Your new door might be too casual to work with the formal entrance. I think it might be helpful to keep some of the weather off your door. Maybe a canopy. I have added a contrasting paint to your entrance.

I think the door color you like would look nice

The style of door you picked is not compatible with the architecture of your house. Stick with a solid, six-panel door.

I agree with Laura Haynes about the beautiful blue shade you have chosen for the door. Now, I hope you will add a few small accessories in this color throughout the rooms of the house to tie the interior and exterior color schemes together.

Thank you for your input! I went with Wythe Blue for the door and changed the light fixtures to a more traditional Cape Cod style. Now, the green shutters do not work! Color suggestions???