Software
Houzz Logo Print
alanna_migliacci

What Lemon variety should I get?

9 years ago

I live in NY and I want another container lemon. I'd like a good hearty producer and something that will grow to a decent size. Both of my Meyer lemons grow soooo slow and are so tiny (I'm thinking about air layering the main branch off of the dwarfing rootstock to speed growth, crazy idea?). What do you recommend? This is what I already have:

Meyer

Persian lime

Key lime

Miho satsuma

Tango

Comments (47)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    New Zealand Lemonade tree. I have 2. What zone are you. Are you NY, NY or just NY^

    Steve

  • 9 years ago

    New Zealand lemonade is definitely on my list! I just have track one down. I stalk Four Winds weekly. I also need another regular everyday lemon. I use about a dozen a week in juice and tea. im in zone. I'm in zone 6a, about 45 mins north of ny,ny.

  • 9 years ago

    Feminello, if in good condition, it will have lemons twice a year. They are good size, and awesome aroma

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Are you near the AT. I hike through there in 1990 from Maine to Georgia.

    Steve

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, there are several of the AT segments near me. I picked tons of wild blueberries on one for my birthday. There not very popular these day, so you always have the trail to yourself.

  • 9 years ago

    Susan, I've never heard of a Feminello. Where are they available?

  • 9 years ago

    Awesome info Silica. Matter of fact I would love to add Femminello Zagara Bianca. Of course not available in the USA. This variety supposedly blooms four times a year. All white flowers and the best in taste. Yup, lots of trees but like I said if I can fine something special, I would make room :)

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Maybe I'm lucky and this is one of the common market lemons in Italy? I have two seedlings named Laura and Rosa :) Both look a bit different from each other.

  • 9 years ago

    Wow 4 and 5 blooms a year! Even indoors? I've seen the Santa Teresa on the FWG website, but there is very little info about it. I was learning towards a Eureka, but how do I find other Femminellos?

  • 9 years ago

    After some google research, I can safely say: I want all the Italian lemons! I am so jealous of people who can just go to Costco and find amazing citrus varieties. My current wish list is:

    New Zealand lemonade

    Santa Teresa or any femminello variety I can find

    golden nugget

    kishnu

    I already have 2 Meyers, Persian lime, Key lime, Tango, and Satsuma.

    I'm supposed to move soon and I'm going to need a separate truck just for my plants.


  • 9 years ago

    While we are discussing lemons...I clearly grow all of mine in containers. I've been disappointed with my exceptionally slow Meyer lemon growth and I've read that I should have purchased a non dwarf variety and they will just stay smaller because of the container. I've also read that I should get a semi dwarf Eureka and not a dwarf, but I've heard that there is no such thing as a true dwarf Eureka because they are incompatible with dwarfing rootstock. So much conflicting information on the internets these days. What's a girl to do when she wants to grow her on citrus?

  • 9 years ago

    You may want to check Stan Mackenzie farms for the NZ. I heard he had it, as well as finger limes, but does not have them listed on his site.

    Costco.com also has a few citrus.

    Bear in mind some places may be out of stock until spring.

  • 9 years ago

    All Meyer lemons are dwarfs and grow like bushes no mater the root stock.

    Steve

  • 9 years ago

    What is your fert. schedule on the meyer?

  • 9 years ago

    My Meyer in July before repotted and set straight. Looks like a tree to me ;)

  • 9 years ago

    Is your Meyer originally a cutting? I don't actually know the differences in growth rate for cuttings versus those grafted on a rootstock but I live in NY zone 7 and my Meyer was profusely throwing up vertical shoots during July and August. Until I hacked almost of all of them down haha.

    I recently read a published article about nitrogen uptake by citrus and they use the most nitrogen during leaf expansion and shoot growth. So maybe timing of your fertilizer and the amount you apply may help. In their data, the dry weight yield of the plant plateaus at a certain point but it decreased when they received 200mg or more N per liter of nutrient solution.

    Good luck with your Meyer. I like the characteristic tree/bushing of the Meyer and want mine to look like Susanne's tree!

  • 9 years ago

    So what does the F stand for in FN?

  • 9 years ago

    Fertilizer Nitrogen :D there were a lot of terms and units I had to go back and find reference for too

    Here's the link:

    http://journal.ashspublications.org/content/119/2/195.full.pdf

    One of the few shorter papers and really interesting! It talked about whether the trees used N the most during root growth or shoot growth because a separate paper by other scientists showed that it used more N during root growth periods..if I'm remembering right


  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Hurry to four winds! they just got Santa Teresas and New Zealand Lemonades in stock! as well as Genoas and Varigated pink lemons. I just ordered mine!

  • 9 years ago

    What they test can help change around fertilization timings if someone wants to try it out especially if you foliar spray and use fast acting synthetic fertilizers. I don't use either yet so I can't test any of this myself

  • 9 years ago

    Omg..nnoo I also want a New Zealand Lemonade but I can't afford to get anything :'( snag that tree and show us pictures when you get it Alanna!

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Thanks, but I don't think it stands for the word "Fertilizer" perhaps "Foliar". The article does a poor job of explaining the meaning of "F".

  • 9 years ago

    Susanne your Meyer is a beautiful tree very nice shape . It was in a very handsome pot .

    Brian

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Kvetch, I don't know if it counts for anything but FW has had NZL a few times in the last year and its been nearly a year and a half since they've had the ST. So you might get lucky and they will have it in stock later! the prices are so high for shipping (and I'm on the west coast ) that I held off on getting a Genoa and a few figs I had been eyeing.

  • 9 years ago

    I just did a stock check and they only have two left. I hope you guys end up getting one. *fingers crossed* I am so happy that I was at my computer when the email notification was sent. they sell out so damn fast.

  • 9 years ago

    In the screenshot I attached it says "Fig.4. Fertilizer N (FN) uptake per gram..."

    They used different concentrations of added nitrogen in a nutrient solution so they are labeling it as "Fertilizer" because it was N added through a liter of nutrients

  • 9 years ago

    Already sold out of the ST.So glad I already have some :)

  • 9 years ago

    I was outside and didn't have my phone! I can't believe I missed it. Should I still buy the NZ lemonade tree or wait for the ST? I really can't afford either, nor do I have the space!

  • 9 years ago

    In the "Materials and Methods" section, they explain how it was applied

    "During Expt 1, the plants were fertilized daily through drip rings with liter of either...." The difference in experiment 1 and 2 was just the milligram concentrations of nitrogen in the solution dripped. They also describe above that they flushed the containers with deionized water daily for 5 days to remove pretreatment N before applying their solution so I believe FN refers to their specific nitrogen concoction. I hope that was enough to explain it wasn't foliar. If it says somewhere else that might suggest it was foliar then let me know, sometimes I get tired of reading papers multiple times lol

    Sammers, I will leave the trees for you and Alanna :) I don't actually use lemons in cooking much but I chose the Meyer because at least the flowers are supposed to smell amazing even if I don't grow lemons. So it was a practical pick for me, but I would love to try eating/drinking lemonade in fruit form! One day in the future, I'll definitely get the nzl



  • 9 years ago

    Should I get a genoa instead or just wait for the ST? Like I said, I don't NEED it right now and if a Santa Teresa is really a better variety I can try and be patient.

  • 9 years ago

    Alana then wait??? I will try to air layer some next year. If you do not have one by then, I will send you one. (if the rooting works out ;). )

  • 9 years ago

    Alanna, my 2 cents is if you can swing it get the NZL. There's nothing else like it and when you end up getting a ST later you won't have too many similar lemons.

  • 9 years ago

    I waited...I did snap up the NZ Lemonade, BUT I did not go crazy and buy the 5 other varieties in my cart. That is not an exaggeration, FWG has 10% off if you spend $120, so I was going to buy 6 trees just to qualify. However, cooler heads prevailed and I am happy with my pending Lemonade delivery.

    Susan - I am really interested to try air-layering myself and cannot believe how sweet you are to offer to send me one! I'll keep an eye for a ST in the meantime (probably in spring) and see what I other varieties I can find. Hopefully, my life will be a little more settled then (currently desperately seeking a new job, moving, and taking care of my 82 year old dad) and I can add more trees to my collection with less guilt. It's hard to plan for future trees when I don't know if the new home with be able to provide enough windows and light.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Sorry everyone not interested in another post about the paper but I found the direct reference for "FN"

    "Labeled FN (4.5 mmo lead per container as 10.8 atom % abundance of N-15 )". Sorry Silica I was wrong, I didn't fully understand the information and also skimmed over some parts but after looking more carefully, FN is the abundance of the nitrogen isotope N-15 which was detected by mass spectrometry. So they looked at total N then separate N-15 (FN) to figure out nitrogen uptake. I know not all results from papers is evidence of one thing to be true but I thought it was interesting enough to affect one's fertilizing timings if someone was interested in trying something different.

  • 9 years ago
    last modified: 9 years ago

    Yay! I am glad you got the NZL! I hope you end up liking it! I know what you mean about having to have reason when filling your cart. I immediately put the ST and the Valentine Pummelo in my cart but hemmed and hawed about adding a Genoa, Golden Nugget, cara cara and a few figs before deciding it would take too much time and hastily checked out with what I had. Its so tempting to try and get the 10% off but with how fast I suspected the ST to sell out (I've been burned with the AFL twice) I knew I couldn't afford to wait. But I am wishing I had at least added the golden nugget but I panicked. . Its crazy how much adrenaline I had going racing against an invisible clock to get that tree. Clearly I have a problem... Do they have meetings for plant addicts? lol And all that didn't even take into consideration that I shouldn't spend all that money on trees right now anyway.

  • 9 years ago

    What is AFL??

  • 9 years ago

    My bet goes, Like the grapes that the fox could not reach the ST will also probably turn out to be sour. Get the NZL.

    Steve

  • 9 years ago

    Susanne its Australian Finger Lime. It gets tiresome to type out such long names that I sometimes use the abbreviation.

  • 9 years ago

    I learned some of them but AFL did not came in my head. Thank you

  • 9 years ago

    Great article. I also thought it was foliar like Silica suspected, but it is explained in the article. Interesting. Thanks for sharing.

  • 9 years ago

    Oh, and sorry to hijack your thread...I have not tasted the ST yet, but am looking forward to it. I have lots of other lemon varieties - so I will need creative uses for them soon. I have also heard good things about the bearss lemon (sold my Harris). Ruth (from Harris) described it as having a very fragrant rind and it is a Sicilian cultivar.

  • 9 years ago

    I have fruits and used them. The ST is very aromatic, lots of oils in the rind that smell just wonderful when forking with it. Love to use the zest for baking.

  • 9 years ago

    Laura, did you happen to ask Ruth if they might be able to offer the others, like ST or NZL? I guess those are more specialty and Harris is more geared towards commercial. One positive note about Harris and Mackenzie are their reasonable ship rates.

  • 9 years ago

    Hibiscus, yes I did, and no they could not as of then. She said the bearss is much like the ST, but I've not compared them yet ;-)

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks Laura! And no problem :) I like learning new information from the posts I see here so it only feels right to share what interesting things I stumble upon. Sometimes the common sites that show up on the first page of Google repeat the same things and my curiosity isn't satisfied enough. I'm glad she spurred me on to read slower and understand it better.

    The way you describe the ST Susanne...almost made me forget that I wanted a NZL

  • 8 years ago

    Hey Susanne, I sent you a message via Houzz, but not sure if it went through. Let me know if you did not receive it :)

Sponsored
Bella Casa LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars17 Reviews
The Leading Interior Design Studio in Franklin County