Software
Houzz Logo Print
allie_szot

Tomato Plant Questions

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I live zone 9 California

Compost, Dr Earth vegetable Soil or Fertilizer ?

- Should I use any of these when I transplant my tomato plants into the garden ... Like mix any of these into the soil?

- Has anyone planted tomato next to their lemon or avocado trees ?

- how close to plant basil next to the tomato plants?

what do you personally plant next to your tomato plants ?

how often to fertilize ? Any fertilizer recommendations for superior fruit growth and less Foilage?

- once transplanted into the ground, do you pinch off the flowers and lower stems to promote better growth?

Comments (17)

  • 10 years ago

    I don't think much of companion planting. One person plants rutabagas next to tomatoes, has a big harvest, and it becomes companion gardening lore. Don't plant anything next to tomatoes that shades them. That being said, although basil can grow to a height of three feet or more, tomatoes behind them should be OK as long as they get a head start.

    Why would you NOT want to mix compost in your soil? That's the cheapest amendment that will give your plants huge advantages. Commercial "vegetable soil" is probably mostly that, and some dirt. Some nitrogen fertilizer would give the foliage development a push, but you'd rather it not remain heavy in the soil when the tomatoes are trying to fruit.

    I personally pinch off early flowers, just to encourage the plant to grow more foliage, but it's never really been entirely clear to me that it increases productivity.

    Allie Szot thanked daninthedirt (USDA 9a, HZ9, CentTX, Sunset z30, Cfa)
  • 10 years ago

    I posted earlier about mixing compost, fertilizer or organic soil into my existing soil before transporting a young lemon tree into the ground and everyone said no because it doesn't encourage expanding roots, so it had me wondering: should I ever mix anything into my existing soil when transporting plants from pot to ground LoL...

  • 10 years ago

    I'm a brand new gardener, not my family, friends or myself have any experience growing anything haha! I need all the help I can get - when I had watched a lot of YouTube videos about transporting plants to the ground almost every time they used some sort of soil amendment to mix with the existing soil, which is why when people on the forum told me not to do that - it made me go back to the drawing board haha

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I am absolutely not an expert but I've grown tomatoes for a few years so I will tell you what I do when transplanting tomatoes. Dig a good size hole/ mix the compost with the soil you dug out, 50 50 or so, you can mix in the compost or the Dr.Earth or both/ hand full of fertilizer in the bottom of hole and mix in/ add a little of the soil mix to hole then plant your tomato deeper then it is in the pot, filling the hole with the soil mix... roots will grow from the stem and make a stronger and more productive plant. Water well when you plant but do not water every day, tomatoes do better with infrequent but deep watering, I fertilize with another handful of tomato/veg fertilizer when the plant flowers which is 4 or 6 weeks after planting. Work the fertilizer into the top of the soil and water well. Also, a tall stake in the ground when you plant is good since most tomatoes get tall and need support, they are vines. I plant basil near my plants but be aware tomato plants can get huge so space your companion plants 1-2 feet away at least. A lot of people poo poo companion planting but it is a fun experiment. Tomatoes need full sun to grow the best fruit so make sure your trees do not shade your tomatoes. It is a good idea to mulch around the plant to retain water and regulate the temperature of soil, I use straw but a thick layer of compost or manure is good too but not too close to the stem of the plant. Since you are new to tomato growing keep it simple so you can enjoy the process and not get overwhelmed. I'm in N CA and the master gardeners in the area recommend we plant tomatoes around May 1. Note: I am a female with small hands so a handful is about 1/8 cup. Follow directions on your fertilizer package.

    Look at the Growing Tomatoes forum... there is tons info.

    Allie Szot thanked User
  • 10 years ago

    "Hole prep" - what you are referring to - isn't generally recommend for anything for the reasons you mentioned. It tends to confine the plants roots only to that hole rather than expanding as they should. The better approach is to improve the soil in the entire area/garden if it is needed.

    That said some folks do "hole prep" with all sorts of things so if you want try it you sure wouldn't be alone. The success with it all depends on the quality of your soil to begin with.

    So I'd propose an experiment - 1 plant with compost etc. mixed well into the hole and 1 without. See which works best for you. I personally have little regard for Dr. Earth Vegetable Soil since it compacts tightly IME so I would avoid using it. Compacted soil suffocates roots. But compost never hurts. As for fertilizer? All depends on the type and brand.

    JMO

    Dave

    PS: ditto the recommendation for some extensive reading over on the Growing Tomatoes forum here.

    Allie Szot thanked digdirt2
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    EXCEPT: the OP lives in an arid climate and there the nutrition in the holes will be less important than the moisture outside that spot. When moisture is scarce, roots will grow towards moisture more than they will grow into food (so to speak) or soil structure. For a similar reason, trees and shrubs have a harsher effect on veggies than they might have in wetter ground. Of course, all this is moot if there's a lot of watering going on...

    Allie Szot thanked grubby_AZ Tucson Z9
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Forgot to add that I agree with Dan that all the companion planting stuff is hooey so I plant more tomato plants next to mine. As for fertilizer, there are literally a hundred discussions here about them and the one you choose all depends on what you soil and plants need. Ever had your soil tested?

    Here is one of the old stand-by discussions on hole-prep for you from over on the Tomato forum.

    Earl's Hole prep discussion

    Dave

    PS: Sorry grubby but I didn't realize that all of zone 9 CA was supposedly arid. Sure doesn't look that way on the maps of zone 9.

    Allie Szot thanked digdirt2
  • 10 years ago

    Tomatoes don't want a companion. They are greedy. :)

    Allie Szot thanked Peter (6b SE NY)
  • 10 years ago

    I always find that companion plants have totally different needs (soil, sun, water) than each other, so I end up with one healthy and one sickly plant, depending on whose needs I cater to.

    I remove lower branches and blossoms to keep them from touching the ground and inviting disease. Also, I have heard of adding bone meal to the hole if you have trouble with blossom end rot. I had that problem with several of my plants last time I planted tomatoes, so was thinking of adding some this time. I will probably add to some and not others and see how it goes. And then, I won't be able to remember which plants got the bone meal, so it won't matter. Did I tie ribbons to the ones with the bone meal, or without? Why do all the birds' nests have ribbons in them?

  • 10 years ago

    It all depends on where you live. I used to live in upstate Pa and then central New Jersey. We added very little to the soil. Now that we live in Ga we have 100% sand so we have to add to it.

    Allie Szot thanked zzackey
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If you can't amend all the soil (and if your California dirt requires a jackhammer to get through like mine), hole preparation is a good idea. Make the hole as large as possible without killing yourself...and much agreement with the suggestions of other as to how to prepare it and fertilizing options.

    One thing I did want to mention is that you should not plant anything anywhere near the feeder roots of your avocados or citrus - you just create competition for nutrients and water for both plants with benefit to neither. Not to mention that citrus and avocados have different water requirements than most annual vegetables...and since most of us out here have to irrigate rather than rely on rain, that can create a big problem for one or the other of your plants/trees. Leave your trees to themselves for best results.

    Allie Szot thanked Humsi
  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Wow, great responses!!! Thank you all! I do apologize about not being good and responding quick, I'm getting ready to enter into my Nursing program in April, its just as much "prep" as it is being a gardener hahah - with immunizations, doctor checkups, drug tests, background checks, list goes on from there!

    So I just planted my super young citrus meyer lemon tree in the corner of my yard, I've decided to plant the tomato plants about 4 feet away from the lemon tree, my lemon tree is about 4ft tall right now with about 20 leaves on it, if that, won't expect huge amount of growth for awhile, so I won't need to worry about it shading my tomato plants.

    Has anyone used kellogg brand? Maybe they have a type of soil i could mix into the existing dirt... or maybe Ill just head to my local nursery for some compost, I don't know why, but I just seemed so sketched out about it because I feel that they could put some stuff in it to make it not as organic as it could be maybe like putting human manure compost in it (worse case scenario) .. Ill check it out this weekend!

    As for the companion planting, I've gone ahead and decided I'll be just doing containers and they'll happily sit on my patio next to the future strawberry plants in other containers will be.

    OMG! thank you for just going ahead and reminding me of the whole blossom end rot, I looked it up and so many people suggest different things = watering with lime stone, watering or spraying foliage with TUMS, Oyster shells, or calcium tablets. Bone meal - hmm, wonder how much that costs... Any recommendations on personal preferences to prevent the whole blossom end rot and what you've used?

  • 10 years ago

    As for our horrible drought problem, its not too much of the problem will be having with our plants, I'll mulch heavily and run the drip irrigation twice a week, watering in-between just incase the soil moisture evaporates to quickly in-between irrigation waterings, it gets about 110+ here in the summer with ZERO humidity

  • 10 years ago

    If you pull up the many reviews on Kellogg products you'll find many negative reviews. Surely there are other products available near you. And for containers you want a soil-less potting mix anyway.

    "reminding me of the whole blossom end rot, I looked it up and so many
    people suggest different things = watering with lime stone, watering or
    spraying foliage with TUMS, Oyster shells, or calcium tablets. Bone meal
    - hmm, wonder how much that costs."

    Unfortunately that is true - all sorts of crock claims out there that just keep getting passed around despite all the research to the contrary. So before you waste a lot of money on the so-called cures and preventions do some reading over on the Tomato forum here about the real causes of BER. It is discussed in great detail there.

    Dave

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ive looked up the forums on the Blossom end rot, there so many mixed responses saying its genetic, infrequent watering, low calcium, the fact that there isn't a low calcium problem, - its just the fact that the infrequent watering causes the roots to not be able to suck up the calcium in the dirt, lol, ill keep reading up on it though. Yeah, kellogg and miracle grow is really popular around here, some people stand by it, others not so much. We have very limited dr earth products - those are at osh, and home depot carries their fertilizers. For EB stone, super limited on products too


    I know what people say about using lime stone is it can make the soil alkaline which isn't desired

  • 10 years ago

    I have found over the years that the very best information (when you don't know who you're talking to) comes from the many State Ag Colleges, starting with my own state, but adding to that the states that surround mine and have similar climates. Case in point, the advice for tomato fertilizer, is to stick to "moderate" nitrogen so that you don't get all foliage and little fruit. Over the last couple of years I have wondered if my "moderate" is not enough. Just this morning I found an article from a university in Missouri that gave specific recommendations for the amount of fertilizer to add. I have only been using about a third of what they recommend. (It has taken me a good number of years to figure out how to translate soil test recommendations for commercial fertilizers to the organics that I use.) So, until you figure out who the experts here are (and we have some really good ones), I recommend Ag Colleges. All that said, even a less than bumper crop of tomatoes is still wonderful!