Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_29518333

Is this frost damage?

10 years ago

I live in the SF Bay Area and have been pretty lucky with my succulent hobby for the last 5 years or so. All potted and outdoors. Recently it's gotten down to 40 degrees at night and I've noticed these particular varieties with some damage. Frost? We're also getting more rain than we have in a while and are about to get a lot more in the next week. Which is good but I'm getting concerned about the possible damage this may cause my little guys. Any insight would be awesome. Newby here.

Comments (12)

  • 10 years ago

    looks more like trauma... did you have freezing rain? Graptopetalum has to get REALLY cold to suffer frost damage... at same temp, Kalanchoe would be a melted pile of goo... so my guess is something different is going on.

    User thanked palmbob
  • 10 years ago

    Looks like the hail damage that my succulents suffered a while back....

    Josh

    User thanked greenman28 NorCal 7b/8a
  • 10 years ago

    Precisely. The hail beat the hell out of my plants.

    Josh

  • 10 years ago

    I live about 1000 miles away in NY. Certainly looks like my Echeveria after the terrible 2014 hail in Albany.

  • 10 years ago

    dununaya, the plants look healthy. The damage on the leaves doesn't look good but doesn't look like it will kill the plants. After some time the the plants will grow new leaves and will look OK.

    User thanked Polypompholyx
  • 10 years ago

    I have those same plants...no problems. I think your potting soils are staying to wet.

    We haven't had freezing rain in the bay area. What part are you in? Santa Rosa or Napa? Those are not really bay area. SF has had a low- one night- of 38f. Its been zone 10b. The rest of the urban bay area 10a- above 30f.

  • 10 years ago

    @stanofh, I'm in Richmond. I guess there was only a night or two within a month ago that it seemed there was a freezing rain. I just noticed a sheet of very thin ice in some shady corners. That's all I can think it would be? Would too much water cause this type of damage? They're definitely getting more water than they should right now because of the rain. And boy do we need it. Trying to make sure everything has proper drainage so it doesn't become a problem though. Maybe it's time to consider bringing them inside till it passes. Not sure. Thanks for the feedback though!

  • 10 years ago

    Its not frost damage for sure. Richmond's low of 35f this year is a 10b winter. I see that kind of damage in cool wet winters all the time. Move them if in pots,or under an overhang to keep dry. A porch or patio. I had to endure a 31 in Hayward!..feel for me-lol. Oh,if they are in ground- you might consider changing things in spring- moving or amending the soil to drain better. Even though 10 months of the year here is plenty dry.

    Richmond is one of the better subtropical growing climates in the bay area. I've seen tree sized Ficus benjamina's,Rubber tree's Shaving brush palms. Its why Golden Gate Palms nursery is there..he never has to protect his stock in cold weather.

  • 10 years ago

    Earlier I said the plants generally look healthy but the blackened areas on the leaves of the plant in your first picture make me pause a bit. Watch for changes of the blackened areas. Don't want those to spread.

    User thanked Polypompholyx
  • 10 years ago

    @Polypompholyx: Will do! I have these in multiple locations and they are all doing the same thing. Very strange. I guess this is a good opportunity to bring all my plants inside to let them dry out. We're gonna get hit pretty good with rain this week. As hard as the Bay Area can get hit anyways:)

  • 3 years ago

    @dununaya These look just like all my outdoor succulents right now. I'm in Northern Ca, and they're getting tons of rain and it may have froze about a month ago. What did you end up doing and how'd they do?