Software
Houzz Logo Print
maxlgreen

to flip/rent. Asbestos siding. Paint or replace v. $? Open up porch?

10 years ago

Comments (9)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    I bought this 100 year old New England house on the cheap to either flip or, failing that, to rent for a while. While structurally sound it requires some improvements cosmetic and otherwise. The house has some nice details, including the slate shingle roof. However, the siding contains asbestos. This is probably not dangerous because it is exterior and not friable (disintegrating) . However, I know it is a turn off to buyers.

    Abatement (removal) is about 7k, and new siding runs between about 12-16K installed depending upon the options. That would eat up about 1/3 of my budget for this house. I'm not interested in covering over it. And I don't think vinyl is a good choice considering the historic nature of the house.

    Recommendations?

    Also, I'm guessing this porch was not enclosed originally. Anyone think I should "unenclose" it? The house would look better but this is New England, so it would cut down on the usability during the many cold months.

  • PRO
    10 years ago

    IMO asbestos siding in good condition poses no hazard I would save the money and let the next guy worry about it I dont think removing and residing would be a good ROI I would join the front and porch entries together for a nice sitting spot and work on the interior where you might get some payback, paint the exterior to bring out some of the really nice features sort of like a painted lady


    Yes, painting asbestos cement siding is not only possible, it is recommended. The reason is that it will prevent deterioration, which may cause some of the asbestosfibres to become friable and get into the air outside the home.

    One match Kenny thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    Remove the asbestos and assess the wood siding beneath, usually 90% is salvageable. Cheaper than residing and may be preferable depending on your market.
    One match Kenny thanked Ellsworth Design Build
  • PRO
    10 years ago

    Paint the siding and spend your money elsewhere. Asbestos siding takes paint beautifully and a good paint job will do wonders for your curb appeal. We did a Sears kit house that has asbestos siding on three sides and the siding wasn't even mentioned as a concern by the buyer.

    It appears to me that you are in an area of low housing values and many of those buyers/renters will value functionality. I would not open up the side porch, even though the windows are of a more recent vintage. From a curb appeal standpoint, I would concentrate my money on replacing the front stoop with a small porch appropriate to the house and a more elaborate paint job on the front facing gable. Drawing the eye toward the primary facade will help the secondary entrance become less notable.

    If you are intending to rent (and make money doing so), you will need to limit your spending to items which add value for renters. While most tenants want good mechanicals, they are more likely to be swayed by updated kitchens and baths, bright lighting, closet organizers and hardwood floors than by boring things like siding. Asbestos siding is great for rental property as it is super durable and easy to paint.

    Without knowing anything about your location, I'm guessing you are hoping to sell in the low 200,000 range. Am I anywhere close to right?

    One match Kenny thanked Linda
  • 10 years ago

    All it needs is paint and landscaping. Keep the covered porch, it is useful.

    Opening the porch and removing the siding are jobs for a homeowner who expects to live there twenty years, not for a flipper. Besides, it looks nice as it is.

    One match Kenny thanked emmarene9
  • 10 years ago

    Powerwash the siding and paint it, something other than white. Keep the enclosed porch, it functions as an "airlock" and will save your interior floors from wet, muddy boots.

    One match Kenny thanked chiflipper
  • 10 years ago

    Thanks to everyone for their input. I think for the sake of an investment I'm swayed by keeping the enclosed porch and painting. I completely agree that removal and "unenclosing" is preferable but not from an ROI perspective. I really appreciate the advice from all.


  • 10 years ago

    It paints well. I think you'll be happy you kept it. Please do a darker/brighter color. I actually like this enclosed porch.