Software
Houzz Logo Print
bielski

Liquid Amber Tree Roots Invading Driveway

9 years ago

My elderly neighbors have lived in their house since the 50s. They have a huge liquid amber tree in their yard about 50' tall and about 8-10 feet from my fence. We purchased this house last year and are getting ready to redo the driveway with pavers because the roots and age (our driveway is original to the 50s as well) have lifted and cracked parts of the driveway. I've consulted 2 arborists who say similar but conflicting things. One says to cut 3 feet worth of roots a long out 40' fence and install a 1/8" thick root barrier. He says that should offer about 10 years of protection from new invasion. The other arborist is concerned the cutting so many of the roots risks damaging the stability of the humongous tree and it could possibly fall and damage mine or my neighbors' homes. He suggested that I just bank the money and use it if I ever need to fix the pavers down the road. My paving contractor has suggested installing a 12" concrete bond beam along the edge of the wall as a smaller measure of prevention. Will the root barrier really help, or is it a short term band aid? Most importantly I don't want to harm the tree.

Comments (36)

  • 9 years ago

    Hello Jason, you ask some good questions and are doing your homework.

    Do I understand right that your driveway is maybe 20 foot or so away from the tree's trunk at its closest and the driveway will be about 40 foot long?

    Also, the driveway was concrete from the 50's?

  • 9 years ago

    Do you mean liquidambar? Like as in liquidambar styrcflua? I would ask the neighbors if I could remove the tree. Then replace it with an ornamental like redbuds or dogwoods. I hate sweetgum. I have 2 of them and have tried numerous ways to kill them.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    50 ft. isn't huge for a large-growing tree but anyway no I wouldn't cut a lot of roots off a tree I wanted to remain standing. And this species can often be a structurally vulnerable tree anyway, that is inherently very short lived, as far as trees go.

    Some comparatively small ones are already breaking up pavement in a parking lot in my town. So all in all your best bet would probably be to offer to pay to have the tree removed if they would agree to it.

  • 9 years ago

    I do mean liquid ambar. The driveway is original to the house from the 1950s and is on the other side of a cinder block wall about 10 ft. from the trunk. The neighbors have lived there since the 50s and love the tree. Realistically any new owners will probably remove the tree in favor of building a bigger home. There is no way they would agree to its removal, even on my dime. The arborist who is suggesting the root barrier feels that there are enough subterranean roots to keep the tree alive and stable even if we cut 40ft of roots along one side. The other arborist has only consulted over the phone and via text and has not been on site, but he feels that cutting 40 feet of roots is risky to the tree's stability and health and only be preventative for 5-10 years. He doesn't want the tree to fall. How deep is the root structure of the liquid ambar? I know the rootsNot sure who or what to believe.

  • 9 years ago

    Well I would just cut the tree back (roots and canopy) even with the property line. Install the root barrier, then sue the neighbors for any damage caused by the tree.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Logan, but if the tree dies and falls because I cut the roots, I'm the one liable in California and I'd be sued. I can cut anything on my property, but with that caveat. The neighbors are very conscientous and trim the canopy every 2 years and will be doing so next month. But that doesn't solve root issues. I have basically 2 options, install the barrier and hope it doesn't kill the tree or just cut what is necessary to install the paver driveway and if roots become an issue down the line, pop the pavers, repair underneath and reset the pavers after.

  • 9 years ago

    Trust me, it won't kill the tree. I took out basically all of the surface roots on my 2 sweetgums so that I could plant under them. They aren't dying by any means. I even girdled one and it is still alive. Cut it back to the property line like I said before. It may make your neighbors sad to have a tree with only 1/2 of a canopy, but it will be worth it. And I would keep it cut back so that it doesn't drop those spiky seed pods.

    Jason Bielski thanked Logan L Johnson
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Sara. As I mentioned, one arborist was on site and the other via phone because of availability issues. I try to reach out to discussions like these to see if if other users have been through similar situations and how they solved their problems so that I can make a more educated decision.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Interesting. That is close. It is also a species of tree I really enjoy.

    Perhaps thinking outside the box is the way to go.

    I have a long 1950's era driveway myself. One part is newer than others. There are random cracks but nothing which concerns me.

    If I had to repave mine I would go with asphalt like my neighbors. Its relatively cheap AND relatively unobtrusive to roots. Not totally beautiful though.

    Wonder the life expectancy of pavers would be if you essentially smash up your concrete and put the pavers over it leaving the roots be.

    Tree roots do eventually disturb concrete and displace pavers. I can't see a big tree suddenly growing roots like crazy and damaging new concrete. Especially one which strikes me as 90% its potential size.

    Jason Bielski thanked Toronado3800 Zone 6 St Louis
  • 9 years ago

    Sweet gums get way bigger than that.

  • 9 years ago

    The estimate of a root barrier buying you 5 to 10 years is accurate.

    The tree will grow new roots where the cuts are made.

    Guessing how cutting that many roots will affect the tree depends upon how many vigorous roots remain. It might be fatal; it might not.

    Jason Bielski thanked Jean
  • 9 years ago

    Another option would be to explore something other than pavers for the driveway that would not require root removal, let alone chainsaws and lawyers. There are a number of modern paving options that employ plastic grids, gravel, grass, stone dust, etc. that require minimal excavation, look good, provide great drainage with little to no runoff, will not crack and are resistant to heaving.

  • 9 years ago

    Are you in a part of CA that requires irrigation to grow trees of that size and if so are you irrigating on your side of the line to keep the grass green? If so you are contributing to the root 'problem'.

    In TN where this tree is native it is NOT short-lived.


  • 9 years ago

    How deep is the root structure of the liquid ambar?


    ==>>> the root structure of large trees.. is more pancake like ... than anything else ... the roots do NOT mimic the tree you see ABOVE ...


    not a great pic... ken

    http://weldbham.com/blog/2011/11/07/requiem-for-a-tree/



  • 9 years ago

    Thanks for saying that, Ken. It needed to be. I'm thinking along the lines of akamaine....some pervious pavers, which are inherently adjustable over time, allow for pass-through of precip, and provide an adequate surface. OR....since you clearly value the tree, and since it's not yours anyway.....pave your drive and don't worry about this tree. It's a slow-motion thing anyway, who knows what might be important in your life in five years....or ten. Maybe the best bet is to not worry about something that will clearly take time to happen.

  • 9 years ago

    I still say cut it even with the property line.

  • 9 years ago

    The sweet-gums on the site here are rapidly destroying the pavement - the City is soon going to have to do something about it.

    And they are maybe 20 ft. tall at this point, if that.

  • 9 years ago

    Well then let's panic.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Problem is already present on site being discussed, hence the discussion.

    We purchased this house last year and are getting ready to redo the driveway with pavers because the roots and age (our driveway is original to the 50s as well) have lifted and cracked parts of the driveway

    Even if an alternative paving system is used the roots are just going to keep getting thicker and more protruding over time.

  • 9 years ago

    The only permanent solution is to remove the tree. See if you can offer to plant a new sweetgum somewhere else for the neighbors and remove the other one. Maybe they would be happy with that. You could also replace the existing sweetgum with an ornamental.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    That you have described the tree as "huge" - and the neighbor thinks they have to keep paying to have it cut back - suggests you may prefer a smaller tree in its place anyway.

    Apart from the driveway damage.

  • 9 years ago

    Guys, I propose we need to reset our expectations and ideas of permanency.

    I
    have a few thirty year old slabs of concrete perhaps 120 feet from the
    nearest tree, my big shingle oak. Somehow they have cracked at the same
    rate as those 15 feet from it.Concrete as Americans use it, and
    expect it to stay perfect for rollerblading I suppose, is not
    permanent. Much like a Bradford Pear, Silver Maple or Bald Cypress, you
    can expect it to last soo long in certain situations.

  • 9 years ago

    My driveway is blacktop and is cracked to pieces. It is just old. You can't tell me my cornus florida cracked it.

  • 9 years ago

    ! EXACTLY !

  • 9 years ago

    Quote from OP's original post:

    "Most importantly I don't want to harm the tree."

    It's too bad that some couldn't respect that statement.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    People post here with stated objectives that may not be realizable or the smart move all the time. When I ask somebody about a situation I have I want to get the whole story, I want to benefit from their experience and insight. What I don't want is to find out later there was something I should have known, that I wasn't told!

    "Why didn't you tell me that might happen?"

    "You didn't ask".

  • 9 years ago

    Indianagardengirl, cutting the roots extensively and not harming the tree are specifications that are not compatible with each other.

  • 9 years ago

    I don't disagree that OP should have all relevant info, just believe that once you've made your case, it would be nice if you could then let it go. It's the constant bickering over your opinions that I'm referring to.

    How many times, Logan, did you advocate removing the tree? And it's interesting that above you say cutting the roots extensively and not harming the tree are not compatible. In an earlier post, you state 'trust me, it won't kill the tree.'

    Anyway, have at it. I'm just saying I'm tired of the hysteria.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hysteria? Aren't those the vines with the hanging pea-flowers? Those can get big too.

  • 9 years ago

    It didn't kill mine but I'm sure they'll never recover to complete health. So yes, they were harmed, but not killed. For instance if I got shot in the foot, I was harmed not killed. You can shoot someone and not kill them, but you still harm them. See what I'm getting at? Just because it isn't dead doesn't mean you didn't harm it.

  • 9 years ago

    Well, I will say that due diligence does call for as Embo states, filling in information not explicitly asked for. To not do so is a type of negligence. That said, OP does not own the tree, even manages to appreciate the tree (right?) despite potential problems, and quite clearly does not want to harm it...why not do a moderate root cutting and install a bio-barrier type of product? Those work, right? I haven't really used. I pretty much doubt a 12" bonding of concrete would stop stuff for long enough to justify cost. They'll go that low easily, I think.

  • 9 years ago

    Beautiful tree

  • 9 years ago

    jdo053103, You can have my sweetgums. Come and dig them up. Just get a dumptruck to set them in. Silver maples can be included in that offer. I hate both (sweetgums are worse, because I don't where shoes in my own yard). I still think offering to plant another sweetgum, removing the existing one, paving the driveway, and planting an ornamental.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Is the OP still
    there? He wrote: "I have basically 2 options, install the barrier and hope
    it doesn't kill the tree or just cut what is necessary to install the paver
    driveway and if roots become an issue down the line, pop the pavers, repair
    underneath and reset the pavers after."

    FWIW, I asked very
    basic questions about root barriers a few weeks ago and got a lot of opinions, but no hard facts. Hence, I think that your first option is
    a mere 5 to 10 year temporary solution which may not be substantially longer
    lived than your second option.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I don't like either of them. Really if you can't replace the paved surface with one that sits at a higher level established by the swelling of the roots I'm not sure there is any satisfactory way to retain a tree that is lifting pavement.