Software
Houzz Logo Print
bpath

Following your heart

9 years ago

My younger son decided on his college tonight and the deposit is in. It's not the school I'd have chosen for him, but it was his choice from the get go. I didn't get into my school of choice, and while "plan b" worked out fine for me, I would have liked to have gone there just the same. So, while I had compelling reasons for him to go elsewhere, one must follow one's heart, and I look forward to visiting some lovely vineyards and taking some spectacular walks when we go to visit him.

In the meantime, I am consoling myself with Escape to the Country (oh, dear, could Jules have the flu? He's not his usual chipper self. I watch this show too much) and polishing off the jelly beans from Easter.

How about you? Did you let the kids follow their hearts? Did YOU follow your heart for school?

Comments (70)

  • 9 years ago

    I grew up in SoCal and very few kids in my graduating class of 1200 went away to college. I and most of my friends went to the junior college then transferred to the state U in our town. I lived a few miles from both. I don't think it ever occurred to any of us to go away to college. I don't know how it is now but the Cal State system back then had a good reputation. Tuition my senior year was $90 a semester!

    My oldest two both went to their first choice schools....one in state, one out of state, but both state u systems. My oldest changed his major from computer science to environmental science when he went for orientation. He decided he didn't want to be desk-bound all day. He now works for the county EPA. He makes ok $....he'll never be rich....and has job security (as much as you can count on these days). He talked about grad school for awhile and looked at programs then lost interest. I thought he'd be more ambitious than he is, but he seems happy and content with where he is and as a parent that's what you hope for.

    My second, DD, went out of state, found the perfect major for her, not found at many schools, went on to get a master's at the same school while working there and is now a consultant still living in her college town. She's doing very well financially.

    Our youngest son would probably have been happiest staying home and going to the junior college, but at the time he wanted to major in something not very common and offered by few schools so off he went. Two years in he decided he didn't want that major anymore and considered transferring back home to a state school, but few of his credits would transfer so he'd almost be starting over and still didn't really know what he wanted to major in. We talked it over and he ultimately decided to stick it out where he was. A semester abroad junior year helped. About the same time he decided against his major he became very interested in animal rights....mainly farm animal protection. He did a lot of volunteering in college and got a job with an animal non profit when he graduated in 2010. Seven years later and he is still passionate about it and will start a new job in June doing more of what he wants to do....writing/communications/public relations. He has a degree in something he'll never use, but he might not have found his calling had he not attended that school for that major. You just never know where the best laid plans may end up taking you. He'll never make a lot of $ either but is very dedicated to his cause.

    We always told our kids "find something you enjoy and find a way to make a living at it. It doesn't mean every day or every job will be bliss, but if you can wake up in the morning and be generally happy about your field and going to work each day, you've got it made."

  • 9 years ago

    No kids so I can only speak to what I did. My heart had nothing to do with it. I grew up in a lower income somewhat messed up family so my goal in going to college was to make a better life for myself; i.e. make a decent living. I chose a field that would allow me to do this with less than a four year degree at a state university. I didn't even know there was such a thing as a private college.

    I hated high school and I wanted to get away from home permanently so that influenced my decision. I loved college when I got there and did very well so I finished the two year program, got a decent job and continued going to school at night and finished my four year degree with very little debt in part because I got grants due to family income along with some scholarships and low interest loans.

    I worked in my initial vocation for about six years, moved out of state and had to wait 11 months to take the boards in that state and applied for a job working with computers for medical offices. I loved that work and it led to a very lucrative career in healthcare IT.

    I can't begin to imagine going into major debt for a liberal arts degree or anything else that wouldn't lead to reasonable employment. People would be better off learning a trade (many of which are very much in demand) so they can be gainfully employed and pursue the college degree over time as they can afford to do so.

  • 9 years ago

    PinkMountain, some great advice there!

  • 9 years ago

    I followed my heart and am so glad I did. Against my parents wishes I wanted to go out of state for college--just to get away in that mildly rebellious time. I got a full ride to a small college in a neighboring state, loved the place, majored in English, went abroad for a year. Several inspiring teachers led me to apply for graduate school, again a full ride, completed my master's in English, then went on for a Ph.D. It led to a career as a university teacher and now administrator. I love what I do and have loved it for the 30 years I've been in this career. I would not change a thing. Yes, I feel really blessed in this regard.


  • 9 years ago

    MtdRd, getting back to your first response, good luck with all the visits! DS was too overcome by all kinds of anxieties junior year and couldn't go on visits; we couldn't even mention college without him getting all verklempt. He'd been on all the visits with his older brother a few years before, so finally senior year we got started. We really had to make up for lost time, so there was no early decision for us. We even saw one school whose early decision date was in mid-October, I heard of another that is October 1!

  • 9 years ago

    This thread reminded me of a recent NYTimes article about the college visit not being a great tool for chosing a school.



    https://www.nytimes.com/2017/04/26/well/family/skipping-the-college-tour.html

  • 9 years ago

    Interesting article, Crl. If only it were easy to find experience surrogates! If you a considering a school where you don't know anyone, how do you find the surrogates? Will there be an effort to silence those with a negative experience?

    We did look at retention rates after freshman year and beyond. And on a college visit you hope that you have a small group or a tour to yourselves with one or two guides. It will be easy to ask questions and maybe build some rapport so you get more candid discussion.

    We had an unexpected experience with our visits. Went to school Red and School Green in the same weekend. Red's tour guide was stellar, a real outstanding kid, highly intelligent and personable, a natural leader, candid, and encouraging. Ya wanted to go to HIS school.

    Green's tour guide was not the sharpest knife in the drawer, lacked direction and gumption, and gave us a bad taste for Green though we knew other students there who were, frankly, more like our Red tour guide.

    A few months later we visited again to audition, same thing happened. Our lunch host at Green was at least the same major as DS, but only because she couldn't think of what she wanted to major in. Um, ok.

    So, after two visits, we liked Red, didn't like Green though we knew it was a good school for the major.

    Admitted student visits followed. Our Red experience was not so good, and it was the first time we saw the dorms: one tiny window. Eek. Our Green experience was outstanding. Our host was a senior in DS' major and another great guy, really showed the school well. And just like that, we liked Green, not Red.

    In the end, DS chose school Blue. Similar to school Green in some ways but on steroids, bigger, farther, more discriminating, and more professional (and better views). (Oh dear, has "discriminating" taken on a non-PC meaning?)

  • 9 years ago

    DH and I practically cried when our two sons told us what they were planning to study in university. One had really enjoyed his high school philosophy class, and insisted that's the only thing he could see himself studying in university. The other had always loved drawing, and likewise said the same about studying fine arts, for illustration.

    Of course we questioned our older son about how many philosophers he personally knew that were currently employed, and told him it was an archaic field that had no relevance in today's business world. We asked our younger son how many artists he personally knew that were making a living in actual buildings and not being forced to hawk their art outdoors.

    We tried to convince our sons to choose something more practical, that would enable more of a chance for decent employment. We suggested our older son could always read philosophy books in his spare time, and that our younger son could always still draw, in his spare time.

    Neither son heeded our advice and one pursued a degree in philosophy and the other in fine arts, for illustration. They both received some academic scholarship assistance and the remainder of their tuition was paid for by their part time jobs and help from us. DH and I basically felt our money was surely going into aspirations that would never pan out for them, but had tired of trying to convince them to study something practical.

    Long story short, is that both sons are doing amazingly well, in companies that have no connection to the fields they studied. Our 31 year old is already earning more than DH retired at, and he earned a nice income. DS was recently promoted to a Director in his company, who said they "love the way he thinks.' Naturally, he feels that's in large part, due to his philosophy background. I don't know how he perceives any application of philosophy to his job, but we're extremely proud of his success and how much he loves what he's doing.

    Our 26 year old also ended up in a business company. They hired him because his resume and interview showed a 'talent for creativity' and they were looking for someone who "can think outside the box." Again, I don't know how his degree in art illustration helps him in a career that is not in that field, but of course, he feels that his education developed his creativity.

    We'll never know if the fact that both sons's degrees from our country's top rated university, meant MORE than their actual fields of study, (to their employers) or whether they just got very, very lucky and aced their interviews. We're just glad that despite our years of worry, somehow everything worked out great in the end.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    We'll never know if the fact that both sons's degrees from our country's top rated university,

    I don't know if you are talking about somewhere other than the US, but here it is definitely true. Certainly for Ivies but prob for the Top 25 at least, If you get in and do well, they know you are smart and hard-working. The rest takes care of itself.

    I don't think any of my kids will get into our country's top rated university, though.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    If the country is Canada, maybe McGill (aka Harvard North)? Top three are probably UBC, University of Toronto and McGill. Or I may just be showing alma mater favouritism ;)

    I haven't really noticed University playing a huge role in Canada in hiring outside of academia, but I'm pretty low level.

    it's been 20 years since I first stepped on mcgill campus and just this week I got hit with a huge wave of nostalgia and arranged a trip to Montreal for st jean baptiste. Can't wait! Spent many happy hours at the open air pub....back in the days when there was still a student run pub in one of the undergraduate dorms and the other dorms held huge street parties serving beer out of the common room windows. I thought I had ended up on a 24 hour quiet study floor and I remember my very first night in the dorm, the girls in rooms on either side of me started blasting music and smoking pot in their rooms. I was completely bewildered and enchanted. Montreal is a great place to be a teenager, especially for a small town nerd from Nova Scotia.

  • 9 years ago

    Like joanieponie, only one girl from my HS went away to college. That just wasn't what people did. I grew up in a city that has a lot of higher education institutions and everything someone could want from a community college to education, law, engineering, medical, dental, nursing, and business. Pretty much anything other than ag-related fields.

    I am also in a field that didn't really exist widely at the time but I always wanted a health related career. Tuition was cheap, and I got more financial aid after my father retired. Still, I had a few loans. I didn't take loans when I went for my masters and I was sick all the time from working so much. So, when I got to my doctoral institution I took more in loans so I could save my health and sanity. Plus, we had no GA/TA in tthe summers and the rent and utilities needs to be paid. At the time it was a low cost of living area and rent was incredibly cheap that I could cover my basic expenses with the stipend. I still LOL that I paid over $2500 out of those loans for a Dell pentium desktop computer and had dial-up for $10 a month. Although the stats programs I still had to do on the mainframe at the computer labs.

    Some undergrads are very focused and know exactly what they want to do and then do it. For example, they come in wanting to be a physical therapist (which is now a three-year Doctor of Physical Therapy or DPT when I could have completed a BS in PT) and they aim towards that goal. I've had about a half dozen recent DPT graduates and a lot more ready to get out. OTOH, others find that they want to do something else like public health, or are very deterred at the prospect of paying an additional $20-30K per year tuition for the DPT. Even the DPT who teaches for us part-time says there are students in DPT of two types: families who are paying the bills or else on max loans--no in-between.


  • 9 years ago

    This thread is very timely for me, as my youngest will be putting in his deposit this weekend. He will be going to his second choice school, we will call it "Scarlett.". it is our big state school, and a great school, but it sad because his first choice school that he got into is not an option for us financially, and that is breaking my heart. It is another big state school, but not as big, and one of the top public universities in the country. We will call it "Blue". Ironically it is also the biggest sports rival of Scarlett.

    DS finally made the tough call on Monday to accept reality and go to Scarlett. Which as I said, is a great school, I know lots of kids that didn't get in, so kudos to him for getting in and to the Honors program. But then on Tuesday he got an email from Blue informing him he was accepted in to their Honors College. Great news, but sadly it changes nothing, and so Scarlett here he comes.

    it is breaking my heart that we can't make this happen for him, even though I know he will most likely end up happy wherever he goes.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hatethecold......try calling the "scholarship office" at Blue and ask if they can do anything. When I realized my daughter had missed out on a scholarship she would have qualified for, I called the large out of state public u and talked to someone. I told them it was her first choice school but it was more than our state school and could they offer her some $ to bridge the gap and they did! It wasn't a lot in the grand cost of college but it sealed the deal. Worth a try.


  • 9 years ago

    I didn't read any of the comments and am just replying to the original post. My older son is heading off to college this fall and has committed. The choice was his. I think his heart and head were involved in his decision. It is definitely a school he loves however his list of options was guided by head and heart. He considered internship availability, course of study, carreer placement, location, class size. He is pretty practical and pragmatic. He is also aware of our contribution and his potential debt load.

  • 9 years ago

    Hatethecold, I also agree with joanieponie.

    My parents were not exactly supportive of my education choices. I think some of this was a lack of understanding of what it all meant. But they also told all of us that if we wanted a car, a wedding reception, or college we would be funding it ourselves. So, I did.

  • 9 years ago

    Joanieponie and gsciencchick, we have been in touch with the Honors College, the FA office and everyone else we can think of, to no avail. :(

    I will make one final phone call, on Monday, but I don't expect anything to come from it. The gap is pretty significant, and since DS is talking med school, we need to minimize debt for undergrad. Thanks for the thoughts.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, unfortunately, there is far more financial need than what most places (other than the Ivy League and a few other schools) have financial aid and scholarships to cover. If we could get states to restore some of their funding to higher education, that would help a lot, but that ship has sailed.

  • 9 years ago

    The problem with most college students I see is they don't know how to combine their heart and head. It can be done. They should not be forced to go into a field they hate, but think seriously about how to turn what they love into something they can make a living doing. That is acquiring skills and experiences.

    I try to advise my students, who are liberal arts majors, to focus their out-of-class time on building a resume of skills, which you get through trying things and experience. Don't waste a summer working at a fast food joint unless you want to go into that field at a management level. Get jobs and experiences that build skills and build your resume, they are out there, even for sophomores or juniors. Students who wait til their senior year to think about getting a job after they graduate are at a disadvantage. Classes are training you how to think, volunteering, part time jobs and internships will show you how to apply what you learned. They need to mix the two. Good professors mentor students and point them to meaningful experience. I went to a huge state school and no one did that for me. Eventually I found out how to do it for myself. It took me six years to graduate, and figure out how to mix head and heart. The reason it took me so long is I went from music to biology, which I would have never dreamed of doing while in high school, so I had lots of makeup classes to take. I fell in love with biology while taking a field course over the summer for my gen. ed. requirement. Honestly I did it just for fun and thought I might meet some cute guys doing it. Instead I fell in love with ecology and have made a career in natural resources. My friends could not believe it. But if I hadn't been adventurous I never would have found my niche.

    I got a leg up job-wise after my ambitious room mate dragged me to a job fair, which was two months before school got out and I would have never thought about going if not for her. That's how most students are, they just pass through. Luckily I met this gal, and at the job fair I actually got hooked up with a summer job and met most of the movers and shakers in my field in the state through them sending me to a training program. All because my room mate noticed that there was a place in her home town that had a summer job opening with the same title as my major. She said I should apply for the experience of interviewing. I would have never dreamed they would hire me but they did. Being lucid can get you a long way in some fields, lol!

    Young people need mentors and if they just pass through school with their heads down, they will miss out on that valuable part. Getting a job and having a career is about building skills through experiences, and building relationships with people. Networking. Where you go to school is only part of the picture. The ability of the faculty to mentor and also the connections they have are important, as are the connections the institution has with the wider world. But some of it has to come from the student. Most higher education institutions have channels to get students hooked up with experience and mentoring, but students don't often either have the ambition or the ability to seek out help or know how to identify help when it is out there. I know I sure didn't. But it worked out in the end, I figured it out because I kept at it. One does not need to chose between head and heart, one has to reconcile the two, and that is a skill set also. A good college will help with the process, but it is a life long one.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    "It's not the school I'd have chosen for him, but it was his choice from the get go"

    bpathome, This is an exciting time for your son. He was accepted at his first choice school! Assuming you were ok with him applying there, why are you not happy with his choice? Your not getting accepted to your first choice school is not a comparison for your son's situation.

    Am I missing something?

    Our 3 children applied to several colleges and all ended up making the final decision themselves, yes to their top choice schools. They graduated within the 4 years; one was a 5 year program due to co-op. Two studied abroad. Two had co-op or internships that solidified their career choices. All are gainfully employed and are loyal to their alma marter. Were there some struggles along the way-you bet there were. Were they insurmountable? No, but we chalked it up to all part of the growing process. Undergraduate education is the part where our children need us the most, IMO. By graduate school, they need some guidance, but ultimately must make that decision on their own, and most likely are in a better position to do so.

    How was the process different with your older son?

    Watch Escape to the Country (loved that series!) and eat those jelly beans.

  • 9 years ago

    Bonnie, I honestly didn't think he'd get in! This was a curious process.

    At one school where I thought he was a shoe-in, he got into the university but not the program.

    Another waitlisted him and two weeks later admitted him with a scholarship. My favorite school waitlisted him till after the May 1 deadlines.

    Yet another admitted him probably as he left from his first interview and visit, the day after he applied. Pretty sure, because they gave him a t-shirt that said #Red School Bound!

    And so on.

    DH's and my favorite school would be a great choice if he wanted to commit to his other area of interest (and where we both think he has more passion and ability).

    DS' school of choice wanted him in the program, but general admissions had him jump through a couple of hoops. When he was admitted you could have knocked me over with a feather. But clearly they saw something in him, some potential, for the program. I'm excited about that, but nervous for him as well.

    My older son started his process a year sooner and had lots of friends in or headed to the same major, some to the same schools. By the time he finished his applications and heard back from all, he knew exactly where he wanted to go. And we were totally on board. (Yeah, I was a bit disappointed he didn't opt for the the school I wanted for him, but he made the right choice.)

  • 9 years ago

    Cyn, I wish I could give your post more than 1 Like.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Money is only unimportant if you have enough of it to provide for a reasonable standard of living. Being wealthy does not make you happier, once you reach a certain base level of living. But ask a person who cannot afford their rent how important money is and whether having more money would make them happier, and you will get a different answer to this question.

    There are so many ways to learn things and be an educated, well-rounded person without paying a very expensive college for a useless degree. IMO, it is unforgivable that we push every young person into doing whatever it takes (like going thousands into debt) just to get a piece of paper that doesn't even make them employable.

    Borrowing $50K a year to learn about things that you could learn about for free is a poor decision if you will struggle for the next ten to 30 years to repay that money and if substantial debt prevents you from fulfilling other life goals you may have had, like buying a house of your own, saving enough to have a reasonable standard of living during retirement, and having enough money to do things you enjoy.

  • 9 years ago

    My DD is an accountant after going through a community college. She graduated with distinction and then she had 7 large companies offer her a position. She was in competition with brilliant university students but through her hard work and dedication achieved as much as those students, if not more. I begged her to reconsider and go to university as we were paying for the schooling and she would have no debt. She kept saying she was fine where she was. She is a practical woman who simply puts herself into working hard and smart, and still helps others by tutoring and so on. She knew she would achieve what she wanted without a big uni. I am and was very glad she didn't listen to me. I couldn't be more proud. Your son will surprise you if you let him. Best to him.

  • 9 years ago

    I would agree with Cyn in spirit but I have to add it makes no FINANCIAL sense to go to a BIG BUCK University for say teaching. You come out with the same education but have paid thousands more for it--and in the end your salary possibilities/ job opportunities are the same as a small State public school. Do what you love--for sure no matter the end salary. And I agree I hope it isn't all about MEMEME accumulate as much for the sake of accumulating... For people where money isn't an issue, they or their parents have earned the freedom to do what ever they want..but for the vast majority of the populous making decisions that don't put a young person just starting out sooo far in debt they can't see the end of the tunnel is prudent.

  • 9 years ago

    Remember, too, that a student can always double major. We have plenty of them doing that at my medium sized university. For example, art history and business. Philosophy, which teaches you to think logically and critically, and act ethically, is often combined here with some aspect of business and much needed in the business world! As a university professor of +35 years, I'm a great believer in the value of the liberal arts for life, as well as the incredible value of study abroad.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Don't forget, too, that money won't be as cheap as it is now forever. Paying interest on an entire mortgage worth of student loans is a lot easier at 3% than it is at 19%. Speaking from the perspective of someone who had relatively little student debt from an American point of view, but that still kept me from getting established in my career of choice as I couldn't afford the low-paying internships I would have needed to get established. I was not a good planner!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I see this alluded to in the comments but I just want to make a point about importance of internships and career specific job experience while you are in college. A student can pursue these options on their own from anywhere but if they are in an academic environment where they are considered important, there are mechanisms in place that make the process easier.

    I have a recent grad. Friends who were lifeguards or waitresses during their summer breaks had a much harder time getting good jobs even with a desirable degree. And friends that went to schools with anemic career centers also had a much harder time.

    This advice is, of course, for kids that want to travel a conventional path to adulthood. Four years of school that will lead to a good paying job.

  • 9 years ago

    Interesting point Arcy. Yet......a good friend's daughter went to a top university and majored in English. She worked for five years in the publishing field, then went back for her masters so she could teach. This was always her plan.

    I believe that top ranked schools come into play when there is a choice to make between applicants.

    More info: My friend's daughter was valedictorian of her class. She wanted to go to a specific Ivy but did not get in. She then decided on the very top ranked school. Her dad felt, why put herself through debt since it wasn't the Ivy that she originally wanted?

    Here's the thing though: Sometimes self-esteem comes into play. She wanted to go to a college with peers! A school that would challenge her. A school filled with valedictorians like herself. She also wanted to feel proud of her college choice.

    It is true that majors are offered and there is little potential for employment when push comes to shove. Universities and colleges are a business, but I think people more and more are holding them accountable for the end results.

    Yes it is so important to be well rounded and open to new thoughts and ideas. At the same time, as Beagles mentioned above, it's only good if you can support yourself.

  • 9 years ago

    My daughter went to the local community college for two years and got her general ed out of the way. Then she transferred to a local state university and got into the broadcasting program. For two years she took a full load, worked part-time and had a non-paying internship in her field. Two years later she graduated with a job offer in her field through her internship. Relatively small student loan which got repaid in a few years. She loves what she does and she's good at it. There are many paths that lead to happiness and a satisfying career.

  • 9 years ago

    Robo brings up a good point. When I first starting paying back my student loans, the rate was something like 8%! I was able to refinance them to something like 4%, and I paid them off 5 years ago. But that is where interest rates were at the time. My first car loan in the late 90's the same time was also something like 8% and this was through the credit union. And I had excellent credit. Still, there were nights I sat home and had eggs for dinner because I had car payment, loan payment, and rent due at the same time. Fortunately, that didn't last too long and my salary did go up because we got an annual percent and merit raises at that employer. In a couple of years I was able to buy a small townhouse and had my car paid. I still have my Mustang 20 years later, LOL.

    All our students do a a full-semester internship, but we are facilitating to get them to do more major-related work experience and job shadowing before they get there, engaging them in the major and across campus. Still, we have a lot in retail or restaurants. Yes, you can do that but you also have to do things in your major.

    Double majors are good, and it is pretty easy for students to add a minor or two because classes can count for both major and minor though not across multiple minors--got that? Popular minors include health, coaching, business, entrepreneurship, human nutrition, health care management, gerontology, and biology.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    ...if everyone were to choose a school, a major, a job based on whether or not it will lead to lucrative career, the world would be a much poorer place.

    Indeed! As long as kids are making these choices with eyes wide open, and understand the range of likely/possible outcomes. My DS has said "money doesn't really matter to me", to which I say "good". But I also asked him to think about exactly what that means. I think for him it means something like "I don't need a Rolex and yacht" or some silly Thurston Howell-ish idea of money. Years ago I volunteered to teach inner city kids about money management. One of the exercises was to pick a car (odd since we were in NYC but anyway) and place to live, price them, determine the income needed to afford them, and determine what jobs/careers might generate such an income. I don't know if every 18 yr old really understands what it takes to support what they personally regard as a modest lifestyle.

    For people where money isn't an issue.

    Taking this out of context, but it reminds me of career advice I often give. I have often said that the best skill a kid can develop is the ability to enjoy a modest lifestyle (yes, I say this, but I do not model this). It gives one tremendous flexibility and freedom. In fact, there are only two ways to feel free from stress about money. Either have a lot of it, or don't care if you do. I know a number of people who never got "caught up in the rate race" and it is indeed freeing.

    PS I also believe in liberal arts ed, esp in a fast changing world. Generally people who are looking for lucrative careers are talking grad school. So liberal arts is for undergrad, "vocational" ed is for grad school.

  • 9 years ago

    Mtn, in one of our classes, we have students do that. So many say they want to own their own clinic, gym, etc., so we have them fully develop a facility plan as a semester project. They have to evaluate commercial real estate (some even go in person), price equipment, develop a staffing plan, learn about benefits, payroll, taxes, budgeting, risk management. It is quite the eye opener for many of them.

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, Gscience, that is such a good idea.

    When I was in HS, my Dad had each of us take a turn managing the the household checking account for 3 months. I think it was brilliant. I was really shocked how much dumb things like water and electricity cost!

    Not quite the same today with all the auto-pay!

  • 9 years ago

    "I would agree with Cyn in spirit but I have to add it makes no FINANCIAL sense to go to a BIG BUCK University for say teaching. You come out with the same education but have paid thousands more for..."

    For, say, teaching? Really? To me, this is a perfect example of how little respect people have for teachers. Instead of that statement about how we really shouldn't bother going to a top tier school, how about one that would push for teachers to be paid what their job is worth to every citizen? Not one of us would be where we are if not for teachers. I never had to worry about student debt, but if I had, I would still have chosen as I did. My grad school was my job education, my undergrad was my life education.

  • 9 years ago

    My older son wasn't sure if he wanted to go onto school after high school. So I had him do a budgeting exercise. Go through the employment pages and see what kind of hourly rate you will get for high school education and it worked out to about $15/hr. Then I had him research all his expenses and see what that will cost him. When he brought me the budget he had forgotten things such as cost of his contacts, tenants insurance, bus pass (no car on $15/hr), etc. He didn't have enough money for a beer at the end of the month.

    I had him do the same exercise on a two year associate degree earning $20/hr and in both cases he really couldn't do it and he certainly couldn't live in the way he was brought up or in the way he wanted to live.

    It was a real eye-opener for him. He has just bought his first place and the budgeting that kid did to show us he could afford it was heart-warming. :)

    Anyway, I'm not saying that a nice life can't be had on those wages, I'm just saying that like MtnRd's dad did, going through a budget process at a young age can be a real learning experience.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    cyn - is it worth it to accrue like $200,000 in debt realistically if you know you want to teach for $60 or $70K a year? I'm speaking from the perspective of someone who had to go into debt for university. From my perspective, no, it's not worth it. $30,000 debt was hard enough, imagine paying $350 debt payments per month on my post-school starter job of $15 an hour. I did it but I had to move back home and give up some dreams. $200,000 would have been completely crippling. You could have a great undergrad experience at a state school and be earning the exact same amount when you come out for much less debt. Your quality of life for the next 20 years after university would be radically different.

    In my province teachers are well paid for their education level, starting at $45K and going up to >$100K for principals. That's good money for 10 months (equivalent of starting at $54K for 12 months). But also our university tuition and fees are only $8000-$10,000CAD per year (not including residence) so the math works out a lot better.

  • 9 years ago

    Instead of that statement about how we really shouldn't bother going to a top tier school, how about one that would push for teachers to be paid what their job is worth to every citizen?

    I agree 1,000%. I doubt anyone here would disagree. Teachers in our country today are underpaid and under-respected, if you will. I don't think there is a more important profession in a country's future, especially a country that is a democracy.

    Of course, you can't bash someone for being on-topic. And it is on-topic to say that, given the current pay scale, a teacher should consider if they want to burden themselves with a higher debt for a "better?" education when it may not be compensated. They are already sacrificing a lot.

  • 9 years ago

    Mtn....what a great idea your dad had! I wish we had done more to educate our kids about finances. We did to an extent, but fortunately they have learned a lot on their own and are all very prudent money managers.

    blfenton....our youngest was very ambivalent about going to college....thought it was stupid, he wouldn't fit in with a drinking/fraternity crowd, etc.. I did a lot of research to find a college for what he wanted to major in at the time...an unusual major.....and the classes started freshman year, so no going to the community college here first then transferring there which probably would have better suited him and been fine with me.

    Well, he came around when one of his good friends, a year older, graduated. He was from a poor family so there was no going to even the comm college. He got a job at a warehouse making minimum wage. We talked about "Ben" a lot and did my son want a life making low wages, barely scraping by just to pay for necessities...forget about vacations. How he was fortunate we were able to pay for him to go to college and that education is the key to a more comfortable life. It was a tough sell...he's my altruistic save the world I don't give a fig about $ child....but he went to college...then accepted a job starting that August at a nonprofit for $12,000 a year in....Boston! We tried to tell him $12,000 just about anywhere, and certainly Boston, was not enough to live on. I'll be fine mom. Luck intervened and he was offered another job for $25,000 in Chicago...still not great but more doable. He's now making a lot more and though he still doesn't care about nor will ever make a ton of $ he now appreciates that earning a decent wage allows him to go out to eat, travel, drive a later model reliable car, contribute to a 401k for his old age, etc.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    beagles I liked this pair of comments on your article. I wish I could explain things like this to people at work. Not sure the executive directors would appreciate the tone, however.

    "You show a Phd in education as earning only about $90,000.00 after twenty years. How old is this data? Seven years ago when I retired, I was easily making that much with a Bachelor's degree. Were i still working, I know I would be at least 10% above this figure now. Mind you I am happily retired with a defined benefit pension plan which pays a COLA clause every year."

    "Ooops, they made a statistical error. Instead of reporting your personal salary in Canada with a Canadian degree, they actually only included median salaries for U.S. graduates and didn't take into account individuals' personal feelings. They shouldn't have hidden this information in a section titled "Methodology", because who would look there?"

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    There is some evidence (I don't know how credible) to show that actually going to an Ivy doesn't confer a lifetime salary advantage. Although Ivy graduates tend to earn much more on average, it seems that being the TYPE of person that goes to an ivy is what conveys a huge lifetime advantage (high SATs, high social capital). The exception is relatively disadvantaged students ("the students who fell into this category were Latino, black, and low-income students, as well as those whose parents did not graduate from college") who probably benefit from the networking opportunities their families cannot provide (and who hopefully are not paying much tuition).

    https://www.usnews.com/education/blogs/the-college-solution/2011/03/01/the-ivy-league-earnings-myth

    Based on the same research, but a little more depth https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2004/10/who-needs-harvard/303521/

  • 9 years ago

    Good point about internships above. My DS (the one who is just finishing jr year of college) has had great internships since the summer after his sr year of high school. Two summers at DH's company, which is well regarded in the business/finance world, then an accounting/finance internship at a small investment firm, and now, because he is double majoring in finance and supply chain management, he felt like he really needed/wanted a supply chain internship this summer. Not too easy to find, but he did get one. Unfortunately it's a lousy/long commute and very little pay, but they have assured him that he will get valuable experience in all areas of supply chain management. By the time he graduates, he will have worked for 3 very different companies. Not to mention the part-time jobs he has had at different times during the school year (neither related to his major, but work experience nonetheless).

    Another note: Have your kids approach companies even if they don't advertise internships. The internship my DS has this summer was created for him after he wrote to the company (with a connection supplied by a neighbor of ours).

  • 9 years ago

    it seems that being the TYPE of person that goes to an ivy is what conveys a huge lifetime advantage (high SATs, high social capital)

    This intuitively makes sense.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    There are programs that will forgive student debt in return for a certain number of years in a job that provides service such as some non-profs. It may be that teaching in a Title 1 school as I do would qualify.

    I am still in the camp of follow your heart.

    Robo, in my area the $90,000 figure for a PH.D. is pretty accurate these days. In my district it would be very slightly more at the 20-year mark. Administrators make more even without a doctoral degree. New teachers start in the mid-40s if they have only a BA or BS. and to think I started at $17,000 with a Master of Ed. degree...and as a single parent! Oh and I completely agree with your comment about the "type" of person. I also wonder how much the "old boy network" enables graduates from elite schools to get those higher paying jobs. A foot in the door can be a big help.

  • 9 years ago

    what a great thread!!

    will take me some time to read all the comments, which I'll do for sure as I'm very invested in this subject right now (DD is in an university, third year-transferred after 2 years of community college, she's in sciences, namely pre-immunology and biology of the cell..very passionate about biology since middle school..DS is in his junior year of high school, applications this coming fall..still deciding..passionate about learning everything except art but prefers sciences a bit more..less of a very strong passion for some specific field, but more of the ability to concentrate on everything pretty well..learning itself is enjoyable to him. Soccer is also lol)

    My short answers: yes, I do. Most definitely. a bit of a struggle since my ex is a bit different in that regard..harder for him to separate his goals from kids' goals..his passions from theirs.

    (btw I'm probably the worst in sciences and math out of all my huge family. It's like the nature decided to rest a bit..when it came to my creation..))

    As for myself..yes..I probably did modify it somewhat. But I find all my strong interests that are several, ones that appeared before I started university, and others long time after-are inter related in many many ways..some more some less obvious.

    My parents never pushed me too. They did push me to learn. And to do the best I can in whatever I choose/am given. That, they did.

    I'm grateful for that, and that's what I try to do for my kids.

    Now, I'm going to read you guys, yay!

  • 9 years ago

    robo, further upthread I wrote,

    "We'll never know if the fact that both sons's degrees from our country's top rated university, meant MORE than their actual fields of study, (to their employers) or whether they just got very, very lucky and aced their interviews.

    and you replied,

    "I haven't really noticed University playing a huge role in Canada in hiring outside of academia..."

    Yes, I was referring to University of Toronto. U. of T. was #1 rated at the time, with McGill next, although I believe they reverse quite often and McGill is now ranked number one. I agree, with your opinion, and feel that going to the top ranked universities here, probably makes less of a difference than graduating from them in the States, overall. But one certainty is that my sons were very lucky to parlay their philosophy and fine art degrees into something that worked for them!

  • 9 years ago

    Just thinking about this one more time. I've been going to one hair stylist for about 15 years now. When I first met her, she said she'd been cutting hair for 15 years. I asked if she started when she was 5. Well, close. She'd always known she wanted to be a hair stylist, and when she was 15 she did a dual-enrollment at her high school: high school in the morning, beautician college in the afternoon. When she graduated from high school, she also had her beautician's license. When all her friends were heading off to summer jobs or college or looking for work, she started at a salon the day after graduation.

    DH's brother knew at the age of 5 that he wanted to be a doctor. And he is.

    My younger son, from age 2-6, wanted to be a chef on a train. Today he is still afraid to pull a pizza from the oven.

    It can be a good thing to know your heart. It can also be good to know your limitations. But DS could still surprise me and become a chef, he's surprised me a lot.

  • 9 years ago

    Oh, thanks bpathome, for coming back and sharing your current thinking.

    I'll add a bit from my story. I really did not pursue the thing that really caught my interest (architecture and design) but rather drifted to a pre-STEM major. It was something I was interested in, and was very good at, as opposed to something that perhaps held my interest even more, but where I felt I was not as talented (and I was strong across most subjects, from comp lit to linear algebra). Throughout college, I had a full slate of extracurricular and leadership activities, in addition to internships. Rather than continuing on immediately to grad school, I ended up in high tech. However, because I had strong communication skills in addition to a STEM degree, I pretty quickly found myself in business-related roles. I found my sweet spot, perhaps by accident, where capability and interest intersected. It proved to more lucrative than I ever imagined (modest comfort was the goal).

    My childhood friend had a parallel path, with the same classes and she eventually graduated and got placed in a good job in high tech. But she found her passion in her church and in raising her family -- and she too found her happiness -- so there are many different paths.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    I am very late to this conversation but I only wish that I had had some of the "life budgeting" lessons when choosing my first path. As it turned out, I had the "awakening" in grad school. I was in the middle of my second year of a highly competitive Phd program .. one that combined math, zoology, psychology and robotics. Cutting edge at the time in my area of study. The average time to achieve a Phd in the program was 13 yr. Upon leaving the program, you typically went into a post doc program.. hopefully at a leading university in the field-- maybe making $35k. That would have put me in my mid 30s making less than my peers were making fresh out of college in their 20s. I realized I didn't have that kind of commitment to the science. I liked nice things, I wanted to travel, I didn't want to be a slave to what was then my passion.

    At the same time, I also became very aware of the politics in university science programs and research. I had overheard a well-known researcher (my idol when I was an undergraduate) talking to my advisor-- bartering favors for a good review of his soon to be published paper. As a grown up, I get it.. but as a student it was distasteful. The two experiences caused me to leave the program.

    I've been fairly lucky.. I was able to find a new career path where I could use my analytical skills outside of science.. but it wasn't an easy path and it took some major turns along the way.

    The truth is, I had aptitude in a number of areas. I had high enough SAT scores in both verbal and math that I could have gotten into any of a number of college programs (Not likely ivy schools-- but certainly a tier below). I just wish I'd received more practical guidance. I had plenty of support and encouragement.. but I think my counselors (family, hs, and college) were every bit as idealistic as I was.. and/or they trusted me to drive.