First decide which color family you like the best, otherwise too many options. Are you staying in the warm/yellow family?

We were thinking grays or green for a much needed change.

You also need to take in consideration the color of brick on the chimney and your roof color. When I was choosing colors for my house out of the limitless amount of paint colors that are our there (I feel your pain), I put into consideration the three things on my house that would not change: stone color since I have stone around my entryway exterior; the red brick chimney; and the green roof. If you just choose any color you want without thinking about these things, you may end up with a house you are not happy with! My other advice before painting the house--buy samples of the colors that you choose. It will save you a lot of time and expense!

Lori--With the red brick on your chimney and what looks like a brown roof, I would stay away from gray and go with green! Sage green, or something in that color family, would look awesome! Here is a color (I love this shade of green) that I found on Houzz that I think would look great on your house:

Front Exterior · More Info

Hi Bev, I like the photo you submitted. We are considering Benjamin Moore Nantucket Gray that is actually a green or Copley Gray that is also more green than gray but may be a bit dark. Yes I agree with coordinating the paint with roof shingles and front steps. We are also changing the door color as it is currently painted with a gel stain to give the illusion that it is a wooden door. The gel stain is so hard to maintain so we're going to paint it instead.

It sounds like you already have it worked out! Good luck and I'm sure it will look great when the painting is done.