Even though Crate and Barrel is ungodly expensive, I think you could find a similar styles for less elsewhere if need be, but maybe something like these examples.

I think these are simple, yet modern, yet rustic, and the fact that there are no arms on these chairs helps keep the visual bulk down. http://www.crateandbarrel.com/sonata-aretina-walnut-dining-side-chair/s671697

These are a nice short back chair to keep the focus on your table. http://www.crateandbarrel.com/cabria-honey-brown-wood-dining-chair-and-cushion/f34462

I am personally pining for these, and it might add another level of mixing finishes and styles that all somehow mesh... http://www.crateandbarrel.com/elston-dining-chair/s213292

Hello Adrienne,

I appreciate all your input. I particularly like the Sonata Aretina but yes, they are $$$. I'm trying not to get a boxy/rectangular shape for the back of chairs since I already have these captain chairs in my formal dining room. This long table in the pic is from Crate and Barrel. :)

I am thinking about re-painting these Windsor chairs. What do you think? I only have three but I can always check antique stores to find another one. I love their round shape, just not too sure if they are too casual, considering the chandelier hanging above my table. But then again, I do have a river rock fireplace so maybe, these cottage-y chairs are a good fit?