Software
Houzz Logo Print
baw0123

hot water recirculation pump sound?

9 years ago

I recently had a hot water recirculation pump professionally installed near my water heater in the basement. Its a Laing E1/E3 (photo attached). The pump works great and I now get hot water fast in the 2nd floor master shower. However, the pump makes a low level sound that I was not expecting. It's sort of a like a humming/modulating sound. Its very subtle, but it does travel up the water pipes and I can actually hear it in other spaces in the home (and in water heater area).

I was under impression that these pumps were virtually silent. Perhaps a different brand pump would be better for sound?

Thanks in advance for any insights.


Comments (20)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    That sound you hear is the sound of dollars seeping out of your un-insulated copper pipes that now have hot water in them constantly.

    I've never known any motor / pump to be silent... without hearing it I don't know if it's unusual or not.

  • 9 years ago

    Clamping the pipe to a solid structure, as close as possible to the pump, will dampen the vibrations in the pipe.

  • 9 years ago

    The issue is not vibrations in the pipe. The issue is pump motor sound/hum/buzz. I am mainly curious to know if the Groundfos, for example, may be a quieter option?

  • 9 years ago

    As Jake mentioned running the pump 24/7 is wasteful. Also if the pump isn't running all the time you would then not have a sound to notice. I plugged our recirc pump into an X-10 appliance module. I timed how long it takes to pump hot water to the various outlets. We can turn on the pump for the specified time and have "instant" hot water at that spot. Then the pump can be turned off. A bit of an inconvenience but good for the world! The only time I leave it on is for the dish/clothes washers because of the run times of those machines. X-10 isn't as reliable as some other remote control devices but it is quite inexpensive. I started out with a remote Christmas light control but it had a conflict with the garage door opener.

  • 9 years ago

    @pima74, what is the wastefulness? The energy consumed by the pump? My understanding is that they consume very little energy. I don't think the hot water heater runs much more frequently either. At least I haven't noticed it come on. I have it set to a low setting (just enough to pull water back from return line) and there is also a timer if I choose to use it.

    I got tired of waiting for 60 seconds to get hot water upstairs. That's a lot of wasted water which isn't "good for the world" either.


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We have had a Grundfos for 17 years. It is mounted adjacent to the hot water tank in the garage. No sound that I have ever noticed. We have the pump running for showers in the morning and for dishwashing/clothes washing in the evening, about 5 hrs a day. An X-10 controller seems like an interesting idea. Our Grundfos uses about 80 watts. I would think the size of the plumbing system affects the amount of electricity used.

    baw0123 thanked hoovb zone 9 sunset 23
  • 9 years ago

    It's not the power used by the pump that is primarily the issue... it's the heat that is lost through the un-insulated pipes. If you are going to have a circulating pump, at least insulate the water lines.

    I've never heard a silent pump... ok, that doesn't makes sense... but you know what I mean. You may have better results with a different pump though.

    baw0123 thanked Jake The Wonderdog
  • 9 years ago

    Running the pump 24/7 is one of those electrical vampires. It uses small amounts that add up over time. Also even insulated pipes lose some heat because insulation is not perfect. The heater will have to make up for that loss.

  • 7 years ago

    Came here to add that I bought the same Laing E1 recirculating pump a few months ago, and I noticed a similar problem, a low-to-medium pitch humming (like a fan, or vacuum cleaner) in the walls for about 30 seconds, every 5-15 minutes. I downloaded a spectrum analyzer app on my phone, and it says it was about 300 Hz (+/- a few Hz). Took me a long time to figure this out. I thought it was the refrigerator compressor my neighbor directly above me. Or I thought it was the automatic fan in the stairwell. Or maybe a pump or fan in the downstairs garage. Or a buzzing fluorescent bulb in the stairwell behind my wall (which has happened in the past). One by one, I eliminated the possible sources, then inspiration struck and I went to the recirculating pump, put my ear on it, and there it was, the same 300 Hz sound, barely audible at the pump, but (for some reason) seemingly much louder in the walls of my bedroom. Now trying to figure out if I can get this replaced under warranty.

  • 7 years ago

    Then just run it when you need hot water at some location rather than 24/7 (which appears to be the case when you can hear the pump while in bed)

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    @bthouse

    same problem. I have an ecocirc B&G e3 (basically same Laing one as OP...now owned by Xylem). It is the aquastat model and registers as only using 8W but the piping hums for a minute every time it runs about every 15 minutes. It mainly resonates in the small L bend of pipes 2 feet from the pump to the y inlet of the tank.

    id like to try a different pump to see if that fixes it but potentially more money down the drain if it does the same thing. I was looking at something like the grundfos alpha2 which is also an ecm. Taco also comes up as fairly quiet but who knows. A specific machine may just be operating at just the right frequency in parallel with the pipe so hopefully a different model would fix it?

    @baw0123

    did you ever replace the pump or change the pipe bends? I also have a bend right before the pump inlet but about a foot to a bend that goes up to the tank. I thought it could be cavitation or water turbulence (those pipes seem noisiest). But since you have the same pump maybe it’s just the pump causing resonance (Also using 1/2” copper). I have a spring valve right after the pump outlet but I don’t really think swing or spring should matter for the check valve. I’ve also bled air out and cleaned the adjacent pipe and the pump itself of scale but the low frequency hum still is there.




  • 4 years ago


    We have a circulating pump near the water heater. It was installed before we purchased our house eight years ago, and it has been working very well. I connected it to a timer a few years ago to shut it off at night, and that too has been working quite well. We had a leak in the line on the output side, and had our plumbing company sent a guy out after hours to repair it, which he did. However, we noticed a noise the next day coming from the water heater closet, and it was coming from the pump. I placed my hand on the pump, and the noise stopped. So, I placed a cardboard box under it with a wood shim wedged beneath the pump, and it remains quiet. MY QUESTION IS, Why did it begin making the noise? I contacted the plumber directly, and he said I probably now have a pump problem. I don't buy that. Why now, all of a sudden? I will include three photos for you to examine: Two show the leak before it was repaired and the third shows it now, after the repair (and with the box and wedge under the pump). PLEASE NOTICE THAT before the repair, there was a sort of coupling that was removed when the plumber soldered in a new section of copper. WAS THE COUPLING THERE TO PREVENT THE VIBRATION?





  • 4 years ago

    No, it was just a sharkbite coupling.

    like in the original post, the pump will hum and telegraph on the pipes.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you, Jake. Our problem is that it did not make any noise at all before the leak was repaired. It was dead silent.

  • 4 years ago

    We can't hear the noise - so keep that in mind. If it's a minor hum, it could be normal. If it's a loud noise, it could be dry.


    Also do you have the old fitting they removed. It looks like a SharkBite fitting, but it could have been a check valve. It's hard to tell from the photo.


    Take a look at this video



  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Thank you, Jake. I do not have the fitting to know for sure if it was a SharkBite or check valve; I can only believe that the plumber would have known better than to remove a check valve without replacing it. I removed the box and wedge from under the pump, and it has quit making the noise. The air vent has produced a lot of white spew (I don't know what to call it), so maybe the issue was air in the line. Anyway, thank you for your responses. It seems to be back to normal.

  • 4 years ago

    Yes, it sounds like it was air if there was a lot vented.

    Glad it's back to normal.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I recently replaced my pump with the Laing E1 and hear the low motor hum and water passing through. Has anyone with this pump resolved the issue? I tried bleeding the air but as soon as I unscrewed the air vent, water comes out instead of air which means there's no air present. I suspect the noise is normal but not great since the noise can be heard in the adjoining guest room.