Software
Houzz Logo Print
karateoman1

is my cactus dying

10 years ago

After re potting my cactus seems like it's somehow damaged. But I'm not sure if it needs water or if it's rotting.

Attached are photos

Any ideas????

Ps: i would appreciate if someone can id this cactus as well.



Comments (7)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Austrocylindropuntia subulata

    I don't think it is dying - rotting, why do you think so? Is there any yellow, dark/blackish or soft tissue? What kind of soil is it potted in? How often do you water? Is there a drainage hole in the container?

  • 10 years ago

    karateoman1, probably the plants are OK. However, check the things Rina asked about. This kind of cactus often looks like the plants in your picture after repotting. Give them some time. Eventually they will grow new roots and they will recover. Be careful you don't over water them. It looks thirsty but its disturbed roots have trouble taking in the water. This cactus likes more water than the average desert cactus but it can rot because of over watering like other cacti. The skinny growth at the top suggest your plants need more sunlight.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for your comments. Actually it has pretty good drained soil. 30% sand 30% small rocks %40 miraclegro cactus mix. This plant used to have fresh juicy spikes before i transplanted to slightly larger pot (it has huge root system). Now as you can see spikes lost the juicy look. Some of them turned brown (especially lower ones) And plant has wrinkles all over. My main problem i can not tell when it needs water and/or when its rotting. FYI: i water it every 20-30 days

  • 10 years ago

    Sand is not very good; and the MC cactus mix is questionable - I wonder what are ingredients of it. Usually, it contains too much peat and may contain sand too. Neither is recommended for succulents. These have fine particulates that clog up drainage. Peat is also hydrophobic - if it is kept dry for longer, it will dry up too much and is very difficult to re-wet. Water will just 'slide' off it and drains out, but roots will not get any drink. If kept wet, it compacts and the plants roots have difficulty breathing.

    How large are the rocks you mixed in? Having such small ingredients such as peat and sand, there is no point in having any
    rocks mixed in since the fine ingredients will fill all the space
    available between the rocks and impair drainage and aieration.

    Grit should be used instead of rocks. Sizer of approx. that as aquarium gravel. If any bigger, the rocks in the mix are useless. They will do fine as top-dressing.

    Other suitable ingredients are perlite, turface, pumice, scoria - can you get some of these (perlite is available just about everywhere).

    'Juicy' leaves may be just in shock from re-potting and should recover. They also shrivel and die of old age. If the roots are healthy, the plant needs to be watered. Depending on temps and light, 30 days between watering may be too long.

  • 10 years ago

    Hi Rina 'rock' size i used varies from quarter of a aquarium gravel to double of a gravel. I always thought sharp sand would increase drainage but never considered roots would not be able to soak water. I do not want to change the mix till may but maybe longer period of watering can solve this problem (water them for 2-3 minutes so roots can soak enough water)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Sharp sand sounds good, but 'how sharp' is it? It may be just right. There is sand sold as Horticultural sand too - I never bought any, but many use it.

    If you were to use ordinary kitchen sieve to sift it, would it stay in in or fall thru? - whatever falls thru is usually too fine to be used in the mix for succulents (yes, you can, but there is much more attention needed to watering-another thing to worry about :))

    Bigger rocks (approx. double of size of a. gravel) are too big for the mix, but great for top-dressing.

    The larger 'rocks' and the fine sand defeat each other. The particulates for good succulent mix should be very similar in size.

    The grit I use is chicken grit, bought in farm supply store. Very reasonable @ under $10/50lb bag (that's in Canada, it may be even less in US). Best size is #2, aka Grower size. I use next size #3 (aka Hen or Layer size) for top-dressing.

    Best way to determine if it is time to water is a 'skewer/dowel test'. Insert into the pot min. 1/2 way (or deeper). If it comes out with particles sticking to it and/or feels cold and moist, there is still plenty of moisture. It it comes out clean and dry, time to water. Best way to water is to water thoroughly, letting the excessive water to drain rather than in sips. After about 20-30 min, empty any water sitting in the saucer. If soil/mix contains lots of fine particulates, it may retain water for too long.

    You could add perlite to your existing mix, that is a simple way of helping to increase drainage.

  • 10 years ago

    Update: After 2 watering sessions everything is fine now. Spikes are juicy again, trunk of the plant is perfect and it looks health.