Software
Houzz Logo Print
ckrohe

Totally confused!! Please help :)

11 years ago

So totally confused! Please help :)


We are taking the old brick of the fireplace down and replacing it floor to ceiling with the stacked stone. Here is my dilemma:


1. Since my bookshelves will remain white, do I have to use a white mantel for the fireplace? Can I do a floating mantel, or does it need to be more traditional because of my bookshelves? If wood, do I stay with the oak/hickory that we have in the house now? I found a retired carpenter that would make our mantel for us, but I have no idea what would look best!


2. Where the heck should I put our TV? On the stone above the fireplace? On the wall between the sliding glass door and the bookshelves? There is no other walls as behind our sofa is the staircase, the kitchen and FR are all open to the sun room. Any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!


We have ordered the stone, but can't do the fireplace until these questions are answered!


Thanks again! Cindy

Comments (28)

  • 11 years ago
    With a smaller room like yours, I would do away with the tv and table, looks too crowded. The tv could go above your fireplace and I would look for a beautiful reclaimed piece of wood for your mantle.
    ckrohe thanked Katbv Vero
  • 11 years ago
    I agree with cat videos, tv above fireplace. If you go to my idea book under fireplaces there is a setup very similar to yours with stacked stone , white bookshelves and a rustic mantle! It looks beautiful. Wish I could attach photos but can't.
    ckrohe thanked Business_Name_Placeholder
  • 11 years ago
    I meant katbv! Darn spellcheck!
  • 11 years ago

    love your new stone. use a big chunky mantle and I would use white, but I love white.

    also, hate tvs above fps. I would put the tv above the shelves, probably on the right side.

    ckrohe thanked Lori
  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Stone's lovely.

    Agree with katbv about getting rid of the TV/table combination then agree with Lori:

    • Hang the tv like a picture over the right bookcase on a swing arm mounting [do you really want the TV on your new focal feature? Unless you leave TV on with company and a fire going, I wouldn't!]. The swing arm will allow you to adjust whether you're watching from the kitchen or the couch.
    • Balance out the left bookcase top/wall with things of substance; vases, darker frames on picture groupings maybe just overlapping each other - like the ones on the shelves now with the bigger picture maybe hanging behind them
    • Let the stone go all the way up uninterrupted
    • Add a round or big square ottoman in front of the TV side bookcase that you can pull up for feet or food tray while watching TV or for guests when you're just there for a chat when it's off.
    • A plant like pothos that will like the filtered light on the bookcase, grow down to drape - even if you don't have a green thumb - to the right of the TV will soften that section
    • If you feel like you have to have a mantel, keep it even with the top line of the bookcases, the same color, simple and wrap it on all three sides - can be fatter but not a focal point... don't introduce anything new... the stone adds enough extra texture and pattern. Keep everything else the same as above and put something small on the mantel.

    Just a thought. Good luck!

    ckrohe thanked Kitty
  • 11 years ago
    I don't know why everyone has such a problem with the tv over the fireplace? This is a family room after all! The big oblong black hole of the firebox will be balanced by the big black tv above it! They are a fact of modern day life. Sticking them in the corner doesn't make them go away and makes the room lopsided. Now if this was a formal living room I would agree but in this case I vote for function over form.
  • 11 years ago
    I agree! TV over FP. Moving on! Smile.
    ckrohe thanked miacometlady
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you so much for all the great ideas! The other thought I had this morning is in the winter months, I love to get my great big pillow and sit on the floor right next to the wood burning fireplace as my husband and I watch movies! If I put the TV above the fireplace, I wouldn't be able to do that anymore.

    The stone will be wrapped around to the back of the upper wall.

    Do you think a white mantle would show up on that stone? The FP is 60", would you go all the way across or get a slightly shorter one? Unless I go above the current bookcase, there wouldn't be a way to actually wrap it around as the bookcase would be in the way.

    Love the idea of a plant on the bookshelves! I have a lot of plants in my sun room, but never thought to bring one in to the FR!

    Thanks for your help! I appreciate all of your comments!

  • 11 years ago
    A sofa with a chaise next to pot belly stove would allow you to snuggle and watch TV and get you off the floor!
  • 11 years ago

    My concern with a TV over the FP in this space is that it appears that there won't be a lot of distance between the TV and the seating placement which means that to watch TV, your viewing angle could put a strain on your neck. Here is a very good article regarding optimum TV viewing distance.http://www.apartmenttherapy.com/the-home-theater-mistakes-we-see-over-and-over-again-187251

    The other issue is that the heat from the fireplace can damage a TV. Google these issues and I think the only positive is that it saves space.

    I agree with jlsoule to hang it on a movable mount on the right side bookcase.

    ckrohe thanked tedbixby1981
  • 11 years ago

    great comments Ted! TVs over fps are not exclusive norm, they make for a bad viewing angle and except in rare cases, imo, don't look so great. I am all for TVs, we have four of them in our home (I know -- ridiculous), just not over the FP.

  • 11 years ago

    Everything in your home says "traditional" so if you want to simplify the situation just paint the fireplace white.

    Extend a white mantel across from the shelves and you're done.

    I do like the idea of TV over FP.

    ckrohe thanked leelee
  • 11 years ago

    Ted, thank you for sharing those links, I will look at those for sure! You are correct, we have less than 2 ft. from the sofa to the bookcase/fireplace, and that is the only spot we have for a sofa. We have ordered a new reclining sofa and love seat. The love seat will be facing the fireplace.

    We already have the stone for the fireplace, it will be installed in a couple of weeks.

    My husband is really pushing for a wood mantel since we are having it hand made. Will this look totally out of place with my white shelves?

    Thought about trying to cut in to the bookcases so I can put the TV to the right of the fireplace, as I am afraid sitting it on top will be to high.

    Thanks again!

  • 11 years ago

    Wow! Thank you so much for sending me these pictures, it really helps me a lot to see a visual! I did look earlier, but I think I put in mantels for stacked stone, so maybe that's why these didn't show.

    I have a feeling we are not going to be able to make it work with the book shelves. If we sit it on top of them its pretty high, and to put it under the top shelf it seems way to low. I think it would be pretty hard to add on to the bookshelves, we would probably have to tear everything out and rebuild them. The TV will fit on the wall, just wasn't sure it would look right.

    Thanks again for taking the time to look at this for me, I really appreciate all your help!

    Cindy


  • 11 years ago

    If I remember correctly ( so many post ago-lol) that I put in fireplaces with white cabinets- in case you want to look at more. Also, you might want to look at putting a piece of big art on one side and a big clock (as ideas) on the other side of the fireplace on the wall above each cabinet as I think it may help balance the TV next to the slider. Just something to try?? Glad to helped. Good luck. The stone will be beautiful.

  • 11 years ago

    I would put tv to the left of fp, above the bookcase.

    ckrohe thanked happyleg
  • 11 years ago

    Ted, What do you think of this?

    https://www.houzz.com/photos/bankhead-craftsman-family-room-phvw-vp~6470315


    Not sure if we could ever build bookshelves that would match what we have, but if not, do you think we could still mount it in the corner like that? Just a thought, hope you don't mind me asking your opinion!

  • 11 years ago

    Either option for your mantle will look great especially with the great stacked stone. If you are redoing your built ins you have so many options, cupboards below the level of the tv, and bookshelves above gives you the opportunity to be able to hide away the not so attractive tv bits and pieces.



    Media Room facing pool · More Info

    Family Room Built in · More Info

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    You could get a corner unit to work,

    Carmel Cottage Great Room · More Info
    Traditional Basement · More Info

    ckrohe thanked TraceyE
  • 11 years ago

    Thanks Tracey! I was just looking at a corner type bookshelf. I really like the idea, but I dont know if I can add it to the bookshelves we have. My husband isn't thrilled about redoing our bookshelves :) Not saying he won't, but that wouldnt be his first choice! I would love to have doors on the bottom so I could hide my grandkids toys, etc.

    [https://www.houzz.com/photos/bankhead-craftsman-family-room-phvw-vp~6470315[(https://www.houzz.com/photos/bankhead-craftsman-family-room-phvw-vp~6470315)

    Still trying to decide what type of mantel would look best as well! Thanks for your comments, they are much appreciated!

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Having a quick look at what I can see of the wall beside the bookcase on the right of the fireplace- do you think you would have enough wall space to mount the tv on a swivel mount-? If so you could then angle the tv at the same as you have now, you could remove the tv stand and mIght be able to have the components sit in the far right shelves

  • 11 years ago
    That stone is lovely and will look very nice with your white book shelves. I also think it would look best going all the way up. It would be nice with or without a mantel, your choice.
    Here's a different idea. Have you considered modifying your book case to hold the tv. It could still be mounted on a swing arm. I don't know if I would do that, but it seemed worth mentioning. Otherwise, I vote for swing arm on the upper right if you really want to clear up the space it's in.
  • 11 years ago

    Happy to help. I decided to post the TV cabinet you are asking about. You mentioned that you have a retired carpenter to build you a mantel. Does he have the skills that if you show him this picture, that he can tell you if it will work in that space? And possibly build it for you, too. I think it is a great idea as your TV stays pretty much were it is now but instead of it on it's own chest, it becomes part of the bookcase.

    Back to the mantel. Of all the pictures posted, are there any that you are leaning towards? Do you like when the mantel goes all across the front, as below? Or do you like when it stops short before the edge of the fireplace? Corbels or no corbels? Are these questions helping in giving you direction?


    Bankhead · More Info

  • 11 years ago

    Thank you for posting the picture, I wasn't exactly sure how to do that! I will take the pictures to the carpenter and see what he says, that's a great idea. We thought it might be a little low for the TV to be as is only 49" from the floor to the bottom of the top shelf, but if its on a swing arm, I believe we could move it up when we are watching it.

    For the mantel, I am a little confused on where it should be placed. Right now there is 21" from the top opening of the FP to the top of the (old) brick. The top shelf of the bookcase is about 3 1/2" above that. If I do a wrap around, the mantel would have to be above the bookshelf, which would put the bottom of the mantel about 25" from the top opening of the FP. Is that to high? The width of the FP is about 60". Do I need the mantel to have the same style/ledge as the book shelves, or can it be different?

    I think I am getting closer :) Thanks again for all your input!

    Cindy



  • 11 years ago

    If you use your fireplace alot and it gets very hot, that heat rises right up to your tv screen. While Aesthetically it may be the best choice, the functionality of your fireplace will be diminished. I know this from my experience. We wouldn't dare use our fireplace when our tv was placed above. In our new house we have it on a different wall.



    ckrohe thanked D D
  • 11 years ago

    Thank you! Our's does get very hot, and I would hate to not be able to use it! I am going to look at all the alternatives so I don't have to put it above the fireplace. I don't have a lot of options, but I'm just not sold on having it above the fireplace, and covering up all the stone we are putting on with the TV :) Thanks again for your input!

  • 11 years ago

    You might want to take either kraft paper or cardboard (something brown) and draw and cut the mantle to the size you are considering on it. You can then put it up on your fireplace and play around with it to see where you want it and if it the size is correct. If it would be helpful you can always give this as a template to the carpenter, too.