I would remove the shutters and go with deep/rich grey or wood doors. The style really depends if you want glass or not, but either way I would lean towards a classic style.

I really like urbane bronze...would that work?

all shutters or just larger window?

I would remove all of the shutters...if you want more of a classic look. It would be great if someone who read this post was able to remove the shutters visually with a program, so you could see.