Software
Houzz Logo Print
angela726y

What's wrong with my succulent?

9 years ago


I keep a lot of succulents in one pot, but one plant started losing leaves on one side, and when I examined closer, the was very discolored and the leaves that fell off are brown/black and very wrinkly. Only this plant is affected, and the other succulents look fine. The pot is filled with cactus potting mix and there is a drainage hole at the bottom.

Comments (5)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Sorry to say, but it is rotting. Rot could spread to another plants. Even if it doesn't right now, take that plant out asap, it may be complete goner - whole stem looks to be black/rotting. Maybe there are some leaves healthy enough to propagate, but can't tell from the photo. I would suggest that rot is result of keeping succulents in water retaining soil. I can't see how deep the pot is, but if it holds lots of soil it makes things even worse.

    Your plants look also etiolated - not getting enough light. One on the right is likely Sempervivum, hardy succulent that does best if grown outdoor. It should be compact, not stretched. Plant behind it looks etiolated too.

    If my plants, I would take them out. I would get rid of all old soil, and repot into well draining mix. Can't see what other plants you have there, but community dishes that include plants with different needs do not work that well. And it could be more difficult in case person is new to succulents (no offence please!) to take care for too many different plants in same container.

    There is another current thread with very similar questions, maybe you can check it out -here-

    angela726y thanked rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
  • 9 years ago

    Thanks so much for alerting me to the rot! Yes, the pot is fairly deep, but I thought the specialized cactus soil would be enough to drain the water.

    I do realize many of my plants are stretching, but it's been cloudy for the past few months where I live, and winter has just passed. Hopefully they'll get enough sun when summer comes around!

  • 9 years ago

    Unfortunately the soil mixes that are sold labeled for cacti and succulents really don't work as well for those plants as the name implies. Some people here make their own mixes. Others will buy the cacti & succulent soil from the store but mix it with something else like perlite, half and half.

    angela726y thanked Polypompholyx
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Angela

    If I could give advice, it would be best to take all plants out of that pot & the soil ASAP. Specialized Cactus & Succulent soil is more often than not too peaty, with many fine particles in it and water retaining. If you want to get your plants into better condition, at least get a bag of perlite and mix it 50/50 with C&S soil. You could use even more perlite. Instead of perlite, pumice could be used if available. My succulents are in a mix of grit, perlite and a small amount of turface - no soil at all.

    I live in colder location too, never enough sunlight during winter. I help my plants with supplemental lights so they don't stretch that much. Keeping succulents indoors usually doesn't give them enough light, very few have excellent window space with lots of unobstructed light. Still, sunlight looses some potency coming thru the windows.

    ETA: as you can see, polypompholyx is saying same thing about the soil...

    angela726y thanked rina_Ontario,Canada 5a
  • 7 years ago

    I would also like to add that succulents that have begun to etiolate will continue to do so unless you cut at the base, and let them re-root. Plants that etilate will not stop. Its disappointing, but at least the plant has a chance to survive and grow properly. Some plants like sempervivums can sometimes be saved from completely rotting. If you cut the base and find good tissue, you can re-root it and start over. Good luck!

Sponsored
NME Builders LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars2 Reviews
Remodeling Company in New Albany, Ohio