Software
Houzz Logo Print
daethon

Choosing a Sink for the Kitchen...

10 years ago

So we are fully redoing our kitchen. Likely putting in a light gray cabinet, "Super White" Quartzite (which has a lot of white/gray), stainless appliances, and a big ole hood for the viking rangetop. Because of the layout of the kitchen we are moving the sink to an island which will have the same countertop but darker navy blue cabinets "split level" to create a small backsplash behind the sink and allow for more "bar height" seating.

Outside of nailing down the exact color of the cabinets we only really have two outstanding questions: What about the sink and faucet.

We really like Apron front sinks. My wife really wants stainless. We had a Kohler vault most recently but it would make a loud "pop" whenever boiling water (e.g. pasta) was dumped into it, it scratched almost instantly (we won't use a grill at the bottom) and the edges were so sharp that the corners were always disgusting looking.

Because of the above issues I really want cast iron or fireclay, but I've really never had either of those.

There don't seem to be a ton of options for Apron Front Stainless sinks (Kohler, Elkay, DXV, Franke) but even those, I have no idea if they'll be better than the Vault was.

So on the sink we really have three questions:

1) From a durability standpoint, is one material "universally" better than the other?

2) There's a lot of gray in the room, a lot of stainless, would it make sense to break up the space with a white sink (The sink will be right next to a stainless dishwasher (wife wants painted cabinets, so putting a panel unit in isn't going to work).

3) If stainless: Which MFG/Model did you guys go with? Does it have the "pop/buckling" issue? Does it have "sloped" corners for easier "getting food into the hole?"

Comments (8)

  • 10 years ago

    Why won't a panel unit work on the DW if you use painted cabinets? What am I missing?

  • 10 years ago

    Ditto on the paneled dw question!

    I had an Elkay stainless apron sink in my last house and did not have any issues with popping sounds -- and I cook a ton of pasta! I didn't use a grid either, and don't recall it scratching much, but I made a decision that I'd rather have scratches than a grid. I think if you're determinedly anti-grid, you may have to accept some scratching. After a while they blend together.


    In my current house I have a Kohler enameled cast iron sink and I really don't like it. It doesn't scratch so much as scuff -- every time we wash pots and pans. The scuffs come off with soft scrub, but that's an extra step I don't appreciate. To me, it only looks good when freshly scrubbed -- otherwise it shows so much dirt, even when rinsed or wiped with a sponge. It is 16 years old so maybe the surface has become porous.


  • 10 years ago

    On the DW: all the steam tends to interact poorly with painted cabinets leading to damage to the paint.

    at least that's what our cabinet and appliance guys said.

    thanks for the insight on the scuffing, I had not heard/thought of that. I'd rather deal with scratches than with unsightliness!

  • 10 years ago

    Painted paneled dishwashers are fine. They're at least as durable as stained paneled dishwashers! I wouldn't want a stainless apron front next to a stainless DW but I'd be rethinking the paneled DW before rethinking the apron.

    (Maybe your cabinet person is unfamiliar with the newer European-style DWs that don't have the heated dry?)

  • 10 years ago

    Blanco now offers an apron silgranit sink that wasn't available when I remodeled my kitchen. It's available in white, cafe brown and the Anthracite as shown in the picture below. I have a regular undermount silgranit sink in metallic gray and love it.

  • 10 years ago

    I will get a Silgranit type sink. Original sink was a cast iron/porcelain coated Kohler, and like Amy above, it always showed every scuff and required occasional scrub with Softscrub and/or pumice to make it white again. It would look dingy with build up. Currently have integrated Corian which is not bad, easy to clean for the most part. Looking forward to remodel with a Silgranit.

  • 10 years ago

    @DIY: I agree with you on the styling. I think it'd look a lot cleaner that way. Maybe I'll ask about that when looking at the dishwashers next. We were going to do a Bosch 800 for it, but if I could get a cleaner look for a couple hundred extra and get a better DW...might be worth it. Thanks for the feedback on the Kraus!


    @yeh: silgranit: sounds like a great option, seems very durable, and we had one in our last laundry room...is there not a concern on resale value with it? Are they becoming more "in?" It's not a big deal, since we will be here at least 4 years (hopefully much much longer, but schools are lottery based here).

Sponsored
Miller Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars23 Reviews
Franklin County's Trusted Custom Cabinetry Solutions