses in large pots on a stand.

    Epiphytic cacti are very diverse and some have very beautiful flowers. Just be careful, some of them get quite large.

    eta: what's PVN? I'm drawing a complete blank.

    oh, also there are those sticky hook things that have the release tab. You could use one of those placed above the window sill. Just make sure your wet pot doesn't exceed the weight limit! You can use rope, chain or those hooky things you can use to extend a hook down away from the ceiling.

    Dreamstained (6a) thanked laticauda
  • 11 years ago

    Oh, good to know they can be potted instead. I wasn't sure if they just plain preferred to hang instead or not.

    PVN: Perle Von Nuremberg. Since the rosette forming Echs apparently don't taste nice to her, I sort of try to put those at the boarders to keep her away from the rest of the plants, but I just don't know if that would be enough protection from a cacti with her. She's managed to fall off just about everything in the house a few times.

  • 11 years ago

    Wow, that is an amazing looking cactus! I will have to keep a look out to see if I ever spot one around here. :)

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Dream

    Just a little correction on name: it is Nurnberg (not Nuremberg) for PvN.

    Maybe you should try some sanseverias, or haworthias - they tolerate conditions with less light too (I am just assuming that they will be indoors year-round) - ops, I just realized you are looking for cacti...

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Hmmmm Lophocereus and Myrtillocactus are what first come to mind. Also epicactus.

    Rebutia densipectinata is also a good choice, it has spines but they are completely flat.

    But outside of cacti there are lots of non-spiky succulents. Just do some research on the types you are interested in to make sure they're not toxic to kitty.

  • 11 years ago

    Mammillaria Plumosa? They're really fluffy, the spines really look like feathers.

    I'm not sure about toxicity...so hard to find anything about toxicity on pets online..

    Dreamstained (6a) thanked ealdwood (10a)
  • 11 years ago

    From my underatanding, most cacti is safe to eat.....unlike Euphorbs, cacti are mostly filled with water and chlorophyll.

    if you can squeeze it and clear (as opposed to milly) fluid comes out, it's normally safe to drink. Maybe you guys should take a desert survival tour/class?

    wouldn't that be fun?!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    See, I have this Euphorbia resinifera and my dog sat down next to it and it got him right in the keister. He jumped up so fast and whipped around. My husband tried to stop him from sniffing it but I figure, let the dog understand what the plant is (unfriendly) and then the dog's natural avoidance mechanism will do the rest.

    I'm not sure if hanging your cat up by her collar on a tall column cactus is a good idea though, dedefinitely don't do that lol.

    Sans2014 brought up a peanut cactus.

    http://homeguides.sfgate.com/peanut-cactus-desert-plant-70220.html

  • 11 years ago

    I like ealdwood's suggestion: Mammillaria plumosa. Some cacti look soft but they have something sharp hidden in the soft looking spines. M. plumosa isn't like that. A cactus covered with short sharp spines might be OK, too. I had one cat that sometimes tried to nibble on spiny cacti. No idea why she tried to nibble on it but cats have tough skin. She wasn't dumb but she was an odd one. Also, I suspect cats like to touch things with their nose. I don't know about Tephrocactus articulatus but I've noticed some Tephros look spineless but have little spines that come off the plant and stick in your skin if you touch them. However, I'm not sure if those are glochids or a bit different.

    Dreamstained (6a) thanked Polypompholyx
  • 11 years ago

    Yeah, those sound like glochids and they are worse than spines!

  • 11 years ago

    Have you been to Mount Scott?

  • 11 years ago

    I have an Oreocereus Cactus with really thick spines that my cats LOVE to groom themselves on. I use it as a barrier between their designated window and the other windows with plants on my sun porch. Only problem is that I often find it leaning slightly from them rubbing their faces all over it :)

    Here's a picture. Please ignore the bad soil, I've already amended my ways!

    -Cari

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I may need to surround my succulents with Chollas. Danged neighborhood cats!

    (I wouldn't actually do that to cats. Now...stinging nettle and people... .that may be a different story. )

  • 11 years ago

    Members of the genus Tephrocactus, Matucana, Lophophora, Turbinicarpus, Capiapoa, Gymnocalycium, Astrophytum, Ariocarpus, and Mammilaria either have no spination or select clones with very few/recurved/soft spines. However, without spines, you run the risk of your cats scratching up your cacti... it's something you'll probably have to test out!

    and don't keep Sansevieria (Mother-in-Law's Tongue) where the cats ca get to them, as it can damage your cat's larynx/voicebox if it eats it.

    Dreamstained (6a) thanked Ben was 10a/26, now 7a/34
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Oh wow, this thread really took off overnight. Thanks everyone, for all the great suggestions!

    Rina: Oopsie, lol I was very tired when writing that post. I normally know my plant's name. But apparently when i'm sleepy I don't.

    Minty: I do have some non-cacti. :) I was mostly just curious if there was anything in the cacti family that would be cat safe.

    Ealdwood and Poly: Ohh, thank you for suggesting the Mammillaria Plumosa, it is adorable!

    Laticauda: Your dog greatly out-thinks our cat, if the dog learned anything from that. Our intellectually challenged kitty doesn't learn from anything that goes poorly for her. She just keeps trying, even if she's trying to jump at a solid object and falling flat on her back after crashing face first into it.

    CariS: My poor Split Rock almost gets knocked over by the kitty trying to rub her face on it as well. I'm probably going to have to rearrange my setup so that something else is blocking the Split Rock given this.

    Ben: Thanks for mentioning the Sansevieria, i'll have to make sure I avoid that one then, as there's only one window that is very cat-secure in the house, and it's not really a great light window, either.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My cats didn't want to eat the Sansevierias, they wanted to poop in them.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Lophophoras aren't spiny, as Ben mentioned, but having L. williamsii for any reason is illegal in some places and I wouldn't count on law enforcement to recognize the difference between L. williamsii and the other Lophophora species that are less/non-hallucinogenic.

    CariS, I've noticed, with the exception of catnip and a few other plants, cats generally don't like smelly plants. Probably, one cat rubbed your Oreocereus first and the other cats started doing it to because the cactus became a kind of scent post. You might stop them by getting some green lavender, thyme, or oregano cuttings and rubbing them on the cactus. Plus, watching them wrinkle their nose is fun.

  • 11 years ago

    laticauda, I've had similar problems with cats pooping in plant beds outside. If one starts then the others want to do it, too. Smelly herbs or seasonings bought in bulk at a grocery store seem to help. I had some success with cayenne pepper sprinkled liberally in the trouble area. I'm sure there are other smelly things besides pepper that would work.

  • 11 years ago

    Actually, I had only one cat that would wrinkle her nose when she smelled things.

  • 11 years ago

    My male cat opens his mouth to smell things, like a tiger.

    cinnamon is a good cat deterrent but someone told me it makes them have an inflammatory reaction? Is that true? If it is....then I need to stop using it.

    non-sarp cacti that grows super fast!

    rhipsalis salicornioides

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    One of ours does that when smelling things too, Laticauda.

    I did get to see some lovely Mammillaria Plumosa while out yesterday, and I couldn't resist petting it's soft fluff. Unfortunately my housemate paniced at the mere thought of having a cacti in the house, even when I got her to very reluctantly touch it and see that it didn't jab her. I guess i'll just have to remain cacti-free in my succulent collecting.

    Ended up with a sopping wet Sempervivum Royal Ruby, to learn air-drying with, instead, lol. (Pictured prior to me discovering just how sopping wet it was. I was very tired and didn't get to repotting til today).

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    But that plant needs to live outside.

    what will you keep inside? Just get something that she doesn't realize is a cactus like a "Ming Thang" or something. The Rhipsalis don't really look like cacti either. You could get a Euphorbia ferox and when she freaks, be like "well, it's not a soft fluffy cactus, but I didn't get cactus because you didn't want cactus."

    or...tell her to get over herself, stop being such a brat and start acting like a grown woman. This ain't kindergarten anymore.

    but....I don't have to live with her.

    That sounds like it would be really annoying to live with someone like that.


    But that cat makes it worth it.

    speaking of neighborhood cats. Look what I found:

    EVIDENCE!

  • 11 years ago

    Lol that's very patient of you...The kitty is such a good model to pose right next to it.

    Oh the ming thing/thang idea is good, I can't remember if they had short spines or whatever.

    I mean yeah, there's a reason its scientific name is plumosa! Plume of a feather...! Well that's my theory.

  • 11 years ago

    I plan for the Sempervivum to go outside, but I want to give it some time to get bigger, so the squirrels don't completely eat it. When I tried to put my Perle Von and Peacockii out during the summer, they ended up ripped out of their pots every few hours by hungry squirrels.

    Kitties are very patient and don't mind posing with the plants at all, since they sun in a window next to them.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I know you have decided against a cactus, but keep this one in mind. http://cactiguide.com/forum/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=30596

    Very few, short spines and loves to flower. Flowers have a lovely scent.

    Dreamstained (6a) thanked notolover
  • 11 years ago

    That's a cute little thing. I've really become attached to the cacti.