Thank you!

Agree with that, or a loden green could be nice, or a steely blue...

Go white, or go vermillion. You need a more orangey red to better co-ordinate with the stone. Treat the door, sidelights, and moulding as a unit for a more dramatic look. Leave the shutters as they are.

You might even carry the colour up to the wall above the porch roof. The current stone/stucco arrangement in that central area looks a little jigsaw puzzleish.

Thanks for your feedback. So what color would you recommend for the door and carrying it up above? I'm thinking red, blue or green wouldn't be appropriate. Thanks

I would paint the door and sidelights the same color. Black looks great against a stone facade.

I don't understand "carrying it up above" -- all there really is is the window frame, and I think you want those consistent. Anyway, here are some doors...

And consider painting the entry light fixtures black to stand out against the stonework.

Black would be great!

Thanks so much for all the helpful feedback and photos. I am visual so that really helps! I agree, not sure what it means to "carry the color up" but welcome input. Your feedback has been really helpful and has helped me see things from a different perspective. Thanks!

I think a very deep wine color, bordeaux, to be more precise. From a distance, it looks almost black. In my opinion it would look incredible. Yes, paint the light fixtures black. Good Luck

I would select the matching color from the shutters for the front door, however, the wall color needs an adjustment. It's too peach. A color closer to the stone would enhance the appearance. Also the shrubs need a major pruning.

Black looks really nice, agree to also paint your lights black

Thank you Beverly. Yes, I agree. The landscaping needs more than a pruning. We also would like to repaint the stucco. Unfortunately these projects aren't in our current budget. I'm trying to make an improvement now which would have a positive impact on the exterior without being too costly. In the future, I will be interested in landscape ideas and stucco paint color for the exterior. Thanks!

After looking at the photo mock-ups above, I would suggest white for door and side windows. A lighter shade will make it look more welcoming.

I think "carrying the color up" may refer to that white framed window above the door or the area around it. Perhaps if that window had brown shutters and the little trim around your sidelights were brown it would pull the top and bottom together. Then whatever color your choose for your door and those side panels--and prior suggestions were nice--would work.

I like the look of the black door

I think a brighter red than you have now would look great!