Software
Houzz Logo Print
succulentss

is my Eche okay?

9 years ago

I potted it in C&S porting mix(adding coarse perlite very soon). I don't know what's happening and I'm worried. Is it rotting? I have another Eche and nothing seems wrong with it.

Comments (19)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    that does look like rot....But can't say for sure. check the stem, any black parts? and feel the leaf. is it squishy? Also, what's the history of this succulent? Did you just repot it? Where was it before? Was it being watered a lot or in water-retintive soil?

    If it's rot, I would unpot this asap, take off the rotting leaves and leave it on a paper towel to dry till you get that perlite. You can also use pumice if it's available to you

  • 9 years ago

    yeah, those leaves don't look so hot :/ I'd take a look at the roots asap


  • 9 years ago

    @Christina They have a rubbery texture. Not squishy though. My grandmom bought it for me from home depot and I repotted it a few weeks later. It was being watered plenty, keeping the soil moist. The thing is, I was watering my other Eche the same way and it's fine. Can't see the stem through leaves.. I've never had rot before so I wouldn't know yet.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    A good rule to follow with succulents is actually, there are 2 i can think of:
    1. water when soil completely dry (stick a chopstick or something down to make sure)
    2. when in doubt, don't water lol

    In my experience, there has never been an echie you can water constantly and it will stay fine... I would think that eventually, it'll rot. What kind of echie is your other one? Also, watering routine DEFINITELY depends on the humidity, temp, light, drainage, and soil conditions. You can water the same two plants completely different depending on these. For example, an echie that is out on your front lawn in a free-draining soil and gets full sun for 12 hours during the hot summer in california can take watering probably as many as every 3 days to a generous drink once a week. That same echie but indoors in the shade, with c&s soil probably needs water only once every 2 weeks or 3, depending on the season.

    Also, there is no science or steps you can truly follow when it comes to watering your c&s. It's a feeling I'd say. Watch for signs its thirsty or overwatered.

    In this case, I would say your echie is over watered. You can do a few things right now. Since you don't want to un pot it: pluck off all the water logged leaves and stop watering it until the entire pot is completely dry. Can't tell you how long that might take, since it depends on the above mentioned factors.
    If you do want to unpot it, that would be ideal, since you don't want it sitting in that soil- you will risk the rot spreading... If you do unpot it, be sure to inspect the roots. If the roots are brown, soggy and mushy, or slimy, it's rot for sure. Post a pic if not sure and we can help you.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Agree with Christina, and she gave you good advice.

    Succulents do not need to be watered so plenty that soil stays moist.

    To improve drainage, at least add lots of perlite or pumice.

  • 9 years ago

    @Christina I'll pluck the bad leaves off. Would it help to give it fresh soil? Roots are normal. The other Echie is a Dondo. They are in half sun at a window, the temperature inside my house stays around 68-70. Both in same soil. I've only been misting my recovering Haw(it had peaty soil problems..) but I haven't been watering my others for a few days because of the strange leaves on my Echie.

    (Dondo under same conditions as other Echie, except it has a different pot.)


    PLUCKING LEAVES OFF BEFORE POSTING COMMENT: okay, so I've plucked the leaves off. Turns out they are very mushy, one even ripped open because it was so water logged. Its gonna take a while for this guy to recover, I had to take plenty off.

  • 9 years ago

    Hopefully the stem didn't start rotting - those leaves are very waterlogged. Rot spreads fast. Your potting soil is very organic, you need to use perlite or pumice (sorry for repeating myself).

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    oooh yep, that does not look too good. would recommend this: take that guy out of the pot away from all the wet soil. Clean off all the wet dirt, and set on a paper towel to dry away from any harsh or direct sunlight for a few days. Then, you can re pot it in completely dry c&s soil mixed with as Rina mentioned, pumice or perlite. Do 50/50 mix. Do not water it from then on until 2-3 weeks have passed. If you cannot access these materials for a while, you can rest assured the plant will be fine w/o soil for a while, if it's only the leaves that are rotten. If it's the stem, you will need to do some more triage. You can seriously leave the plant out of soil for weeks. It'll still live. Fascinating huh? These are tough plants. No babying required!

    But before repotting,
    Inspect the stem to see if the rot spread. if it has and you still want this echie, you can slice the stem off, separating it from the rotted part. It will re-root eventually but it won't look pretty, so you can throw it out and start with a new plant. As Rina said, rot spreads quickly!! If there are no signs of brown or black rot on the stems, then just keep a careful watch on it daily to see if any appear. Rot can destroy a plant in as short as 1 day.

    Also, you are not going to like this, but terrariums are not exactly good for succulents despite popular belief :(. Terrariums are designed for moisture loving plants. It will look nice in there for a while... but eventually you will start to see it struggle.

  • 9 years ago

    it's unlikely that all of those leaves happened to root independently of one another, imo. more likely the rot is spreading from a central source. I second Christina's advice, definitely repot and check the stem and roots.


  • 9 years ago

    I can't see the stem well... What do you guys think?


  • 9 years ago

    it's hard for me to tell too. You need to get more soil off. Don't be afraid, if you break some of the finer/small roots in the process it'll be okay.
    It also looks like you may have some dead roots, but again hard to tell. Healthy roots should be firm.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Some healthy roots for comparison

  • 9 years ago

    @Christina

    All of my succulents(except the one that had root problems, surprisingly) have roots like my Eche.. (thank goodness I only have four). Anyway, here is what I found..

    looks pretty dark to me.. oh no. I'm only a beginner at succulents and I don't know if I should throw it out or what to do:(

  • 9 years ago

    I actually had soaked it in some lukewarm water to remove as much soil as possible, so that might be what you're seeing. I tried to dry it off though but I didn't know how I should've. Its not mushy from what I know. I'm not that experienced so I don't know if I should get into cutting it. Its really late right now so I'll check on this post in the morning:)

  • 9 years ago

    the darkness of the stem combined with the waterlogged leaves doesn't bode well :/ like Christina, i wish I could be there to actually see the stem/roots, but as it is, my best advice would be to cut it-- better to be safe than sorry. the rest of the plant looks pretty healthy, so I don't think it would take too long for it to send out new roots. whatever you decide to do, though, good luck!

  • 9 years ago

    Lower leaves naturally discolor and wither away as new leaves emerge from the center. However the difference between this and rot is that the bottom leaves would be mushy. To be sure, lift it up, check the base of the plant, where the roots emerge from.

    Is it soft and mushy? If not, then likely you're fine. Just repot in a 50-50 mix of potting soil and pumice stones (Perlite is fine but tends to float to the top, leaving the bottom to heavy). Don't water asap as with any repotting, water 2-3 days after as repotting causes tears that water can enter and rot through.

  • 9 years ago

    Well, here's the thing. I probably won't be cutting it but I don't know about throwing it out, I'd feel a little bad because it was a gift. Decisions, decisions..

  • 9 years ago

    Just cut it. It isn't a big deal, and it will ensure the plants survival. You just cut, leave out to dry the cut, then stick in perlite. It will grow roots and start to flourish in about one month.