Software
Houzz Logo Print
raeanna310

Dark spots on Echeveria? :(

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

What do these mean?

Online results point to over-watering, but those spots look different and the leaves aren't yellow. There is also a single wilted leaf. When I brought it home, the spots weren't there. I recently watered and it's been sitting in a window that gets sunlight but not direct sunlight.


EDIT: There is about 2 inches of drainage at the bottom. Filled with ceramic balls. The soil is not cactus mix soil and it also has the little white rocky things in it (not sure what they'er called). If replanting will solve this issue I would be glad to. But I want to keep it a bowl that does not drain. Something like this.


Comments (47)

  • 9 years ago

    Hmm the woman at the store said having that at the bottom will prevent soaking and it will just evaporate. I know drainage is better though. I will have to find something I like with drainage that is clear for the future then. And transplant immediately eek! So is that the reason for the spots?

  • 9 years ago

    I agree. Not trying to be rude in any way, but it's a huge misconception that succulents can thrive in drain-less containers. Perhaps an experienced grower will be able to make it happen, but it's so risky due to how easily they can rot in there. Glass also intensifies heat penetrating the glass, so you could potentially cook the roots and end up with a dead succulent. Drain-less containers are good for things like a temporary succulent arrangement that you expect to look pretty for a few months.

    Water is not going to evaporate quickly enough for the succulent. Instead, condensation will happen due to high humidity... think of a closed bathroom after a hot shower. Watering the plant a little bit may not be enough for the plant and watering what you might think is the right amount will just give way for water to pool at the bottom. Not your fault at all but It's a huge pet peeve of mine with people who sell c&s don't know the proper care. ):

    It's hard for me to recognize these spots you are referring to

  • 9 years ago

    It was an exotic plant store, the woman said she had a bunch of succulents at home. So she probably has more knowledge on the upkeep if there is no drainage. But I wanted to put them in this specific mug. I brought it with me when I bought the plants.

    Yeah I totally get it!

    They are just small brown/dark spots on the under side of the leaves. Maybe it is natural?

  • 9 years ago

    She didn't explain where/how would water evaporate if covered by soil? Soil will stay wet for as long as there is any water - and that is usually too long. Succulents don't like wet feet.

    Dark spots could be abrasions, but they could be also from too much water. It is difficult to be sure, I can't really see the spots well enough to tell.

    'Little white rocky things' in the soil are most likely perlite. Perlite will increase drainage but only if there is plenty of it. Just few grains of it, that are usually found in bagged soil do not help at all. Your plants will grow best in well draining mix and in plenty of light.

  • 9 years ago

    No she just said it would evaporate LOL. But awesome. Thank you all for the knowledge!

    I will get to transplanting real soon. I don't want to lose my babies :(

    What if I got something like this and was able to put drainage holes in it, and paint the lower half white (or another color so maybe the heat won't penetrate as deep), leaving the overhead part clear? It would be put facing out the window, so the light would not be coming through the glass at all. If that makes sense. So it wouldn't burn the plants. Or am I better off with boring ceramic? :( lol

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    The holes would definitely help a ton! One of the main problems with glass bowls like that is the humidity builds up. No airflow. I'm not saying it's impossible, but a little challenge. Could be a learning lesson for you. Heck you may get it just right and have beautiful plants:).

  • 9 years ago

    Sweet! By painting it, hopefully it doesn't get to hot inside. Maybe I could have holes around on the outside too? Would that help even more for the heat? Although it may leak when I water it. Lol...

    I am determined to have pretty glass planters

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Like like I said it's not an impossibility. Just make sure you've got great drainage and airflow. Get some perlite you can find it at Home Depot or Lowes. Do a mix of 60% perlite with 40% C&S soil. You could even add more perlite if need be. You're going to keep your echie in the house so make sure she's gettin enough light. You gotta remember the Echeveria will only be recieving light on one side. As soon as you see it leaning, stretching, leaves turning down, and looking like the pics below. They need more light.

    Both pics are from the internet:)

  • 9 years ago

    Oooh awesome, thanks! I will do that!
    And I have heard that. Thank you!

    Is that the same with all succulents? I have another in this group, you can kinda see it in the picture. I forget the name. :(

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Yep it's a Crassula perforata aka String of Buttons. They need the same as the Echeveria. I don't know why I didn't think of this before, but Haworthias do pretty well with lower light. They still need a good amount, but not like the echie or Crassula. Drainage is a must for any and every succulent tho:).

  • 9 years ago

    The woman at the store told me two of these are the same species lol?

    Hmm I will put that one in the back then!

  • 9 years ago

    I think you misread Kara's post: she was suggesting Haworthias for lower light situation - not the Crassula perforata. I belive that was answer to your question ..."Is that the same with all succulents?"...

  • 9 years ago

    Yes I meant that i will put the Haworthia in the back of the pot. :) Or in its own pot somewhere else! I have NINE babies growing off of it! I am so excited.

  • 9 years ago

    Well, maybe I misread - but didn't know you have Haworthia too. I see only 2 plants :) and neither is haw...

  • 9 years ago
    Yeah it's barely visible in the picture.
  • 9 years ago
    Or maybe it's not and I misunderstood lol.
  • 9 years ago

    Great plants!

    I love finding new creative ways to display my succulents.lack of proper drainage is a huge peeve of mine too. I have no problem drilling holes into containers (if I'm already willing to put dirt in it why not drill a hole in it) it's a lot of fun to find species of succulents that work well for you and start making cool little succulents gardens! These plants also like bright light-full sun (afternoon shade) and do great on well lit patios!

  • 9 years ago
    These are my first babies and I'm super excited! Bought a new container tonight! It's a bit big. I'd need a few more succulents to fill it. But if the 3 are grouped together they should be okay right? Or I'll just go buy more plants :)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    What's the third plant? I know you've got an Echeveria and a Crassula, but I don't know the third:).

  • 9 years ago
    Your said haworthia so I thought that's what it was lol! It surely looks similar to the Google search. But the lady said two of these are the same species. I think she was incorrect...
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Oh I was suggesting for you to get a Haworthia because they can handle lower light then other succulents:). A misunderstanding it happens. Could you take a pic of the plant? If you don't mind of course:).

  • 9 years ago
    Oh my bad! I do want a few haworthia though. They're rad.
  • 9 years ago
    Is it okay to do a bottom rock layer in my glass bowl? It does have drain holes. And I'll use a 3:2 perlite/cactus soil mix like suggested above.
  • 9 years ago

    Ya that's fine as long as there's a hole at the bottom:).

  • 9 years ago
    Woohooo! Sweet. :) do you know of a good beginner guide to succulents? I don't want to keep asking a bunch of questions lol!
  • 9 years ago

    No I don't sorry. Here is a great place to learn. I swear:).

  • 9 years ago
    Well I also would like to find out how to safely pick off pups? I've got some on the dark tipped plant
  • 9 years ago

    Just pinch them off with your fingers or I like to use micro pruning shears. Let them callus for a day and put them in your mix. Keep in the shade and no water till roots form.

  • 9 years ago
    Okay so same as propagating. I couldn't find anything for pups. Thanks!!
  • 9 years ago

    RaeA

    There is soooo much info here, you can just search the forum.

    Propagating/separating pups is fun, just make sure they are not very tiny.

  • 9 years ago
    You can see a few in the photo I posted in the comments. I'll have to research. :)
  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I only noticed that photo now. That is not Haworthia, but Sempervivum. Best grown outdoors year round even in cold regions, since they are hardy to z4 and many to z3.

    I don't think you mentioned your general location or growing zone, can you add it to your name (as other ppl did)

    Pups are too small to take off yet, wait until stolons get longer and pups bigger.

  • 9 years ago
    Oh okay! Thank you.
    I'm in Sacramento. I believe that's zone 9.
  • 9 years ago

    You can add it to your name (so we don't have to ask :) by going to your profile, adding location or zone or both. If not sure about your zone, check -this link-, just type in your state or zip.

  • 9 years ago
    Yay fixed it! Thanks!
  • 9 years ago

    Great! And you have your correct zone too...:)

  • 9 years ago

    So is my sempervivum okay with the others I have? I got more. Picture

    I think they should all be okay together... From what I looked up, they all need the same lighting and watering.

  • 9 years ago

    Sorry, I wouldn't recommend potting lithops with any other plants...they have quite specific needs for watering. Some consider them fussy :) Not sure what info you looked up to say they have same watering needs as your other plants.

  • 9 years ago

    I would take the cactus and Lithops out. They have different watering needs. The other plants in there look fine. Lithops can be tricky, but it's a good challenge. I would definitely put those in a container all by themselves. These guys turn to mush if you just look at them wrong;). They won't need water for at least a couple months. I never water mine. Maybe 3 or 4 times a year. I honestly wait for the Lithops to tell me when to water. They will look shriveled and thirsty. It's then when I give them their drink:).

  • 9 years ago

    Oh dang. Well I have seen a lady on youtube where she uses a syringe to water hers cause some need more water than the others. Guess I will try that for now. I don't want to stress them by replanting again so soon.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I keep cacti little drier than I would Sedum morganianum. But you can leave them and see what will happen...

    Sorry, but syringe watering doesn't solve your problem. Once you water soil/mix, water will dissipate and all will get some. Lithops will need some periods of time to be totally dry - no water at all. If they are watered too much or at wrong time, first they will get 'fat' and you may think they are looking better. But very soon after, the leaves will just explode and whole plant is kaput. You really should separate them, and read a lot to make sure you know enough to grow them well. There are few members here that do. I have just few, some for about 3yrs, and am still not quite there...

    Just being picky here, but not all info you find on some (many :( sites, or youtube, is correct. Lots of it is to make really good looking pottings, terrariums and so on, but nobody will tell you how long plants survived in that setting. They may not die in short time, but unless you are prepared to keep buying new plants to replace dead ones, think about it. JMO.

  • 9 years ago

    I'm sorry I feel like I keep giving you Debbie downer news, but I'm just trying to help. Knowledge is power:).

  • 9 years ago

    No worries!! I should have looked it up a little better. And the care instructions on the tags were too vague apparently. I will learn! Thank you for the tips and taking time out of your day to help a newbie lol :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    OT I see you live in Sacratomato and the Succulent/Cactus show is May 6-7 at the Shepard Garden and Arts Center. I actually like the Sac one better then the SF one. The plants for sale and on display are just as good. It's not as crazy as the SF one. Just a little FYI I see you may be getting the succulent bug;).

  • 9 years ago

    Researching the plant after I buy it is probably the most important thing I've learned by being on this forum:).

  • 9 years ago

    Ooooh I will try to go! I definitely am getting the bug :) I am getting the plant bug in general. I will definitely have to do better research before repotting next time LOL. Big oopsies.