Software
Houzz Logo Print
izeve

Fabric softeners reviews - recent purchases :-)

9 years ago
last modified: 9 years ago

A few weeks ago I used up the last of Up&up Spring Bloom softener and was terribly disappointed to find out that it was discontinued. As most of you know, I've been on the quest to find something similar over the last couple of weeks. In the interest of full disclosure, I have a very sensitive nose and some scents give me headaches, so my reviews may be skewed :-)

Downy - I bought two Downy products from the Infusions line: Botanical Mist and Amber Blossom. The scent is strong in both flavors. Botanical Mist is quite unpleasant after drying. Amber Blossom is not as sweet, so it's borderline acceptable. The biggest problem is the coated feel of the items after drying. Towels are not absorbent and things are more difficult to iron (I iron a lot). I think these two will need to go.

Snuggle - I bought the Lavender and Sandalwood flavor. I used it in the past but this version is much sweeter and leaves a candy-like flavor after drying. Not great. I think there was also some change in the consistency because items come out feeling soft but rather limp. Weird.

Kirkland - bought this on the recommendation of a lot of you who said that the scent and texture is very similar to Spring Bloom. The jury is still out on this one. The scent is similar but not the same as Spring Bloom. No coated or limp feel, so that's good. I'll continue using it and see if I get used to it.

Great Value Spring something scent - smelled it in the store and didn't buy because the scent was off putting for me - like Spring Bloom gone bad.

Purex softeners - I used them in the past so I went to a local grocery store that carries them. This time I didn't like any of the scents so I ended up not buying it.

Aldi Tandil Springtime scent - This one is the winner! The scent is very very close to Spring Bloom. After drying, there is no residual sweetness, just a nice fresh light scent. The feel is also good, no coating or limpness. There were two versions of this in the store with different caps (one plain, one flower shaped). I got the one with the flower shaped cap because I think that's what the Spring Bloom had? I was a bit concerned because mamapinky said it smelled like animal fat but I didn't detect any of that. So if you are on the quest to find a replacement for Spring Bloom, I recommend that you try it.

ETA: all washes were done with Tide Free and Clear so as to avoid mixing of scents from detergent and softener. Having said that, my favorite combination in the past was Persil tabs (not liquid, which I think smells vile) and Spring Bloom, so I have to try that with the Aldi softener and see if it is the same.

Comments (14)

  • 9 years ago

    I agree...I cannot find a Downy or Snuggle scent that I really love, or at least really like!! Some are "better" than others, but none great....most are horrid!!!

    I think Kirkland/Costco softener is fantastic. A long time ago, MamaPinky sent me some Aldi Tandil softener. I do not remember if I liked it or not, but it seems to be getting a lot of love recently!

  • 9 years ago

    I could not get near any of those fabric softeners or those scents. I would never use Downy though -- I know, I know -- many love it. Fine with me.

    I've settled on Ecover which works well, doesn't over soften, has a pleasant very gentle fragrance and is fairly green.

    I've never used fabric softener until I got new towels which were impossible without it. This has been discussed many times.

  • 9 years ago

    Larsi no you did not like the Tandil at that time, you also could smell the fat. Lol

  • 9 years ago

    Larsi, I'd be happy to send you some Tandil to try. We could even devise some blind test method so that you're not influenced by the origin.... :-)

    I'm wondering if Aldi changed the formula recently - as I said, there were bottles with plain pink caps and bottles with the flower shape on the top. The flower shape seems new. Maybe they took all the Spring Bloom that Target didn't want any more and just slapped the Tandil label on it???

  • 9 years ago

    Here's a picture of it. Seems exactly the same as Spring Bloom.

  • 9 years ago

    This is a past bottle of Tandil FS

    can't see the top of the lid.


  • 9 years ago

    I have found many bottle and lid designs the same but the contents are different.

  • 9 years ago

    Closer look and maybe that's not Tandil next to Tandil detergent.

  • 9 years ago

    This is my pic from 2015, but cant see the lid

  • 9 years ago

  • 9 years ago

    Hmm, interesting mamapinky. The bottle seems different - there's a little fold or indentation in yours above the label but mine is totally smooth. Next time I'm in Aldi I'll have a closer look at the other bottle.

  • 9 years ago

    I did a bit of rooting..Tandil FS used to be called Satin Soft when Aldi first came to the US.

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you izeve. Yes, I remember when MamaP sent me some Tandil softener a while ago, it made the clothes smell slightly of rancid animal fat :-O Looks like they changed name, bottle and hopefully formula!!