Software
Houzz Logo Print
dvargo71

grow tubs

I bought some grow tubs for peppers (10 gallon) and tomatoes (15 gallon). It seems to me like they are not big enough. Plants grown in them did not do nearly as good as same plants in my garden and required twice as much watering. I used potting soil inside.

I am going to try again using larger sizes (I will get 20 gallon for tomatoes).


My question is has anyone had them grow as good as in the garden? My garden has great loose soil and raised beds - in other words maybe my grow tub plants did ok - just not as good as my garden.


Peppers seemed to work a lot better then tomatoes I grew regular indeterminate tomatoes.

Comments (6)

  • 10 years ago

    Don - have you tried the search here to pull up all the previous discussions about some of these questions? It can be quite helpful and saves having to type all the same info over and over.

    As a general guideline no plant will produce or perform as well in any container as it will in the ground simply because the roots are contained. So there is no valid comparison.

    In addition Container Gardening is a totally different method of growing things that has its own different set of guidelines for container size, container mixes to use (never any soil), plant type and variety, water needs, and especially nutrient needs. That is one reason why it has its own forum.

    Assuming accuracy - as I note some smaller containers in the pics you have posted - the size of the containers you mention (15 and 10 gallon) are generally considered large enough for most any single plant (with the exception of a couple of tomatoes). many successfully grow pepper plants in 5 gallons, they just need a great deal more attention. And there are many over on the Growing Tomatoes forum who use 10-15 gallon containers for their tomato plants.

    So in your case the problem was not the size of the container. Rather incorrect expectations or a failure to meet some of the other requirements container plants have.

    Hope this helps but do some reading over on the Container gardening forum too.

    Dave

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks forgot there was a separate forum - however I tend to kind of disagree - I suspect a 55 gallon drum would grow a pepper pretty darn close to a garden - at some point size HAS to become irrelevant. This is why my plan was bigger then recommended. I grew peppers good in 4.5 gallon drywall mud buckets - but again more water/care. I am trying to get away from the more care part - and use containers as a way to have a few plants that are not close to same plants in garden in case of dieses. Also it is nice if cold to pull indoors for a day or two if needed.


    Thanks!

  • 10 years ago

    Sure 1 head of lettuce in a 55 gallon barrel would also grow just as well as in the garden but it would be a very expensive head of lettuce and a very inefficient use of resources and of the costs involved.

    Soil-less potting mix isn't cheap nor is time or all the nutrient supplements container plants need. The normal goal in container gardening is to strike a balance between the effective use of limited space, costs, and resources so that it results in the most production possible at the lowest cost possible.

    I use many 55 and 45 gallon plastic barrels cut in half as containers but since my garden pepper plants are grown at 12-16" internals I sure wouldn't waste all that container space on only 1 pepper plant when I can grow 3 in it instead.

    Dave


  • 10 years ago

    How much perlite should I mix per gallon of mg moisture control?

  • 10 years ago

    Nice plant man...