Software
Houzz Logo Print
rosemint

Which bid sounds the best?

10 years ago

I've narrowed my choices down to four bids. This is for A/C only, to go with my existing Lennox furnace.

My home is 1814 sq. ft, single story, in Los
Angeles' San Fernando Valley. Poorly insulated, house built in 1948. All single-pane windows. The ceilings appear to be 8-1/4 feet high. Thanks so
much for your comments!!!


1) Install Day & Night 3.5 ton 14 seer
model NX4A series a/c condensing unit on side of house.
Install Aspen Manufacturing 4 ton high
efficiency a/c coil on existing furnace in attic.
Install secondary drain pan under a/c coil on
attic.
Install Aprilaire model 2410 high efficiency
air cleaner on furnace.
Run copper refrigerant lines from a/c coil in
attic to a/c unit on side of house.
Run primary and secondary condensation drain
lines in copper.
Run 220 volt 30 amp circuit from main
electrical panel to a/c condensing unit. provide fusible disconnect.
Will connect existing duct work to a/c coil.
Will strap up all ducting.
Will raise furnace higher for proper draining
of a/c/ coil.
Provide mechanical and electrical permits from
the City of Los Angeles.
Provide certified HERS rater to perform duct
test and refrigerant charge verification.
Install extension on electrical junction box
in attic and install cover.
Labor warranty will be for 3 years.

$6950 includes permit and $325 HERS.

2) All work to be performed in a clean and
orderly fashion. EQUIPMENT: Bryant 14 SEER condensing unit M # 105ANA High
efficient evaporator coil with TXV·
Perform start up and run testing of new equipment. · Install a liquid line filter drier
and evacuate lines. ·
Run new copper refrigerant line set. ·
Run new 230-volt electrical circuit with disconnect to new condensing unit. · Install new condensing unit on the
side of the house. ·
Insulate existing return air plenum as necessary. · Run new ¾-inch copper primary and
secondary condensate drain lines. ·
Install an overflow safety switch. ·
Install a secondary drain pan. ·
Connect existing supply ducting to the new evap. coil and seal joints with
mastic. ·
Raise furnace 4-inches to obtain the required slope of new condensate drain
lines. ·2)
Install new plenum coil on the existing furnace.
1 year labor warranty.

$6610 plus $450 permit and HERS test

3) New 4-ton matching R-410 horizontal
evaporator coil; 14 seer Lennox 14ACX-048; 10 yr parts and compressor
Provide 7/8” copper line set
Provide secondary condensate drain pan under
evaporator coil
Provide necessary electric from existing
electrical panel
Provide all necessary low voltage control
wiring and condensate drain line
Start up new system and adjust for proper
operation
2 year labor warranty

$5376 not including permit or HERS test


4) Condenser Lennox 14ACX-048 Cooling coil 4
ton

Condensate drain hook up; primary, and safety
pan; connect to existing vent pipe
New supply plenum
Inspect all accessible ducts and do minor
sealing if needed
Connect (ducts) to the existing supply and
return air system
New insulated electric circuit with disconnect
switch box, circuit breaker and weatherproof conduit and connectors at
condensing unit and/or furnace
Connect to existing electrical supply
Install electrical switch box
All required pads and platforms
Install safety shutoff switch to prevent water
damage
Install high efficiency air cleaner Merv 8 if
possible
10 year for AC, 10 year for compressor, 5 year
for materials, 1 year labor

$6652 [includes HERS test and permit]


The first bid is from a small company with
only one
review on Angie's List (grade: B), and one
review on Yelp.
It was highly recommended by three neighbors
on
a local online board.

None of them did a
load calc. The first company didn't even come inside the
house. The
second company was the only one who seemed to
take thorough measurements of my home's interior. They all went into my attic to see my ducts
and furnace.

Are we allowed to post websites of companies
here?

Thank you so much for your help!

Comments (9)

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    In my opinion the best way to choose is which ever company makes you feel the most comfortable and the equipment they offer (the features of the equipment suit your needs.)

    If you've never used any of these companies before there is a gamble involved. The thing you have to realize is that no equipment is perfect, they all break sooner or later and the company you choose is most likely who you will rely on to fix the system when it breaks.

    The number of reviews one company gets versus another is not always a red flag, unless those reviews are all negative. People rarely post positive reviews, even when prodded. Most people only post reviews when they have nothing but problems or they feel cheated one way or the other.

    A lot of this falls on the company you use. I've had situations just recently where a repair was made to a system some problems again developed when I was contacted I went back out to check it promptly. Not more than a day later after that repair another problem developed. I dropped everything to go back out there and fix it yet again. (this was a retro fit repair, replacing just one piece of a system)

    This business is a service business. Without service not to mention technical expertise the road is fraught with hazards.

    Now imagine what would have happened if I blew this customer off above?

  • 10 years ago

    Thank you, Austin Air Companie! I'm not sure how to gauge how responsive any of them will be if a problem develops down the road. Looking at the bids, do you see any red flags as far as their installation expertise?

  • 10 years ago

    "The first company didn't even come inside the house."

    That's a red flag for me. You can take this guy off the list.

    "The second company was the only one who seemed to take thorough measurements of my home's interior. "

    He didn't do a load calculation, but at least he took the time to measure the house. I like some of the details he listed in the proposal about the overflow safety switch and raising the furnace so the condensate drains properly. It tells me he looked at the installation carefully and thought about it. I like quote no. 2 the best.

    What are the model numbers of the Bryant condenser and coil in the second quote? What furnace do you currently have?

    Does the San Fernando valley have higher summer temperatures than Los Angeles? A 4 ton condenser seems too big, but it is an old house with poor insulation. It would be good if you could do a load calculation.

  • 10 years ago

    "Does the San Fernando valley have higher summer temperatures than Los Angeles? "


    Very much so, to the tune of easily 10-15 degrees hotter on a summer day than coastal areas.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Thanks, Mike and Snidely Whiplash. I'll have to ask for the model number! I didn't notice that. I'm in Studio City, which is cooler than parts of the valley. Are either of you thinking 4 ton might be better? My furnace is a Lennox Model G50UH-48B-090X.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Rosemint,

    without using the service department of any of these companies it is hard to know exactly. Most companies use salesmen to give bids on new equipment, some times these salesmen may have been technicians at one point in their career but not always.

    It's the little things sometimes that stand out. Did they show up on time for the bid? Did they look at the whole job? Do they address areas of concern... concern you had for what is important to you and maybe address areas you hadn't thought of.

    If you have a company that has your interests at heart instead of their own, take pride in their work as well as treating their customer as a customer instead of "just another ac quote".

    Let that be your guide. It's not fool proof, but you have to start somewhere.

  • 10 years ago

    IMO if they are not doing a load calc send them home ! find another contractor who will not guess at sizing an do a through load calc. I say this as a homeowner

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    But I've had more estimates than I want to admit...and none of them did a load calc. I asked company #3 (above) about it, and he said other companies can impress you by doing it with a fancy computer program...but whether he does that or not, he's always come up with the same size.

    And with the first three companies (above), the people who do the work were the ones who came out. And I know it's bad that the first guy didn't look inside my house...but he really impressed me as being knowlegable, and I like the fact that he gives a 3-year labor warranty, and a free air filter...

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    so he guessing based on experience that your existing system is the right size for your home SMH. Good luck ! wish you the best