I went matte black and absolutely love them. They look great but let my cabinets and countertops be the stars.

I went with polished nickel. Matches the faucets. Dover White painted cabinets. Stainless appliances. Love them. Mine were from Martha Stewart at Home Depot. Surprisingly affordable.

Thank you for the opinions . Please keep them coming! Need to make decision in two days!

Love that polished nickel pull! It's such a classic.

Actually the polished nickle hardware I am considering is also from the Martha Stewart collection from Home Depot. Pricing is definitely affordable.

Tough decision. I don't think you can go wrong either way. I'm loving black hardware, so that would be my first choice.

Another classic look for your setup is glass knobs. I don't think they actually make glass knobs anymore, but glass-look.

Oh yes I was thinking of using glass knobs on some of the uppers to mix it up. I just can't figure out if the black hardware elsewhere would be too harsh of a contrast with the white .

I don't think the black hardware goes with the classic quality of your London Sky countertop. It's more classic and sophisticated than the black. I also think black will look dated sooner. And it would also be a big contrast either your white cabinets. Subtle always wins in the end.

polished nickel

Thank you all for your advice! Really helpful, I am going to go with Martha Stewart polished nickle collection.

Im having the same delimina. white cabinets very Mediterranean look, but black counter on island a chrome faucets. I have contemporary polished nickle light fixtures and dont want the hardware to be ghe focus of the room. im leaning towards polished nickel now!