Is the photo the color it is now?

yes, that's revere pewter.

What color is your roof?

Dark Gray

The visualizer is picking up a lot of yellow from your image. Here is what I got for Cape May Cobblestone.

...not working. When this happens I manipulate the color to get something near to what you want. On the right is Cape May Cobblestone for comparison. I got something close to it but not exact. I think it will appear darker on the house. Here is a bluer gray. Sorry I could not help more, sometimes the magic brush just doesn't work it's magic.

Thanks so much. I think the sun is making the roof look red (and the fact that the gutters are gone). I'm going to keep the shutters and door black. I was thinking navy but going to stick with black. I'm hoping for a more saturated, grayer revere pewter so hopefully this fits the bill. Thanks again.

I have Cape May Cobblestone on my exterior and it's beautiful with my charcoal gray roof. It tends to look darker on one side where there is no direct sunlight. It's really a nice color with my black front door. I highly recommend this color.

Gail - what color is your door

Black

I love it with my black door but Hale Navy would also look great

Dont know the exact shade of black because door was bought painted