Ivory house with black trim and keep the brick. Classic!

Jeff,

I love the idea of charcoal trim with the cream of the stucco. You could paint the brick charcoal as well or another complimentary color. Unless you're looking to do a larger exterior overhaul, I'd be afraid that faux stone applied to the existing exterior would look a bit cheesy.

Best of luck!

I agree with DBGC; faux stone is not a direction I would go in. I like the brick trim and think charcoal would make a nice accent color.

I like the classic look. Warm off white for the stucco and dark brown for the timbering. Leave the brick as is.

The long downspout should be painted the color of the stucco.

The house is wonderful. If you do not have a speak easy grill you could add one.