I think a warm beige would look best. I would suggest painting the garage door the same color so it's not a focal point. I think the current garage door color is close but somewhat clashing with the roof.

Hi I just went through this trying to do exterior redo. I found Kevin strader at creative visual concepts under houzz pro. He made a mock up of my house so I could actually see it. He is very talented and resonable starts at $25. I found it well worth it! unfortunately you already see how costly it can be. Here are my before and afters

Before

I could see adding some stone on front post

I remember your house Jerri, have you found a contractor?

Srajapal are you at the beach? That makes a difference I think. Will you have landscaping and typical greenery? Is the roof brown or red?

Don't discount a white villa. Here are some examples. The mint really looks terrible. Just not appropriate for a Spanish style home

I would suggest you paint the body of the house and the garage door a soft white because white will brighten the space and contrast from the brown roof color. For a tone-on-tone effect, choose a bright white for the trim. Then you can use colorful plants in black pots and other landscaping to bring color into the space.