Software
Houzz Logo Print
sylviagrace

Sudden Cucumber Leaf Discoloration

9 years ago

Hi everyone!

This is my first year growing cucumbers! Everything was going great until yesterday, when I noticed a slight tan discoloration on one of the middle aged leaves on one of my plants as well as around the main veins of another leaf. It looked like a powder had formed on top, but it felt like regular leaf. Since I was confused I tried to clean part of the most affected leaf with a little bit of water and patted it dry the best I could (which didn't work, and probably wasn't the best of ideas). Today when I went to water the part of the leaf I got wet was brown and shriveled up, which I was not surprised to see. What did surprise me was that the color spread over the leaf with color around the veins and others that looked perfectly fine yesterday! My plant went from one that got compliments for being beautiful to one screaming for help in two days. What can I do for it?


(Also, if anyone could tell me what type of cucumber this is I'd appreciate it. I got it from someone who said it came from a local farm that didn't tell her what it is beyond saying it's a cucumber.)

Comments (16)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    And again, my plant has declined significantly overnight! The leaf in the top picture has wilted, and the tan has spread. It now looks like this...

    The tan has also spread on the other affected leaves, with another wilting and curling in to a lesser degree:

    Here is the whole plant:

    The problem seemed to start with the leaf at the top of this post and the leaf I sprayed with water, and it's spreading like wildfire. Can anything be done?

  • 9 years ago

    No pictures yet today due to rain, but now somewhere between 66% and 75% of the leaves have tan coloring. Someone has suggested a nutrient deficiency, which is a possibility since I water heavily and have never fertilized as well as having other plants showing symptoms of a deficiency. But could that cause a problem this sudden that moves this fast?

  • 9 years ago

    Thank you for replying! The virus comes close, but there's a few key symptoms that don't match. The color has started at the biggest veins of the leaves and then spread over the rest of the leaf from there, and from what I've been able to see the leaves are wilted and not brittle. I have an irrational phobia of dead leaves so I haven't been able to touch them with my bare hands, but light prodding with a twig has shown only a few places that are slightly hardened.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Some leaves do look like they have a case of PM, but there's most definitely something else going on.

    Dead or alive, I find it quite unpleasant to touch cucumber leaves and stems. :\

  • 9 years ago

    Yeah, not one of my favorite plants to handle but I don't have too big of a problem with them. I pulled up and tore off the trellis my cucumber vines a week or so ago..downy mildew along with pickle worms showing up had done'em in. It was a 10' long trellis 5' high. Even though I don't pay a lot of attention to the "itchy-ness" there was enough there that I was glad when I had all those vines tucked inside the big green garbage can!!!

  • 9 years ago

    I enjoy the feel of cucumber leaves and stems when they're alive, but all dead domesticated plants set me off. Houseplants and garden plants alike, they all make me cringe. Which makes it kinda funny that I love vegetable gardening, with the plants dying every year.

    Here's my cucumber today. It still seems to have life left in it, but it's down to two OK leaves and one barely affected leaf. Can a cucumber survive defoliation like this?

  • 9 years ago

    No just pull it. It can't survive much less produce anything in that condition.

    Dave

  • 9 years ago

    Iit says you are in zone 4 and its about that time of year here in zone 4. I don't really get much production past mid August and pending on weather they will start to die off pretty soon.here. My summer squash are already showing powdery mildew signs which they always start to do about the first week of august

  • 9 years ago

    Here growing season usually lasts through September. I've been very unlucky with my garden this year though. There's this cucumber that's had a very difficult time, another cucumber that's doing much better but is aborting fruit (I'm thinking a nutritional deficiency is to blame, but I don't know what I need to correct), and an Early Girl tomato that's doing OK but has only produced four fruits so far that have yet to ripen. Bugs won't leave my basil alone, and after a harvest it has yet to start bouncing back. The salad greens I started from seed and the broccoli are all doing alright, and the lettuce is absolutely thriving *knock on wood* minus two plants that died for no apparent reason.

    I'll take more pictures of my other cucumber tomorrow when I tend to the ill one. I can tell that the leaves are trying to tell me something, but I don't know enough to read them. There is some bug damage on most of the leaves, and probably some storm damage too. Am I missing anything?

  • 9 years ago

    I'm exhausted right now so pics will hopefully come later. The group that gave me the cucumber plants suggested that the ill one has cucumber mosaic virus and that the best course of action would indeed be to pull it to save the other plants. As sad as this makes me I suppose it's what I have to do. There's one flower on it that looks good, I'm thinking of picking it and saving it on my plant "souvenir" shelf. At least I'll have that. :(

    My other cucumber looks alright, but it appears to have signs of a very mild PM infestation. I'm thinking of fertilizing it, and it's time to spray everything down for bugs. Does anyone have suggestions on the best fertilizer for cucumbers producing fruit, and on the best natural treatment for PM? Also, is there anything besides bug spraying I can do to prevent CMV from reaching my healthy plants?

  • 9 years ago

    Did they look at the plant before saying it has CMV or were they just guessing? CMV has very distinctive appearance and your photos show no signs of that. What "bugs" are you spraying for and what are you spraying?

    Dave

  • 9 years ago

    I showed them the same pictures I posted here, and one of them stopped by to look in person today. I'm honestly doubting the diagnosis just based on a Google image search, but I'm not seeing any pictures matching what's going on. The dead leaves have been removed. I'm torn between pulling the plant and letting it stay for a bit to see if it bounces back.

    In all honesty I'm not sure what all is chewing on my plants. I've seen spider mites hanging out on the tomato and occasionally on the healthy cucumber. Ants are everywhere, and there's the potential for aphids coming from the trees around my house. The spray I have now is a handmade mix of garlic, dried hot peppers, onion, dish soap, and water.

  • 9 years ago

    Ok I assume you know that homemade concoctions like that can be just as damaging to plants as any commercial product can, especially when used inappropriately? That spray alone could be the cause of your problems in the photos above.

    Are you familiar with the basic 3 rules of pest control that we often discuss here?

    1. you must ID the specific pest

    2. you have to evaluate the damage they do. Is it really so severe that intervention is required?

    3. you then choose the least toxic remedy listed as specific for that pest.

    So far all you have ID'd is some spider mites. Ants are not a garden pest (except for fire ants) and can often be beneficial, at worst, neutral. Aphids are not normally associated with trees. They are a domestic crop pest. So do you know for a fact you have aphids?

    Can you attest to this homemade mix actually killing the spider mites? They are quite difficult to eradicate even with commercial products if there is a bad infestation so homemade remedies usually have little effect on them. And a "few" spider mites pose no real threat to most plants.

    The mix you describe would have to be a contact pesticide as there are no systemic effects in any of those contents. That means it could only work if you sprayed it directly on the bug. Otherwise it is just a waste of time and potentially damaging the plant leaves in the process. Anything that coats the leaves can suffocate the leaves by blocking the surface pores and no O2/CO2 exchange happens and cells begin to die.

    I'd suggest you set the spray aside until you can actually ID what, if any, bug problems you have and consider doing some hand picking and squishing instead of spraying the whole plant, Then instead focus on the nutrient/soil issues your plants are telling you about. In the pics your soil appears awfully compacted and wet so heavy soil amending and re-evaluating your watering habits is in order. Then sit down and evaluate your fertility program - what nutrient sources you provide, in what form and how frequently. See if you don't pick up on some clues there.

    Hope this helps.

    Dave

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, I'm aware of the potential affects of any sprays. This particular spray is intended to be a repellant and a contact pesticide. My method of spraying has been to never cover the whole leaf, since when I spray small areas of the leaf insects have stayed away from the entire thing including areas that weren't sprayed. Interestingly enough, the cucumber plant that went tan is one of the plants that I didn't spray at all. As for aphids, I have seen them on the backs of my cottonwoods' lower leaves, and sometimes on the lilac bushes. All of which are in easy reach of the garden.

    Watering has been a difficult balancing act as of late due to daily heavy rains the past couple weeks or so. I haven't watered at all the last three or four days since the soil has appeared soaked. The healthy cucumber is definitely trying to tell me about an issue, but I'm not entirely sure what. I've never fertilized since before now everything seemed to be doing well, but it's time now. As for soil, what should I do with that?