Software
Houzz Logo Print
kyle418

Type of Oak?

10 years ago

Thanks in advance

Comments (13)

  • 10 years ago

    Could be black oak, Quercus velutina.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Pics of full tree and trunk bark would help , but w/the limited info, I agree w/kentrees that it looks like black oak. Definitely not northern red oak.

  • 10 years ago

    Kyle, if there is a slight hairiness under the leaves, and the top of the leaves seem leathery and shiney, it is likely a Q. Velutina Black oak. If Duller on top, and not any fine vellous hairs under the leaves, likely Red oak, Q. Rubra. I'm not too good about ID's, but, it is probably not Scarlet oak, Cherrybark oak. But, I personally can't exclude them from your picture. I doubt it is Pin oak, but, p[ersonally can't say it isn't, I think they have deeper lobes, though. I would THINK 1st that it's Q. Velutina.

  • 10 years ago

    It just may be a Scarlet oak, I know I'm not much help, But, My post here should bump this question to the front of the forum.

  • 10 years ago

    poaky, that is not N red oak. Neither leaves or acorns match it.

  • 10 years ago

    beng - are you sure it isn't N red oak? N red oak leaves are somewhat variable, and some trees around here have leaves very much like those in the photo.

  • 10 years ago

    Yup, I'm sure, at least. Indentations between lobes are too deep for that. Acorns aren't NR oak either. My best guesses are black or scarlet oak. A pic of the trunk bark and/or whole tree from the OP could help.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Beng, Arbor and anyone else, my field guide seems to point to NRed oak. The fact that the acorns are under developed is a bit of a problem, but, unless that acorn cap changes to cover more of the acorn in maturity, it is N Red oak. If it were velutina it would be shinier and the acorn caps would be more bowl shaped than just barely covering the end of the acorn end. I used my field guide and haven't drank much yet, so I just may be right! Now, if you go on Google maybe they will show a different looking leaf and acorn cap, but, my Petersons field guide says NRO. I'm glad to see that some red oaks are forming acorns now.

  • 10 years ago

    We need the Daxman on the case here.

  • 10 years ago

    Unfortunately Daxman has an injured pup, his little lady Daisy has gotten injured due to some vehicles that didn't make way for the "hairy family members" of people in his area. Unfortunately. this happens all the time. many years ago, when my brother was in grade school, he loved a little terrier type dog"Blackie", and my brothers dog got injured too. lets all wish Daisy a speedy recovery. Good luck to Daxman and Daisy.

  • 10 years ago

    Well, sorry Beng and Kentrees, that tree above is indeed Q.Rubra or a hybrid of Q.Rubra and Q.Velutina. Scarlet oak has much more bristles than Rubra and Velutina. I have collected acorns of Q.Rubra and a possible hybrid of Q.Rubra and Q. VElutina. But, you be the judge if they are hybrid acorns, I frankly do not know for sure. I could send them to someone. The parent trees are on a hillside and are Q,Rubra and Q. Velutina and MAYBE some Scarlet oak.

  • 10 years ago

    Well Kyle anyways, if you aren't sure what type of oak you have, what is the need to know what type of oak you have?

  • 10 years ago

    Boy these were sure some stupid posts I made. I was drunk on the last few, sorry, I hope you already got your answer Kyle, the acorns are likely ripe now, unless they were first year acorns. I learned this year that Velutina acorns are alot smaller in width than Rubras, and the caps are alot more bowlshaped in Velutinas than Rubras. Sorry for the bullshit above just ignore it, as you have.