Software
Houzz Logo Print
lclark21324

Planting trees on a berm

What's up with this practice? I've seen it done lately in newer houses' yards. I think it looks neat, but how does it affect trees? Would anyone try this in the strip that's between the sidewalk and road?

Comments (20)

  • 10 years ago

    I,ve seen that on PEI, east coast of Canada, and they seem to be ok.

    We have them on an old berm for a manure pad, and although it's a bit rocky, they do well. I am zone 5/6, sort of on the border of zones. Maybe someone closer will answer you. :)

  • 10 years ago

    I think its trendy in copy cat neighborhoods.

    There can be some reason behind it. Down low in my front yard it is rather damp. A raised berm could help. What if I plant a tree with a LARGE size potential on a berm? Its roots will need to tolerate the damper soil or it is going to blow over.

    A berm may have a little effect on sound. Not much though.

    A berm can also direct water around your yard. Maybe plants will stabilize the mini levee?

  • 10 years ago

    I like raised beds. But I hate berms. They look like what they are, an attempt to cheaply get rid of excess fill, they are usually compacted beyond all reason, the look artificial-where on the earth is there such tight relief like that?-and they become maintenance headaches. Now just a modestly raised bed, 12 inches or less, looks harmonious, the plants like it, and it doesn't look so obviously artificial.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    There is a theory that it helps with drainage in soggy soil. (I've heard the experts question whether this works...but regardless, some believe it.) As toronado3800 said the tree is eventually going to have to deal with the soggy soil beneath the berm...but maybe it would have had more problems with that before it was established.

    I've also heard people recommend doing it for trees in a privacy screen...it gives you a couple feet of instant height.

    Honestly, I think one of the biggest advantages is to deter lawnmowers. You put a tiny sapling in the middle of a berm, no one is going to think it is a weed, or try to mow right up to it and potentially damage the bark. (I've also long thought the real purpose of mulch in many situations is to tell landscapers "I meant to put this here" and "the mower stops here".)

    I've heard it can make the tree more susceptible to drought. I do wonder what happens if the tree ever gets really tall.

  • 10 years ago

    The previous responses seem to indicate that this is something of a new gardening practice - it's not. Garden designers and landscape architects have been using berms for decades. They can assist with developing a privacy screen, they are helpful in situations with poor drainage or if the indigenous soil is not easily worked and they can provide some much needed contouring and dimension in an otherwise flat, featureless landscape.

    If berms are constructed properly, there should be quality soil involved with minimal compaction, the size/scale should be appropriate to the setting and the finished berm should look very natural.

    And you can grow anything in a berm that you can grow in the ground, including large trees. But the scale of the plantings should be tailored to the size of the berm - it would look ridiculous to plant something that grows 40'+ tall and with an equal spread in a 12" tall, 25sf berm!!

  • 10 years ago

    you really dont own the property between the sidewalk and road ... talk to your city about planting there ... or changing the elevation ... not to mention.. its there so peeps can open a car door ....


    presuming we are discussing a berm of reasonable size ... it has no impact on the plants ...


    ken

    L Clark (zone 4 WY) thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 10 years ago

    Gal, tell me how many times you've seen a berm constructed and landscaped to the criteria you outlined above? That's just the problem, none of this stuff is ever taken into account. My favorite least favorite-Colorado spruce up atop a berm.

    And I maintain, nearly all berms are created primarily to dispose of excess soil, subsoil, etc. Maybe as the practice caught on, other attributes were laid to it, but that's where/how it started in modern construction. Almost always hideously ugly.

    Ed, the raised bed is what you want if you're concerned about a plant needing drainage, etc. A berm is a much more substantial-and if you haven't figured it out yet, one which I consider much more artificial -construct. A planting utilizing raised beds could blend seamlessly into its surroundings. Not so a place ringed by impossibly (in nature) high, narrow berms.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    While I cans see the use of berms to contour the landscape, the main problem I see with them is the same as with any major slope. What are you going to use for ground cover.

    If you place grass on the slope you have to mow it. Mowing on any slope with a riding lawn mower is questionable. Using a push mower is not much better as it is so easy to slip and have the mower coming down on you or you coming down on the mower.

    You can cover the slope with mulch but that has its problems with keeping it on the slope.

    Ground cover becomes about the only acceptable ground covering. Then depending on what you use it could become a problem keeping it on the slope and not in your yard.

    The other things to consider are erosion and burrowing animals.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    krnuttle, I actually think the fact you can't get a riding mower up them is half the benefit...

    gardengal48: I believe wisconsitom's concern isn't berm's designed by skilled landscape architects, or even amateurs. The concern seems to be that builders and real estate developers may find themselves with extra fill they want to get rid of, and have recently caught on to the idea that a berm can be a way to do that. A berm made of fill could make small trees look bigger and LOOK good while not necessarily being good for the trees. How many home owners would go to the trouble to check to see what that berm is made of when buying a house?

    As far as the OP's idea , a berm in a "hell strip", that is an interesting idea. Wouldn't there be the risk the berm would avalanche onto the sidewalk or street? You probably wouldn't have space for a gradual slope. Would it have an impact on snow removal? (ie. would it be damaged by snow plows, would it take up space you need to put snow). Are there overhead wires? If yes, it could hasten the moment the tree hits the wires. Would it mess with drainage plans set up by the city?

    On the plus side...if there isn't much good, aerated soil in the "Hell strip" it could provide more soil for the roots of a small tree. It could provide a bit of a privacy screen, or elevate the branches so cars can drive under them.

  • 10 years ago

    We amused ourselves by building a small, circular one in the woods (although we call it a 'tump') - much fun for granddaughter and romping collie. A kind of very bargain basement version of Jenck's Garden of Cosmic Speculation...might do a Fibonnacci spiral next.

  • 10 years ago

    You're exactly right Ed...I'm talking about what I see every day, not the idealized version that exists in GardenGal's head...and evidently, in the yards of her clients! Of course there's a better way and a worse way to do things. That's hardly news. But what I see are terribly inappropriate landscape uglifiers....see, you've got me making up words!

  • 10 years ago

    Um, my understanding of berms and swales were purely water-course diversions and, therefore, in our easily flooded little island, of massive interest to this hydrology novice. Fill hills of spoil are something else altogether and not even dignified with a landscaping term. Do, please guide my reading on this since the whole idea of soft landscaping as flood amelioration is very much in its infancy here in the UK. Suggestions for info hungry wetland owners?

  • 10 years ago

    Hoo boy Camp, that's what I do. But backing up to berms again, as understood so far in this convo-GardenGal's descriptions are going to be most edifying. She knows what she's talking about. But as for the larger picture of stormwater management, I can tell you that some of the primary practices are: detention ponds, vegetated swales, biofilters, rain gardens, wetland depressions (Literally, little man-made wetlands), stream restorations-which may include some of these other items, hard armoring, soft armoring.....and onward and upward. But to break it down, I'd have to know the particulars. We haven't used the term berm in this context at all though. Regional and national language differences may be at play; we sure do enough grading.

    My favorite projects have been the stream restorations we've done. In one case, nearly a mile of what had become roadside ditch was re-meandered into what sure looks like a naturally-occurring watercourse. That is also a project utilizing wetland depressions. Quite a lot going on in something like that, including wetland mitigation, so that's one of the key areas where I come in and do the required monitoring, etc.

    But anyway, I'll write a book here if I don't just stop now.

  • 10 years ago

    Oddly, a berm made of construction fill could work just fine as a water course diverter...only trees growing on it would care.


  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Ah, Tom and Edincoln, I promise to come back to this with specific enquiries and some fascinating photos, including a 30metre stretch of raised bank which has, this last week or so, ripped up forming a great long lip of upturned earth with 4 mature ash trees (now leaning at a crazy 45degree angle into nearby trees) leaving an astonishingly thin (around 1 foot) rootplate with a stream running underneath. Not on my land, thankfully. My land is very fluid, man-made and constantly evolving. It was water meadow in 1947 and is now (neglected) poplar plantation.

  • 10 years ago

    Yikes, sounds like a mess. One thing I don't like about stream restorations, as they are practiced here, is that in nearly all cases, regrading of the banks is a major part of the job, and trees like those you describe-and this before they ended up tipped like that-would be summarily removed as a part of the project. We had to do that in two heavily wooded ravines where the banks were getting undercut like that along with other erosion, so as to get our proper slopes. We then used coir blocks along with some heavy rip rap, and lots of plants. so even though we did lose some trees, it really looks great, the erosion has been arrested, and to the eyes of someone who wasn't present when the job got done, they would never know there used to be more trees. Plus we brought in some appropriate species which although native to the area, were not present at the time of the project. So now I've got some nice hemlocks in the woods there, a few beech, etc. Fun stuff.

  • 10 years ago


    I think we're talking about two different kinds of berms. A berm should look natural and be appropriate with the planted landscape. You can't have an artificially contrived berm that looks like a burial mound. Gradual contouring works for me. I dig a swale between the lawn and the planting bed. The soil is used to mound the lawn so it drains and mound the planting bed so it drains. The wetter it is, the more I contour it. It's easy,.... the soil doesn't travel far. Usually I can do it with a shovel. (I like most shovel work) Also, I design it so the swale drains too, but absorbs as much water as possible with out puddling. A puddle to a landscaper is as bad as an accountant who can't add up a column of numbers. If you have more water than you can deal with that way, make a pond. That's what I did, only I started with a bulldozer and pushed up the heavy, black soil in the low places that had slumped since the last glacial age 40,000 or so years ago and ended up with 12 ponds on 10 acres up on a ridge. I spread it like peanut butter over the lighter soil on the high ground. Now, those areas retain more moisture during our dry summers, allowing more growth during the dry summers we have.

    Mike

    http://i75.photobucket.com/albums/i283/Botann/My%20favorite%20pics/2216546050036511179.jpg


    http://i75.photobucket.com/albums/i283/Botann/My%20favorite%20pics/2675978020036511179lmhZZb_fs.jpg


  • 10 years ago

    I agree with your initial statement Mike. And there are legitimate cases where even the obviously industrial berms could look better. In truth, if people would just quit planting very tall-growing plants on the tip-tops of berms, I'd like it better. Imagine an obviously contrived berm, still serving a purpose, but instead of the typically hideous row of Colorado spruce right at the apex, imagine a staggered grouping of Pfitzer junipers or something of that nature....not going higher and higher and higher, but instead, balancing out the berms verticality with some horizontal plant growth. But noooooo.........let's put our spruce up there! Gawd I'm sick of that look, let alone once the spruce get Cytospora...and every other one is half-dead....what a delightful planting! And people pay money to have this junk "designed".

  • 10 years ago

    Miketann - Your property looks like the garden of eden! Wow