Software
Houzz Logo Print
biondanonima

Small conifers (dwarf?) for this spot?

We bought a house on a steep slope last year and we're slowly reclaiming the landscape from weeds and other overgrown stuff. One of the most problematic areas in terms of upkeep is this hedge, which is located on the downhill side of a chain link fence. (We just cleared the bed below the hedge of horrible weed fabric and a forest of mugwort - I'm planning to move the remaining plants and fill it with perennials, once the hedge is dealt with.)



The hedge is made up of privet and barberry, all of which have suffered from improper pruning over the years. Some of the shrubs are dead, and have been taken over by honeysuckle and other weedy vines (hence the uneven top). The house faces west so this area mostly gets full sun, except the section of the fence/hedge behind that large false cypress on the right, which is more or less full shade. Pruning the sides of this hedge is a nightmare due to the steepness of the slope below - it is incredibly impractical, looks terrible, and I want it gone!

The problem is that my husband likes the privacy it provides when we are on the porch. We live on a busy street with a bus route, so there is a fair amount of non-neighbor foot traffic, etc. He loves the idea of a conifer hedge, but doesn't want to cut down the privet until we have a solution in place that will provide the same amount of privacy without waiting 5 years for plants to grow.

I am sure we could buy conifers that are tall enough right out of the gate, but I don't want to create another pruning issue by planting something that will eventually reach 15' or more naturally. I don't mind trimming the tops once or twice a year, but I know that's not ideal for the tree. Is there a narrow conifer with a compact habit that naturally tops out at 6-8' in height? I have been searching the interwebz and thus far the two most common recommendations seem to be thuja occidentalis smaragd or Art Boe, but even those indicate that they can reach 15-20' under ideal growing conditions. Am I barking up the wrong tree with conifers, or am I just not searching for the right thing? If there is no ideal conifer for this space, does anyone have any other suggestions? Thanks in advance for your help!


Comments (8)

  • 9 years ago

    Just stumbled upon Thuja Holmstrup as well - looks like it might be a contender, although the slow growth rate might make it a no-go in DH's book.

  • 9 years ago

    Conifers are probably not the best choice for this situation. True dwarfs will grow too slowly to provide the privacy you require any time soon and larger growing selections will likely grow much too tall and require pruning....which may or may not be desirable for the plant as well as being a chore for you.

    Instead, I'd consider broadleaf evergreen shrubs. In a zone 7 location, there should be many different choices available and many will come in a wide range of sizes, including many compact or dwarf forms that will stay around 4-5' tall. Most BLE's will respond to any necessary pruning well but I'd hunt for those that will stay right arouhd your height requirement. Your local nursery or garden center should be able to make appropriate suggestions for you but some to consider are Kalmia, Japanese holly, rhododendrons, evergreen viburnums, Euonymus japonica, nandina, glossy abelia.

    biondanonima (Zone 7a Hudson Valley) thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)
  • 9 years ago

    conifers are trees .. and as such.. basically never stop growing ... there is no such thing as topping out at some height ... most size estimates in conifers are at 10 years.. and you can presume they will be twice as tall in 20 years ...


    the key to determining such.. is to find an annual growth rate ... so you might predict future growth ... if something grows a foot per year.. in about ten years [setting aside transplant issues, and reduced growth rates due to such] ... it will be 10 feet tall in 10 years ...


    so something that has an estimate of 5 feet will grow about 6 inches per year .. but it will take that many more years to get to the height you might need ...


    both privet and barberry can be cut back near the ground.. perhaps you ought to start a major renovation of those plants.. by cutting them down significantly ... perhaps do every other one year one.. and when they get back to size.. rather fast with no insult to the root mass ... then the next year.. cut back the others ... and.. even if you decide to go with something else ... there is no reason beyond instant gratification .... to destroy all of what you have.. in one fell swoop ... make a 3 to 5 year plan.. keeping some privacy.. while cycling thru other parts ...


    also..; think about solving your problem.. other than in just that strip of hedges.. something like a redbud.. planted halfway down the hill ... would also solve your privacy issues .. think outside the box ... this is very similar to peeps who want to plant everything right on the property line ... rather than thinking about all that grass in between the fence line and the patio .... you're just that flip side of that coin ...

    ken





    biondanonima (Zone 7a Hudson Valley) thanked ken_adrian Adrian MI cold Z5
  • 9 years ago

    Thank you both very much for your input! Gardengal, I have definitely considered broadleaf evergreens, but DH keeps circling back to the look of conifers. The house is an 1890s four-square, and I think he feels that the conifers fit the style better and "dress up" the front in a way that a more naturally sprawling broadleaf shrub wouldn't. He actually likes the look of formally-sheared privet hedges, but because of the slope it is just not practical to keep this one in shape. Personally, I love the idea of kalmia or another flowering evergreen up there - or even a "mixed border" rather than a single-plant hedge. Perhaps a little convincing is in order! ;)

    Ken, I agree with you that a hedge is not an especially creative solution but in this case DH also wants to hide the fence itself to some extent, as it is chain link and not terribly attractive. We have discussed removing it entirely, but in that case we would need a hedge there for safety purposes (it's a pretty steep drop to the street!). Replacing it with something nicer (decorative iron, perhaps) is also a possibility, although I think DH would still want a semi-solid plant screen in the 4-5' range.

    Anyway, I am absolutely open to other outside-the-box solutions - perhaps showing the rest of the yard would help! Here is the other side of the fence line (the perennials there were all planted by the former owner and are destined to be moved in any case):

    We have 10 feet of depth between the edge of the porch and the fence, which is currently arranged as a 2' deep bed and 8' of lawn. Our ultimate plan is to turn the entire thing into a garden bed, leaving a 3-4' walkway close to the house, which will give us 6-7' for perennials. My plan was to have taller "screening" plants on the downhill side of the fence and use the bed on the house side for lower-growing perennials, but I would definitely be open to planting some taller things in the uphill bed - I'm just not sure that 6' of depth gives me a lot of options. Here's an aerial of what we are planning to do with the path/beds, which will include the side yard as well (fence line is in red).

    Thanks in advance for your suggestions!

  • 9 years ago

    there is a fence in the middle of the privet???


    all kinds of vines can be grown on a fence ....


    ken

  • 9 years ago

    Yes, there is a chain link fence running the width of the property behind the privet. I have considered growing something like English Ivy on the fence, but I'm not sure it will fill in enough to suit my husband (although I do see it growing quite thickly on fences elsewhere in our neighborhood). The other issue is that the fence is leaning downhill quite a bit, so we have been trying to hide it rather than highlight it (as I assume covering it with ivy would do). Perhaps a new fence should be a priority, as I would hate to establish beds only to have to rip them out to remove the fence in a few years. I don't think it's going anywhere fast, but it has definitely leaned/migrated downhill a bit. No idea how old it is or how long said migration has taken.

  • 9 years ago

    Thanks sc77 - we actually had some creeping juniper in this bed and ended up ripping it out because we didn't like the look of it. DH is really hoping for something more upright and "formal," although I have a feeling that we will really need to replace the chain link fence to achieve the look he desires.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio