Software
Houzz Logo Print
alexchicago

First sleep: Brooklinen Classic Core Sheetset

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

I have always enjoyed that Motortrend gives a "First Look" review of new cars so that we, the eager public, can sink our teeth into something while they do their more in-depth road testing and real-life driving. This review is about that same level of depth since I've only had the Brooklinen Classic Core Sheet Set (Bedford Navy Stripe) for one day.

Purchase Process - Simple, quick. I bought online, chose my payment and delivery method, and had the package shipped to work. Now that I know they ship using USPS rather than UPS, I will have it shipped home since I can have those deliveries during the day even if we aren't home. I received the shipment 6 days after purchase, including a 2-day delay at my local post office (Chicago has a terrible USPS system). Price for queen was $109 plus $10 shipping. I've since learned they do offer free shipping on larger orders.

Packaging - This shouldn't matter, but hopefully the same care that goes into packaging goes into procurement and production. The sheets were perfectly folded inside their own tote bag along with a thank-you note and a sample pack of "The Launderess" detergent. The sheets had no obvious scent or chemical odor, which I've come to expect from some other brands.

Quality/Texture - I first examined all the visible stitching: tight and no loose threads. Next I laid out both the pillowcases and the top sheet on a flat surface to make sure the pieces were cut square and could be pressed flat. Perfection. My issue with the Threshold percale sheetset I recently bought is that the two of the four pillowcases are impossible to press flat; the open and closed ends are not the same width and therefore geometrically crooked. Although the Brooklinen sheets are square, they also have designed the pillowcases differently. There is not hem visible on the outside. It is an internal cuff so the exterior is just pure and flat with no hem. I'm sure there's a word for this.

Washability - Despite perviously committing to doing the first wash in a liquid, I could resist washing these new sheets in some of the vintage Tide powder I recently secured. I used one Sears scoop (roughly 2 TBS) and did a 120F long wash with no FS. I smooth-pressed each piece against my chest before putting into the dryer and removed the cases and top sheet when they were still just slightly damp, allowing the fitted sheet to dry completely. Out of the dryer, these have a better feel than the Threshold sheets I've been using the last few weeks. The Threshold sheets, to me, feel a bit like wax paper out of the dryer; they press nicely, but feel somewhat artificial prior to ironing. The Brooklinen are wrinkled, like Percale tends to be, but feel softer. Most importantly, they pressed beautifully. The stitching and measuring is accurate so they are easy to lay out on the board and press. I was done with the pillowcases and top sheet in good time.

Bedmaking/sleeping - I have a medium-depth mattress, and the fitted sheet snugged up nicely in all corners. The Threshold fitted sheet is always a bit of a pain for me (it's not too small, it's just awkward) but this one slipped right on. The top sheet is plenty long, but I wish it were just slightly wider for tucking on the sides. It's not any narrower than the Threshold -- probably the exact same width. My partner and I both thought they felt very good for the first night. I'm chronically overheated in bed so having crisp, cool sheets has been a nice gift by going back to percale. I iron almost nothing, but pressing linen kitchen towels and percale bed sheets is almost therapeutic.

Buy again? - Too early to tell, but initial thought is YES. I am a bit supporter of direct-to-consumer, disruptive retail, and of anything not made in China. The price is also really good for material of this quality (long-staple, single-ply, Egyptian cotton). Plus, there's a generous 60-day return policy. I'm interested in trying their down comforter and duvet cover, but that may have to wait.

Attached are a few photos of the sheets in the package. You'll just have to trust me that they look good on the bed. We've finished off every room in our condo except the master, and it's just not photo-ready. Sorry, folks. But happy to answer any questions.

Comments (26)

  • 10 years ago

    And here is a photo of a made pillow so you can better see the design and the lack of hem.

  • 10 years ago

    I KNEW there was a reason I love the Threshold percale sheets -- they're cooler than regular cotton. Thank you. I should feel guilty for not pressing them, but I don't. But I love you, your sheets, and your comments on this forum. Can't wait to see your bedroom when it is ready. Don't forget, please.


    Alex Chicago thanked Pat Z5or6 SEMich
  • 10 years ago

    @Pat - percale is wonderful if you like sleeping cool, isn't it? My eyes have been opened. And thank you for the nice comments. Bedroom is a work in progress but I hope to make some progress this summer.

    @Roc - Blind hem. I knew you would know what it's called :) Their premium/luxe sheets look tempting but I'm not interested in anything that feels warmer, at least not until next winter.

  • 10 years ago

    We use the A/C in our bedroom, easily 11 months out of the year. I too am CHRONICALLY overheated during the night. Luckily I am NOT a night sweater, but I feel many times like am literally cooking! We keep the A/C set to 65F, and if it is really cold outside (for CA standards (below 40F))...we set the heat to 64F. I cannot stand sleeping in a warm room, it kills me.

    Percale sheets cooler? But....ughhhh, the wrinkles. I do not know if I could do it.

    It's funny I visited the Brooklinen website one time, the day Alex ordered his sheets. Now on Houzz, Facebook, abc7 News....all my sidebar ads are Brooklinen :-O

    Alex Chicago thanked larsi_gw
  • 10 years ago

    Everyone likes dofferent sheets. Percale are coolest and they keep their shape when its hot so they dont cling. Ironing is part of it. In the old days that wasnt an issue since they went to the laundry along with mens shirts that needed ironing. Larsi will end up with a rotary iron. I would bet on it.

    Im getting the brookside everywhere, too. Even on the word unscrambler page.

  • 10 years ago

    I agree. Larsi will have a rotary in no time. He has nine Miele appliances. A tenth just needs to happen to put the world in balance.

    Sorry you are getting bombarded with targeted ads as well. Good thing we haven't been discussing anything salacious.

  • 10 years ago

    Nice review Alex. Percale is definitely what you want if your body gets overheated at night, and if your a pillow flipper you will notice when you flip its always cool on the other side. This is making me want to sleep on my percales and maybe I will tomorrow night.

    Roc when is the last time you bought new sheets? Because I picture your bed made up with beautiful beautiful vintage percales.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    First off, I didn't say to Alex that the review was really a great one! You hit all the points Alex. What's more, it looks like you may have a found a good percale source. That's so great.

    Here's my dirty little secret @mamapinky. All my sheets came from the Sferra warehouse sales in 2006-07. The first one was before they had a website. A king percale sheet set was $87. We had 2 places then so I bought sheets for both places, also cotton knit blankets and my quilted duvet covers. That first sale was really good. Then they had them every 6 months and by the third one, prices had escalated, the best stuff I was after (Celeste Percale) wasn't showing up, and I was tired of getting up at 5 a.m. to rent a car and drive there to get in line by 7 a.m. Haven't bought any since 2007. Probably won't ever buy any more since that quality/price opportunity is gone. A Sferra set even on ebay -- folks in Jersey go to the sale and resell online -- is now $200-300.

    Here are some pix of the first sale. After that, I learned I had to lock everything but my keys and a credit car in the trunk so both hands were free and I could drag the big bags around the sale unencumbered LOL.




  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    @Roc/Jane - wow! Look at those photos. I can't imagine being there. Completely empty arms wouldn't have been enough. Sounds like a Costco-size shopping cart was in order. What a great deal you got on those sheets, even adjusting for inflation.

    If you have any recommendations for a summer-weight blanket, I'd love to hear it. Our duvet gets too heavy in the sticky Chicago summers and I haven't gotten around to purchasing a lightweight down yet.

    And thank you for the "review of my review." I've been on your blog and that means something coming from you.

  • 10 years ago

    Ok...how did you Rococo know that Sfera existed...and how did you Alex know that Brooklinen existed? Are they regional? I am in California so maybe that's why I have never heard of them?

  • 10 years ago

    I was the complete victim of targeted online advertising for Brooklinen. I had been discussing sheets and bed linens on this forum for some time so I began to get ads in my Facebook feed. I checked out the website, read independent online reviews, asked advice here, and decided to try a purchase.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I went to Parsons. I found out about Sferra in my textiles class. Don't recall who heard about the warehouse sale but it was being discussed in class and the teacher, like freaked out, and said Sferra sheets were the best on the market. He actually went with me to that first sale.

    There were no carts. They gave you a huge plastic bag when you walked in. You throw stuff in the bag and drag it around. I got one so full I had to stash it under a table and get another one.

    We have a down comforter/duvet for most of the year. For summer we have same issue you described, Alex. It's humid. I take off the duvet and put on a cotton blankets and a matelasse blanket cover I also got a Sferra.

    But if I didn't have those I would get one of the plainer cotton filled quilts from Pottery Barn. I have two of them in our guest bedroom. They are very sturdy, reasonably priced and attractive. They work with most styles except for very modern. Several colors. Here are links:

    http://www.potterybarn.com/products/belgian-linen-floral-stitch-quilt-and-shams/?pkey=cquilts-shams&&cquilts-shams

    http://www.potterybarn.com/products/pick-stitch-quilt-sham/?pkey=cquilts-shams&&cquilts-shams

    @practigal - Sferra is a high-end national brand. It's as well known as Schweitzer, Frette, Porthault and others. Sferra is definitely sold in California.

    Brooklinen has been marketing very heavily online with ads that appear when you search for bed linens.

    Another very good source is perfectlinens. I have set of their sateen Second Skin sheets. Not inexpensive but embroidered and lovely quality if you love sateen. I prefer percale but I also have sateen because I didn't know the difference when I was grabbing stuff at the warehouse sale. I found out much later. I actually llike the Second Skin sheets better than any of the sateen from Sferra which are much more expensive.

    http://perfectlinens.com/collections/soft-sheets/products/softest-cotton-sateen-sheet-2nd-skin?variant=&variant=1595126275&variant=1595126275&variant=1595126275

    Alex Chicago thanked rococogurl
  • 10 years ago

    Interesting. I bought two sets of sheets of the same size and brand at Macy's several years ago and used them equally a week at a time, one set is still beautiful but the other set literally shredded where the fabric was folded over at all of the edges and has gone to the great rag pile in the garage.... I really don't understand why one set has lasted so much better than the other and I wish I could understand that before buying another set because they are so expensive.

  • 10 years ago

    Roc Thank You for all the good info and sites to check out. I will be looking for 3 new twin size sets of Percales sometime this summer and will give the Sferra consideration. Do you know if Sferra sends out sample fabric pieces to feel? I will be looking for all white Percale but one set I would like to have white embroiderered.... white on white, not only am I limited because of size but also the white on white. I need new duvet covers also, but if I can find top sheets that I like on the cheap I'll make the boys. So iI'll probably check out Ikea for these.

    Thank You Roc for sharing your dirty little secret lol.

  • 10 years ago

    Sferra doesn't send out samples. And I doubt that even their sample sales online now are affordable. I do get their emails so I will forward or post them.

    Even worse they have many different lines so it's important to know what you're dealing with. Best bet is to watch ebay IMO.

    Percale is a premium because it's way more difficult to cheat it.

    @practigal - The shredding was explained on a thread where mamapinky posted a photo of the shredded Target Threshhold sheet. It's a manufacturing defect.

  • 10 years ago

    One more thing. I just got the new Cuddledown catalog today. I want to mention them because I've had their pillows and duvet for years. I've also been in their store in Maine. Plus, when my 20 year old duvet needed to be refilled with down, I was able to send it to them and they made the repair reasonably.

    So that's all to say that I have done business with them for a long time and I trust them. I also just bought a new bed pad from them and it's outstanding. Was very expensive but it has made a difference and should give me many years of service.

    Just noticed they have 350 thread count percale sheets with some special pricing. On the same page there are cotton waffle weave blankets.

    They have sales and I if I needed something I would watch for those and try to take advantage as I did on the bed pad.

  • 10 years ago

    Thank You Roc, you do give excellent advice and your appricated.

    Used to be buying sheets was easy, the most difficult thing was deciding on the color/print. Today its probably the most difficult textile to choose.

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks for all those links, Roc. I really like the Hatteras Cotton Weave from Cuddletown. I have a feeling one of those will be on order before the really warm weather arrives. The reviews say they shrink easily so I might buy a king for my queen bed.

  • 10 years ago

    Great review Alex. It made me want to take a look, but after reading about all the ads after just one view, I decided to refrain. I, too, sleep very hot, and I bought linen sheets a year ago. I have used them last winter, last summer and this winter so far. They are cool all year round, but warm when I need it. I don't sweat with them - ever. They were expensive. Right now I only have one set and I wash them and put them back on the bed. I bought the linen duvet this past Christmas and love that too.

    Alex Chicago thanked Debbi Branka
  • 10 years ago

    Debbi is it vintage linen sheets? Oh and a linen duvet cover, I bet that's lovely.

  • 10 years ago

    No mama, they are new linen sheets. I buy from Rough Linen.

  • 10 years ago

    Debbi..thank you for the link...these look beautiful. If I disappear you will know hubs killed me for ordering...oh they look so comfy.

  • 10 years ago

    Very nice looking products there. I especially like on the "Care" page the proprietor says it's just fine to boil wash linen. So tired of seeing fabric care that says "cold wash only." Blah!

  • 10 years ago

    Horrible experience. Ordered 2 sheet sets as gifts but the only sent the fitted sheets and pillow cases. Tried calling the company many times. Had to leave voicemails and no one ever returned my repeated calls. Will never buy from this company again nor will I recommend

  • 10 years ago

    dakotae,

    Company name?