Software
Houzz Logo Print
mlh6bma

movement at rootball

11 years ago

I removed a bamboo container stake after planting since it was getting in the way. It seems there is now a small amount of movement where the trunk meets the ground. Not a lot, just a few mm, but it's not tight to the rootball like I'm used to seeing. Is this indicative of a larger problem?

Comments (8)

  • 11 years ago

    I doubt it is an issue. How large a transplant are we talking about?

  • 11 years ago

    you planted from a pot to the ground???


    not many real facts to go on here


    ken

  • 11 years ago

    Sorry. It's 6 gallon container grown. About 2.5 feet tall. 1.5 to 2 inch trunk as it comes out of the ground. The plant otherwise looks healthy. Not root bound. Soil was loose when removed from the pot and roots looked loose and were not wrapped around to any significant extent.

  • 11 years ago

    so.. if i understand.. its been growing just fine in this pot .... and now you want to fix.. what is otherwise a healthy plant ...


    dont love it to death ....


    if you repotted it.. say so ...


    ken

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Based on what I have seen for years here staking is typically done with small stock in production* because roots are in fact deformed by being left in bands, liners or small pots too long, unable to hold the top up. The worst examples are probably grafted conifers (very consistent) followed by a scattering of grafted deciduous trees, although camellias with terrible little squares or turnip-like blocks of badly misdirected main roots remain prevalent on this market also.

    Have you seen the entire root system, right up to the base of the stem? The area right around the trunk is usually where the worst problems are, rather than farther out, on the edges - unless the specimen has then been left too long in a larger container also.

    In my experience woody nursery stock that has ever been in a container at any point in the production cycle is almost always deformed. This includes balled in burlap, field grown plants. The only consistent exception is material presented to the consumer bare-rooted.

    *Except where a plant is a climbing or weeping kind that is being trained to be more vertical

  • 11 years ago

    I did not repot the plant. I received it mail order from a reputable nursery out west. They apparently remove the containers, place contents into tightly wrapped plastic, pack and send. So this was not bare root. Three days in transit. There really wasn't any evidence of major damage in transit just the typical bumps, lost a few needles etc. I planted same day I received. It really only jiggles back in forth a little at the base, no major movement and it seems to hold itself upright just fine. Not that I'm that experienced but I'm not used to seeing really any movement at all where the trunk meets the ground. I didn't dig out the inner rootball but as far as I can tell there does not seem to be any visible area where it tore free.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    If it were mine I'd look in there, awful j-rooting, kinking, knotting etc. is pandemic - reputable nursery or not. I threw out a $35 weeping cypress tagged as having come from a grower who has a history of touting the exceptional quality of their grafts because the entire root system looked like a single section of braided hair - how they even got all the roots to grow like a rope I cannot imagine.

    As this was a tall growing item I did not want to plant it only to have it blow over later, maybe onto something (or even someone) else in the process.

  • 11 years ago

    so ... man? .. it was potted at seller.. shipped to you ... and you planted.. in the ground.. with the potting media attached???


    see link ...

    https://sites.google.com/site/tnarboretum/Home/planting-a-tree-or-shrub


    replant ... native soil ...


    stake for one year ...properly planted.. in native soil.. it should not move as you SEEM to describe ... your base problem is the media/soil interface ...


    stake properly ...

    water properly

    mulch properly ...


    provide pic ????


    ken


Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting