The bottom two are too dark and too light. The left upper one is kind of boring. I'd lean to the upper right one which is a more complex colour and would give some character. That said, I really love the way the colour is currently on the door and window trim. Would you consider just updating that colour and painting the house white instead?

Here's our house up north. In some light it looks more gray. In the bright sunlight it's more green. I thought you might get an idea of how it looks. The trim along the roof is a putty color. We bought it this way.

Thanks Cynthia! We definitely weren't originally thinking something with green tone, but the upper right option is quite nice. (Behr Juniper Ash). I've attached a better photo of the house. We are thinking replacing the door with a lighter tone stained natural wood door, and eventually stone veneer on the chimney in front. There is a white house next door to us, so we'd like to go with a color body and white trim. Let me know what you think.

Another thought, Would the Juniper Ash color clash with the green grass?

Yes, I see how you'd like to be different from the neighbours. I actually quite like your front door and I prefer a painted door to a wood one. I'm glad you're thinking of putting some emphasis on that chimney. I'm afraid with it painted to match the walls it won't stand out as much. With stone veneer it would get the importance it deserves.

I agree with Cynthia, the bottom two are too dark and too light. And for some reason the top left just feels too sterile/cold. The top right just feels like it has more life to me and I think it will look great with white trim.

And to your comment about clashing with the grass, I really don't think so. It should look just fine. Definitely think the stone facade on the chimney will make a huge difference. Happy painting!

My vote is the top right. It'll look nice with white trim.

Top right.

Thanks everyone for your suggestions! We ended up choosing [Behr Atmospheric PPU12-15[(https://www.houzz.com/products/behr®-paint-color-atmospheric-ppu12-15-prvw-vr~15054299) for the main color, which is just 1 shade away from the top right in the picture ([Juniper Ash[(https://www.houzz.com/products/behr®-paint-color-juniper-ash-ppu12-16-prvw-vr~15054302)). We're planning on a white trim, but still considering options for the door.

Please share a photo when you can. I want to see how it turned out.

Looks great