I'm not an expert, but it looks to me like the spacing in the upper rail is a bit wide, like it might not pass inspection. Isn't the rule something like max space of less than 4 inches, so kids don't get their head stuck?

I like the one on the second floor, but it may not meet code if that is an issue where you live. Here's the railing is you add additional rails.

No railing can have an opening a 4" sphere (baby head) can pass through.

The plainer detailing on the first floor is likely what the house was born with.

Hmmm. Perhaps, but I suspect it varies significantly by state. It's quite interesting what a difference in building codes there are between a highly regulated, restrictive state like, say, California, and a more libertarian state like South Carolina. Different strokes for different folks...

I think the 4" rule is in the national building code and has been for awhile. Some jurisdictions are more lax about applying it.

Haha, you may be exactly correct about the "lax" part...kind of like how certain federal laws are enforced or not depending on where you live.

I prefer the ground level railing, looks more period appropriate. Now, for your second question, " needs work....," what exactly are you interesting in doing?

I like it the way it is...it looks correct

http://dennisvillefence.com/wp-content/uploads/chippendale-vinyl-railing-from-dennisville-fence-01.jpg

A little trip to your local historical center with a picture of your house, could help you see what original designs were like when this house was built. Your local patterns are what I would look for then adopt to current codes as appropriate. It reminds me of shot gun houses in New Orleans.

Use the railings to add to the charm of the porches. The rest of the facade is plain and more intricate metal or woodwork for the porches would give you great curb appeal. Play up the columns with bright white paint - they are a nice feature.

This home is located in an Historical District. I am not yet familiar with all the rules but I know if anything on the exterior gets changed it has to be approved except paint. As much as I like the idea of the Chippendale-ish rails on the second story they do look out of place. I LOVE the photo that kjbjw sent of the duel railings but that house can handle it with the larger proportions. I think the first step will be painting the door Black until I can replace it with the glass style it was born with. STill love hearing ideas from fellow Houzzers!

Mathew Hallet I love your work!

Tracy. If you are going to paint the front door, why black? That house next door is turquoise. So i would be a bit more daring, especially since it looks like an interior door and probably really needs to be replaced. Just cleaning up yard (maybe you aren't in yet?) would be good. Lots to do here as i am sure you know. Good luck.

No, we are not in yet and it was a rental up until now which should explain the condition the house is in. I was thinking of blue as well however I tend to like muddier colors than turquoise. This is really my sons first house and we will be helping fix it up and staying there for a while.

That's what I figured. This is quite a project. Hope your son is rolling his sleeves up too! How about a purple door! Son's favorite color?

Bayard Blue from Benjamin Moore is a favorite of mine. It has charcoal undertones. Great for accent, but not bright.

Dalton Blue, Pinecrest Gray, Bayard Blue.

Son likes the blue on the right!

I love that blue too. Go with son! The more "ownership" he has the happier all will be! Good luck!

Bayard Blue - I've used it and it's gorgeous. Lots of depth.

Done door yet? M

I like the Chippendale railing on the second floor and would add rails to it to meet the Code.