Software
Houzz Logo Print
parker25mv

Mangosteen may not be a true species

10 years ago
last modified: 10 years ago

There is some evidence to support a theory that Mangosteen may actually be a result of a cross between two other Garcinia species. This would explain the unusual fact that Mangosteen seeds appear only to result from asexual means.

http://www.mangosteen.com/Sciencenonscienceandnonsense.htm

Mangosteen is very unusual in that it grows true from seed, 100% genetically identical, since the "seeds" are actually adventitious embryos (or hypocotyl tubercles). The species Mangosteen is olbligate agamospermous (seeds only form asexually). However, all other Garcinia species only propagate seed via sexual reproduction (having separate male and female flowers on the same plant).

You might be inclined to think therefore that all Mangosteen trees in existence would be genetically identical, but this was found not to be true. A genetic study showed that some mangosteen lineages had a small amount of genetic variation, while a small number had as much as a 22-31% variation. This suggests that the original mangosteen lineage could have been crossbred at some point with another Garcinia species, possibly resulting in hybrid lineages capable or sexual reproduction (that have now been lost) that could then have been repeatedly backcrossed with mangosteen.

Mangosteen fruit has been cultivated for at least 500 years, perhaps several thousand years, in what is today Indonesia. There is one theory that the fruit might actually have first been domesticated in Thailand, although it was not native to this range.

(I will also point out that a similar situation exists for the rare Wood's Cycad, Encephalartos woodii, in which there are no surviving females of the species, although some speculate this could be evidence that Wood's Cycad might have just been a localized natural hybrid between E. natalensis and E. ferox, as it is naturally possible for the cycad to propagate clonally through offshoots)

Comments (4)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    If the hybrid species theory has any validity, one thought is that Mangosteen may have descended from Garcinia globulosa (which appears very similar to G. atroviridis). Asam kandis is common and sometimes cultivated in Malaysia and Indonesia. It bears grapefruit-size fruits whose sweet pulp is eaten raw.

    The wild mangosteen species Garcinia forbesii, native to Kalimantan, seems to be very closely related to Mangosteen. The rinds are used by locals in cooking to impart sourness to food dishes. The inside of the fruit is not bad, but does not taste as good as mangosteen, slightly bitter and herbal, and more sour.

    Garcinia nigrolineata: Kandis jantan (big kandis) has orange fruits like G. globulosa , but larger and sweeter. The edible fruit is gathered from the wild for its delicious fruits and the species is sometimes used as a rootstock for mangosteen.

    Garcinia hombroniana: Manggis hutan (jungle mangosteen), from Indonesia and Malayasia, is a species bearing fruit with a flavour like a slightly sour peach when it is eaten raw. The exterior of the fruit is a bright red-orange, while the inside is translucently opaque, appearing similar to Mangosteen.



  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    This paper says that Mangosteen was thought to have arisen from two wild species, G. celebica (apparently alternatively known as G. hombroniana ) and G. malaccensis, but that researchers had originally mistook another species (G. penangiana ) for G. malaccensis (not at all uncommon to confuse closely related obscure species in the Garcinia genus) and that now that true G. malaccensis has been identified it has been found to be nearly genetically identical to Mangosteen. Mangosteen highly resembles G. malaccensis and shares a similar taste of ripe fruits.

    This paper speculates that Mangosteen may have come from G. celibica rather than G. hombroniana. G. celibica and G. hombroniana appear extremely similar. It appears they may have been mistaken for the same species, or possibly mistaken for different species.

    I do have to agree that the fruits of Garcinia Malaccensis look the closest to Mangosteen out of any of the wild species.

    To make matters more interesting, there was a report in 1987
    (Idris and Rukayah) of the existence of a male mangosteen tree, about 70 years
    old, growing in the Negeri Sembilan region of peninsular Malaysia. The
    characteristics were similar to those of the female tree but the male flowers were
    smaller than female flowers, and the stamens in the male flower were numerous
    and arranged in a mass, the filaments of the male flowers being much shorter
    than those of the female flowers. Later studies by Richards in 1990 suggested
    that this plant could have been a hybrid between mangosteen and either G.
    malaccensis or G. hombroniana. There can be found mangosteen trees growing wild in the forests of Kemaman, in peninsular Malaysia, though it is unclear whether they were endogenous to this region or escaped into the wild from human cultivation.

  • 10 years ago

    Seedless Mangosteens

    Often some of the fleshy white segments inside the mangosteen rind do not contain seed. These segments tend to be much smaller, but also make for a more enjoyable eating experience. In rare cases a mangosteen fruit may not contain any seed. The best Mangosteen fruits are those with the highest number of stigma lobes, which indicate the highest number of fleshy segments and the fewest seeds. The number of stigma lobes and the number of fleshy segments always match.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I think the rare mangosteen variety "masta" / "mesta" only has 2 to 3 hard seeds, so the fruit is relatively seedless.

    (This is still G. mangostana, same species as regular Purple Mangosteen)

    Here's a picture, as you can see the shape of the mesta variety is a little bit oblong, compared to the regular variety, with a more pointed tip. Fruits are slightly smaller and the exterior rind a little thicker.

    The variety mesta is cultivated in Pahang and Sabah, Malaysia. The fruit in the latter picture was taken from a tree growing in Temerloh.