Software
Houzz Logo Print
daninthedirt

acorns - green or brown?

Have loads of leaves to compost, and could use some nitrogen. Nut shells are carbon. I know that. But what about nut meat? I've got huge amounts of acorns, and they smash up nicely when I mow my leaves. Is nut meat a carbon or nitrogen source in a compost pile? Amazing how many websites refuse to give a clear answer to that. Nut meat? Eat it, they say! Yeah sure.

Comments (32)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    The nut meats are high in protein and moisture so I'd consider them a green.
    But I wouldn't rely on them to provide the nitrogen necessary to kick
    start a compost pile. If you haven't got enough nitrogen rich material
    on hand then consider using something you can buy like urea, blood meal, or well moistened
    alfalfa pellets.

    Rodney

  • 10 years ago

    I now see that whey, also a protein, is considered a high nitrogen source for compost. In fact, it is protein that is the magic ingredient in "greens" that supplies nitrogen. Clorophyll is a protein, and it makes stuff green. Nitrogen is a key constituent of amino acids, which are what proteins are made of. I've also now read that acorns use up a large fraction of the stored nitrogen in an oak tree and, FWIW, providing nitrogen to an oak tree maximizes acorn production in mast years. Green leaves are about 2% chlorophyll, and acorns are about 6% protein. Now, the acorns also have fats, and that can make the compost smelly, I guess.

  • 10 years ago

    Someone correct me if I'm wrong about plant physiology, but I believe that in leaf senescence, where leaves turn color and die, the chlorophyll breaks down, and many nutrients, including nitrogen, are carted away from the leaves, presumably into the branches.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm no expert by any means but my understanding is like daninthedirt's - that fallen leaves have lost their nutrients which have been reabsorbed by the tree. But if you stripped off green leaves and dried them they would still retain many nutrients. That's why hay is a 'green' but straw is a 'brown'. One is harvested alive and the other is harvested dead.

  • 10 years ago

    Interesting, thanks.. but then that doesn't explain how browns get extra carbon... (isnt carbon a fundamental element abundant in all organic matter?)

  • 10 years ago

    Do 'browns' get 'extra' carbon? As far as I understand it they simply lose Nitrogen so the ratio changes.

  • 10 years ago

    The slightly odd thing about this is that you'd think winter branches would be rich in extra nitrogen. Strip off branches in the winter and compost them?

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    All materials are more rich in carbon than in nitrogen. The "greens" just have a lower C:N ratio. For instance, grass clippings are about 25:1 and wood chips are like 500:1.

    Tree branches would take a long time to break down, as they are more resistant because of the lignin content.

  • 10 years ago

    Yes, I make mushrooms with logs, and if you cut and colonize a green branch it will fruit a lot less than if you do the same with a winter branch. A tree trimming guy who has 10,000 logs and sells to restaurants taught me the whole technique, although the winter/summer effect is generally known. I have not used my chainsaw during the growing season in maybe 8 years. But this preoccupation with nitrogen is slightly misguided. If you bury a brown branch, it will just decay more slowly. Fungi will break it down first, then bacteria will pull nitrogen from the air to break it down completely. so even the brownest of browns will give you nitrogen, just much more slowly. If you have a good nutrient bank you may even prefer the browns, as you have to feed the soil less often.

  • 10 years ago

    There's the master gardener in training ;)

    So, Chris, why do you need browns at all, and not just greens... can you have too much N?

  • 10 years ago

    Haha, I'm sure you know the answer to that.

    Excess nitrogen allows the microbe population to increase rapidly, but too rapidly. This rapid breakdown can cause nitrogen to be lost into the atmosphere in the form of ammonia. If you've ever had too many grass clippings piled up you would experience this. Carbon is needed to give microbes energy for metabolism. They say 30:1 is the best ratio, but obviously it doesn't have to be exact. Always better to have excess carbon than excess nitrogen.

  • 10 years ago

    Actually I didn't know the answer... I really need to get a good book on composting and soil chemistry. I have a lot to learn on the subject, and it is interesting.

  • 10 years ago

    It's extremely interesting. Anything involving the rhizosphere is mind-blowing.

  • 10 years ago

    The Science of Composting This a good read from Cornell.

  • 10 years ago

    Peter (6b SE NY)The
    browns were often recently green. How does the elemental composition
    change? Does it turn to gas? Either way, adding greens to the compost
    won't stay green for very long.


    I sort of got the feeling that some writer invented 'brown' and 'green' to sell an article or a book and did many a disservice. I think one needs to think available nutrients and I feel strongly that one should think colorblind. This color thing gets so silly that coffee is called ''green''. The first UC Davis site I searched did not even have the word ''brown''. Cornell, an old reliable source said good nitrogen sources may often be ''green and moist'' (My emphases.)

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Agreed about the slippery invention of "green" and "brown" as compositional discriminators. But if you pulled green leaves off a tree, and let them dry out, they would neither be green nor moist, but would add plenty of nitrogen to a compost pile. I'm coming to the conclusion that while acorn meat is brown, it's a dandy nitrogen source. Same with coffee grounds.

    Of course, in both cases, what we're talking about is *seeds*. Seeds have protein, and thus are nitrogen sources. Yes, coffee beans are about 1-2% protein, but the protein is left in the grounds when you make coffee. Don't get your MDR of protein by eating coffee beans! Brown seeds of grasses (wheat, etc.) will bring a lot of nitrogen to a pile.

  • 10 years ago

    Re the Cornell "Science of Composting" , you might have better luck getting it at

    http://cwmi.css.cornell.edu/chapter1.pdf

    Not completely sure what it's chapter 1 of, but the cwmi site has a LOAD of info on composting.


  • 10 years ago

    I had not been to the Cornell site for some years. I just noticed they have instructions for composting a dead horse.

  • 10 years ago

    It's better than beating a dead horse ...

  • 10 years ago

    I am all for composting road kill (one possum will service a large winter squash plant for the year) but composting a horse may be above my pay grade.

  • 10 years ago
    last modified: 10 years ago

    Yeah they tell you how to properly compost animal waste. Most sites will tell you not to compost such things, but only because of it attracting unwanted guests. I throw fish and crustacean carcasses in my pile, but I just bury them deep. Sometimes I'll put used coffee grounds on top to mask the smell from animals.

    Diseased plants can be composted too, but there is the obvious risk. If you don't properly compost, and this goes for seeds too, you won't get the pile hot enough to kill them. You would be shocked at how long some weed seeds are viable for and what they can withstand. Some are viable up to 80 years!

  • 10 years ago

    Getting back to "green" versus" "brown", I think the real discriminator is proteins versus carbohydrates. Proteins have nitrogen. Carbs don't. As it turns out, clorophyll is a protein, and it happens to be green. But there are lots of other proteins, like the ones that nuts and seeds (and horses) are rich in, that aren't green.

    FWIW, my acorn-augmented shredded leaf compost pile is running noticeably hotter than my leaves-only pile in previous years. It's over 110F now, and increasing. In previous years, my piles have never quite gone thermophilic. Not exactly scientific, but it is kind of interesting.

  • 10 years ago
    Looks like you answered your own question. Glad to see you got a desired result and that's certainly good to know. Always good to experiment.
  • 10 years ago

    Yes, I was inspired to do some more research. I'm still trying to figure out how urine ages, relative to nitrogen and productive compost. More on that soon, I hope.

  • 10 years ago

    Squirrels are definitely a green so if the old saying 'you are what you eat' is true that would make nuts a green as well.

    I prefer to let the squirrels pick up the acorns and hickory nuts and then harvest the squirrels for the compost pile.

  • 10 years ago

    I'm an urban gardener, and can't kill squirrels. It's against the law. You know, it's that law about protecting cuteness. But I'll scrape 'em off the street.

  • 10 years ago
    I wish I had it in me to kill the little SOBs. Would be nice to use them to amend the soil for the plants that they destroy.

    Just went to turn my pile because I didn't cover it when it rained yesterday. We got about 1.82", which was way more than was expected. When I turned the pile a big plume of steam came out. Goes to show you how much of a difference moisture makes.
  • 9 years ago

    Just an addendum to the business of "greens versus browns"-really-means-"proteins versus carbohydrates", in the context of another nitrogen thread here. Urea, which is the nitrogen containing part of urine, is NOT a protein (and it sure isn't green!) Urea is not built out of chains of amino acids. So urea, which is a fabulous nitrogen fertilizer, has to be considered an exception to the rule. Urea is actually designated in ag chemistry as "non-protein nitrogen" (NPN).

    The idea that non-green things can contain nitrogen, and can contribute to minimizing C/N in compost piles seems to be largely ignored, in the interest of simplicity. If you cut greens before they die, and allow them to dry out and turn brown, they're actually nitrogen rich. In fact, while hay is sometimes considered a carbon-rich source because it is brown when dried, it's actually protein (clorophyll) rich and a pretty effective "green".

  • 9 years ago
    You're really getting scientific with this haha. It's definitely interesting stuff. I have heard of urea as a fertilizer, but didn't know it was in urine. Reading about it now....urea isn't a protein, but it's no surprise that it's a product of protein metabolism via the liver. The urea that is available as a fertilizer is synthetic though, right?

    It makes sense that hay is a source of nitrogen. Hay is when the plant/grass is harvested before it goes to seed. It's purposely harvested at this time because it's nutrient content is higher, which is beneficial to the livestock eating it. Straw, on the other hand, is harvested after it goes to seed and the plant is spent. This is primarily used as bedding and is why we have issues with the seeds germinating, when using it as mulch. I heard that one way to avoid this is to use oat straw, because oats aren't winter hardy and the seeds will die.

    Happy Thanksgiving, everyone!
  • 9 years ago

    Well, this "greens versus browns" business needs a little added science. Most of what is available on the matter in gardening blogs is just viral hand-wavy stuff, copied from here to there without addition of any facts.

    Urea was first discovered in urine, but is produced industrially by combining ammonia and CO2. No, they don't collect urine to make it. Massively used as fertilizer, and called the "king of fertilizers" in the ag industry. What got me interested in this was the parallel thread about urine, and how long it takes for urea to break down in urine. Agricultural urea breaks down as well after application to soil, becoming ineffective as a fertilizer, and it is a major research topic how to best use it before it decomposes.

    Hay is an OK source of nitrogen. C/N is 25 or so. But a lot better than fallen dried leaves or sawdust.

    Speaking of proteins, happy turkeys, everyone! But please don't compost them. That's nitrogen that you should ingest. Dead horses, yeah sure, compost those.


  • 9 years ago

    OK, I'll close this out with one more thing. Had dinner with a plant biologist tonight, and was told that no, chlorophyll isn't the main nitrogen bearing protein in green plants. It is (ready for this?) -- RuBisCO (which stands for a chemical name that is quite awesomely long -- look it up). That stuff is the most abundant protein/enzyme in green leaves, and contains about 30% of the leaf nitrogen. It is not green. RuBisCO is probably the most abundant enzyme on Earth! No, chlorophyll is just a handy green marker for where the stuff will be found. Chlorophyll is a minor carrier of green leaf protein and nitrogen. As for chlorophyll, RuBisCO is pulled apart and absorbed into the stem or roots upon senescence of the leaves. So little nitrogen is left in the leaves that fall naturally. Plenty of it in foliage that is harvested while green and dried (as in hay). That is precisely why hay is a feedstock and straw is not. Hay is vastly more nutritious. Lots more protein and, as a result, lots more nitrogen.

    Botany 101, I am told.

    This is why, you can see, it isn't smart to strip green leaves off of trees for compost because the leaves are just going to fall anyway. You'd be robbing the tree of vital nitrogen.

    So, you can have brown stuff with lots of protein and nitrogen. Protein -- that's what you want with your carbs in compost. Thank you acorns for making this come up!

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting