If you could post a photo? If ceilings, walls, floors, and cabinets are all wood, I vote no. But if other surfaces break up the wood, like painted cabinets, tile floor, Sheetrock on interior walls, etc. I think they would look pretty. Really need more info. I have soapstone in my log home kitchen.

Yours look really nice. Actually, I'm less interested in appearance than I am functionality and durability. I'd like to hear from someone who has had wood counters for a while. We do a lot of cooking and have lots of experience with butcher block, but not as counter tops. The place needs a lot of work and we're on a budget. It has unattractive beige patterned linoleum flooring and the original wood cabinets that have darkened with age which we like. It's also very small--I'm sorry I don't have photos immediately available.

Laminate is a great choice. A basic one is not expensive. Less than butcher block, that's for sure.

In mine I actually did granite but used an old fireplace mantle to act as a transition on the breakfast bar separating the kitchen and the main family room. It ties in the old and the new real well. Another idea would be a soapstone countertop. That would work well also! Good luck! You can check out pics in my ideabooks.

Good wood counters will last forever. They are easy to clean and care for. IF they are unfinished, you should oil with mineral oil once a quarter or so. If they are finished, no maintenance at all.

Thank you Victor and auntthelma. I really like the idea of wood countertops and I'm glad to note that you endorse them, AT. We're a family that spends most of our time in the kitchen and the feel and look of well-used wood appeals to us.