Software
Houzz Logo Print
greekshambo

Listeria questions

10 years ago

I'm confused about the safety of refrigerator pickles. In the thread about Ziedrich's "Dutch Lunch Spears" a link is given to the recipe. It states, "Store the jar in the refrigerator for a least 1 week before eating the pickles. Refrigerated, they will keep for several months, at least."

However, I did a search on the NCHFP website regarding listeria and refrigerator pickles and pulled up a 2004 abstract that concluded with the section quoted below. It sounds like refrigerator pickles are no longer recommended.

So, what's the story? Is Ziedrich's recipe still approved? Or is the NCHFP telling us to avoid refrigerator pickles due to listeria? Is there more up-to-date information about listeria and refrigerator pickles? I couldn't find anything else on the NCHFP site. Nor could I find refrigerator pickle recipes there or at the Ball site. Thanks for clarifying this for me.

CONCLUSION

  • Based on old recommendations, consumption of refrigerator dill pickles could typically occur anytime after 3 days of refrigerated storage
  • Since L. monocytogenes may still be viable well after this point, there is a food safety risk involved
  • Recommendations to prepare this product in the home should not be distributed

Comments (9)

  • 10 years ago

    Yikes! I made my grandmother's refrigerator dill pickle recipe last year! I kept them in the fridge but ate them up within 3 months. I guess I will toss out Granny's recipe.

    Whatever happened to the commercial refrigerator pickles like Clausen's? Are they still made and sold?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    A little misunderstanding here and it comes from a too broad application of the term "refrigerator pickles" - a common mistake. It is the difference between fermented pickles and brined pickles.

    Please note that the abstract you are referring to applies to fermented pickles - pickles that are fermented in a low salt brine at room temperature for one week and then placed in the fridge. This was quite common in many old recipes and were called "refrigerator pickles". That is what is no longer recommended, those old family recipes called refrigerator pickles simply because they were not processed in any way. People used to just fill the jars, leave them sitting out on the counter or in the spring house or cellar, and every 1-2 days add a bit more brine to the mix.

    Newer recipes for making fermented pickles call for a higher salt content than formerly used and that higher salt content is from Day 1 rather than gradually increased as many of the old recipes called for AND for immediate refrigeration.

    Modern "refrigerator pickle" recipes - like Zeidrich's Dutch Lunch Spears - are not fermented pickles. They call for no room temperature fermentation, only brine and only in the fridge, and contain higher amounts of salt PLUS vinegar.

    So does that mean all old family recipes are unsafe? Not necessarily but each must be evaluated on its specific ingredients and some changes may be necessary. Does this mean that modern brined pickles can be stored indefinitely in the fridge? No, they have a recommended shelf life in the fridge of approx. 3 months. Do the modern recipes mean no threat of listeria? Yes, if they are processed and never opened. Once opened even processed pickles can develop listeria which is why they have a limited storage life but it develops at a much slower rate

    Hope this clarifies rather than adds to the confusion.

    Dave

    Edited to add link to the abstract in question: http://nchfp.uga.edu/papers/2004/04ift-picklesabstract.pdf

  • 10 years ago

    Dave, thanks. I wondered about the short fermentation period before sticking them in the fridge. I've also often wondered about claims of making a year's worth of refrigerator pickles. Probably not a good idea.

    OK, another related question. In a true refrigerator pickle, just brine & into the fridge, can the salt content be reduced? Or is a certain level necessary for safety's sake?

    Thanks for your help. I've got more questions but on a different topic. Will post a separate thread.

  • 10 years ago

    " In a true refrigerator pickle, just brine & into the fridge, can the salt content be reduced?"

    Yes, it is primarily a flavoring ingredient in brined pickles. But it will make a noticeable difference in the flavor.

    It helps eliminate the confusion if you drop the "refrigerator pickle" term and think of pickles as either brined, quick pack processed, or fermented as all of them end up in the refrigerator sooner or later. ;-)

    Dave

  • 10 years ago

    Thanks again. OK, will drop the "refrigerator pickle" term.

  • 10 years ago

    Dave, I wanted to let you know that I ordered the 2016 "All New Ball Book of Canning and Preserving" and received it a couple of hours ago. I'm happy to report that there's a great section on "Refrigerator Pickles in 4 Easy Steps." It gives the steps for four basic flavoring recipes for a variety of vegetables: Spicy Dill; Mediterranean; Mexican; & Szechuan. The section also includes 3 other more specific recipes for fridge pickles. So that pretty much takes care of all my questions. Thanks for your help.

  • 10 years ago

    Yeah, I have it. As we have discussed here in the past this particular edition is from Jarden-Bernardin Canada rather than Ball USA so uses some different terminology in some of its recipes and instructions.

    Just as Ball has always had the Ball Blue Book, Bernardin has always published their similar edition called the Bernardin Guide to Home Preserving. Jarden is the parent company of both Ball in the US and Bernardin in Canada.

    Either book is fine to use, just a bit different, although some have reported quite a few new recipes in the Canadian edition.

    Dave

  • 10 years ago

    My son is a microbiologist and has a food safety testing lab. I work there 1-2 days a week, so I have learned some things about food pathogens. Listeria loves to grow in cool refrigerated conditions. Weird, isn't it?