I like it but it would look good either way. It's very subtle since there are shadows from the beveled edges on the tiles.

It's pretty close. I think I would have thought this was the closest available match, if you hadn't drawn my attention to it.

Ok, so doesn't look dirty?

I think the grout color is perfect.

It looks great the grout matches perfect.

It's perfect. All it does is accentuate the dimension in the tile (which is a good thing), while at the same time it doesn't create a visual "checkerboard" which is a risk with a darker grout.

Thanks all!!!!