I like them both, honestly, so I'd say, if you want to use the extra $$ for something else, go with the less expensive ones.

Can't really see much of a difference. Note the sticker that says available in Value Pack..not sure if you need that many. We purchased the value pack of containing 10 or 12 and there is quite a large discount in purchasing this way.

I voted for the look of #2, but make sure you like the feel -- one of those looks like it's rounded in the back and the other flat. My family, for instance, hates sharp edges on pulls.

Maureen, the total price calculates the value pack. I need 24 pulls and the value pack has 10 so $46.88 ends up being the total cheapest cost.

When I found the value pack and got the handles I had been dreaming of, I was thrilled. That's great.

I would go with 2 not just because of the price. I like the shape better. The others are too square.

What about something like this?

http://www.lowes.com/pd_501895-81227-P0270AZ-SN-C_2z8vi__?productId=50019910&pl=1&Ntt=arched+pulls

I've used a similar one in the 5-inch length many times.

Brag pics · More Info

I voted for the $46.88 set of pulls. Use the money you save for something else that you may need.

I ended up going with [these[(https://www.houzz.com/products/hickory-p3591-sn-3-cc-kite-cabinet-pull-satin-nickel-prvw-vr~23169723)

Hickory P3591-SN 3" cc Kite Cabinet Pull - Satin Nickel · More Info

They cost somewhere in the middle of the two I found and I like the design better. Thank you all for your great feedback!

Those are also very nice! Great choice.

Very sleek I like them. Congrats.