Software
Houzz Logo Print
christine_sera

Help Brick Disaster !

8 years ago
We are building a new home and after months of looking for the perfect brick we chose one of the standard bricks the builder offered .The brick we chose is a pretty uniform in color but each brick does have some color variations , its a lighter brick and that is what we wanted , we avoided spotty brick lime the plague . Fast forward to our house being bricked we noticed that there were dark brown almost burnt looking bricks in patches on our home with no glaze , the clay was a different color. When we pointed it out to the builder he said he would tell the brick layers not to use them , well they did and put them all in the inside of the 2 story entry way of our home . We are furious the brick looks like a totally different brick , clearly a defected batch . We had a meeting with the builder , brick distributor and the manufacturer , their solution was to send their professional out to stain the brick to look like all the rest . We agreed because they said its a perfect match and they do this all the time . That ended up making it worse . 1 person came out , he color matched the brick from a picture , no test was done and it it turned the brick he stained a weird bluish gray , its now more spotty . We had a meeting again . Everyone agrees that there is something wrong with the brick color . They want to try and work with the satin guy to come up with a better match to blend with the rest of the house but to us it looks terrible !!! It looks decent when dry and your not on top of it but when your up close it looks horrible and when its wet the brick looks really bad !! Their suggestion was to seal all the brick to help it have a uniform look . The brick will never look like the brick we picked , its been made worse by the guy who tried to stain it . What should we be asking for , what options do we have . I feel like we are going to be forced to settle on the way it looks . The house is almost all brick at 3900 sf . Any help or advice is appreciated !! We also are due to close in a couple of months .

Comments (64)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Speaking of flashings, there's no kickout flashing. But since it's not usually a Code requirement, I'm not surprised.

    Source: Building America. US Department of Energy.

    Aesthetics are important. But, in the long run, functionality is what we live with and what most affects our long-term comfort and pocketbook.

  • 8 years ago

    Yeah the stone throws it off. Wth is that.

    With a couple shrubs it should look better.

  • 8 years ago
    You sometimes get a choice between more variation and lower price, and less variation and higher price, regarded as two different sets entirely. And you sometimes get builders accepting money for the latter and using the former. Happened when our house was built, we realised years later, though the more varied batch looked far better in any case.

    The stone doesn't work.

    "put them all in the inside of the 2 story entry way"
    indoors? pics of this?
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    If that counter flashing is done like this at 4:00, it's fine.

  • 8 years ago

    Love the way he cut a kerf into the masonry to better seat the sheet metal. I've never seen that!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Kickout flashing is used where the majority of the step flashing is installed under/behind the siding, and the last piece of flashing at the bottom of the roof needs to make sure any water ends up on the outside side of the siding. The lower piece of siding at the bottom end of the roof is under the kickout flashing (shingle fashion).

    In this situation with the brick, the step flashing is installed on the outside of the brick all the way up the rake, and the counter flashing covers the step flashing so that you do not see it. There is no need for kickout flashing because the flashing never goes behind the brick, so it never needs kicked back out.

    ETA aparantly, others think of kickout flashing as a separate piece in addition to what I am talking about above. I do a smaller extra kick on the last piece of flashing over top of the siding when there is no gutter (instead of a big booger hanging off the house), or more of a "z" flashing over the end of the gutter against the wall, as I do not like making a place for ice to build up.

    https://www.exteriorsourceva.com/roofing/house-may-need-step-kick-flashing/

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    CS....I am not a pro, but I TOTALLY see your complaint and cannot understand how practically no one else can see it! All the bluish bricks spattered across this section of the house is horrible. I agree it looks terrible and you are NOT crazy for thinking so. Even though it would be quite an undertaking, I would insist that they re-brick the entire thing because they obviously are incapable of fixing it. At least they have acknowledged there is something wrong so they can’t possibly think you should accept it the way it is. I’ve circled most of the offending blue bricks for the others here....

  • 8 years ago

    nidnay, I think most of us can't see past the location/use of the stone and the fact that the stone and brick are not a good match at all.

  • 8 years ago

    The stone is way weirder than the brick. At this point, I would plant shrubs.

  • 8 years ago

    The brick doesn’t bother me at all. It’s a non-issue. The stone at the lower left corner is a different story. WTH is that stone doing there?

    I don’t understand your comment about the inside of your two story entry. You mean INDOORS? Where’s the picture of that?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Milly Rey & littlebug zone 5 Missouri....do you like blue bricks?

  • 8 years ago

    I think it looks strange too. The more that I look at it, the more it looks like 3 different batches of brick. The stone doesn't bother me, but I am only assuming that it ties in with something around the corner?

  • 8 years ago

    Unfortunately - it is VERY likely that a tear out and do over is going to make a bigger disaster than leaving it. It's one of the dirty little secrets of the construction industry. Mistakes happen, and rarely will the fix be better than living with it for thing that are "style" or visual (I am not talking about things like framing, etc - but that would be an inspection issue). It's "the devil you know" type thing. When the builder or the trade has to suck up the cost of the do-over, they are not happy about it and budget even LESS time than the original - often leading to a worse, but different, problem. It's passive aggressive payback for holding them accountable to a high standard.

  • 8 years ago
    Incompletely agree that the brick is a mess-it’s very obvious to me that there is too much variation in coloration across the wall. Doing this has affected the stone-i feel like more contrast between those two elements is needed. Have the brick fixed again-I would love to see the inside portion you mentioned
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Fred S

    Good points!

    I never specified kickouts in the brick homes I've done--which with one or two exceptions is all I've built--and have never had a problem

    But I note that the site you linked to--don't know if that's you or not--includes references to kickout flashings, which this Fine Homebuilding piece notes is IRC 2009 required.

    ****

    The brick looks fine to me.

    But since the builder, distributor and manufacturer's rep agreed there's a problem, you clearly have the high ground in your complaint. It's not that big a deal to tear down a small veneer wall. I've seen my masonry contractor do it simply because he wasn't satisfied with what his guys put up!

    (It would be interesting if you could post the brickmaker's sample pics, so we all could see what they were offering.)

  • 8 years ago

    In response to ninday’s question: do I like blue brick?

    If this were my house, I wouldn’t care about the blue brick one way or the other. In this application it looks fine and in the big scheme of things I sure wouldn’t make an issue of it. If there is a possibility of a small financial consideration on the part of the contractor, maybe. But I wouldn’t pitch a fit over it. Small potatoes to me.

    I guess we should assume the stone was placed there PURPOSELY, since the OP hasn’t addressed it? It bothers the heck out of me and I would plant a thick evergreen to hide it. Is that stone on the FRONT of the house, I wonder? If so, then maybe the blue brick would be more of a concern because the stone and brick sure do clash.

  • 8 years ago

    On my screen I don't see blue brick there at all. Looks like a light gray. The stone in the picture looks kind of blue on my screen.


    However I do think they did a really poor job of mixing the bricks up into a more evenly randomized pattern. It looks to me like when it was laid that several of the same color ended up grouped together vs. taking the time to make sure to place the bricks of the same color a bit more spread apart.

  • 8 years ago

    The brick looks fine to me. The stones are weird though!

  • 8 years ago

    The OP went MIA. Maybe they will update us on the resolution!

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    The OP most likely didn’t have the stomach for the interaction here (don’t blame him/her).

  • 8 years ago

    I agree with nidnay. The OP wasn't expecting all the critical comments about the stone corner design element. When you ask about something you think is a problem and then are told that something you didn't ask about is a bigger problem, you might want to move on....

  • 8 years ago

    Truth is tough

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Sorry kudzu9, when you come to Houzz, you get what your get, not necessarily what you want to hear. It can be tough at times, but truth is what makes the site valuable.

  • 8 years ago

    The stone is very blue. So not sure how the bluer bricks can be discussed without the cooler tones of the stone.

    But - point taken - I'll stick to the question at hand in the future.

  • 8 years ago

    I was just making an observation, not trying to chastise anyone or discourage comments. I've been posting on GW for enough years to understand the dynamic. And sometimes people are grateful for unsolicited input. In this case, the OP presumably liked the stone corners and wasn't going to rip them off, so a lot of piling on about that feature did not likely strike her as helpful, or make her feel we were sympathetic to her main concern, or trying to be constructive. Sometimes we do slide off the road a bit....

  • 8 years ago

    nidnay...well said!

    It takes very little effort to word things with class. And it was entirely wrong to trash her stone selection.

  • 8 years ago

    Sometime I want to ask, 'How many Build Forum members does it take to beat a dead horse?' I don't buy into 'you get what you get when you ask a question here. Not every forum is like that here or on other sites and just because you can doesn't mean you should. You can wave the constructive criticism flag all you want but the tendency towards group attack here is becoming more frequent and reads like the intention is to draw blood. All I'd ask is that people think about that.

  • 8 years ago
    Of course, courtesy and understanding always helps, but I've not seen much here that's overly harsh/cruel.
    Equally, when an op says "Any help or advice is appreciated !!" well, we'll be giving any help or advice we have. And I can see that though that's said, that advice might be quite unexpected, but in no way is it then wrong or inappropriate.
    Op, you coming back? We get it, the feelings involved, though we may not all have focused on saying so, and don't all agree. If it helps knowing, we do get it.
  • 8 years ago
    Some bricks look blue and white and the others look like light and darker grey. Clearly there is a problem with the batches or the stains. The corner stone highlights are not really the issue.
  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It looks like you don't have an even brick color distribution... most of the dark bricks on the top and most of the white brick on the bottom and they should be spread out more or less evenly on the wall. Some mason bricklayers don't realize the importance to take the brick pallets apart the right way and this is the outcome when it's done incorrectly.

    That being said, most brick manufacturers have unstacking guidelines how to take the pallet to end up with an even color distribution, and it plays importance in cases where you have many color variations in the brick, so following manufacturers suggestion helps to distribute brick color uniformly on the wall.

  • 8 years ago

    @Najeebah - it's not just this thread and there are others where the criticism is much sharper. I understand what you're saying but OP disappeared and people still think they need to pile on day after day over the same thing.

  • 8 years ago
    I hear you but c'est la vie.
    Some people speak in ways that offend others, rightly or wrongly so. And on houzz, those others start threads about it. And... the former bunch continue in their ways, because c'est la vie.
    Maybe our op is just busy? Maybe he/she is actually offended?
    We'll have dozens of thread in the future where people respond, and ops become receptive, defensive, offensive, or leave all together.
    C'est la... you get my point
  • 8 years ago

    One of the problems with the tone of the board is that it makes for a much less interesting board. My feeling is that the board has become dry and boring lots more than in the past. Very few new threads than in the past. I've been here on and off since 2002. You open up the board...same old, same old. Nothing new.

    Lots of folks may have interesting, stimulating, ideas/questions that they would like to post (that we can all learn from) but do not because of the repercussions /harsh criticism they see when others have posted. God forbid you have a pork chop return on your house and someone points it out.

    look at the monthly progress thread. Why aren't more of these folks posting on the general board? The progress thread is the "safe" thread.

    it can't hurt to try to be just a little kinder and gentler to encourage folks to stay or come back. And for the regular posters to post more or start new threads.




  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I agree with ILR. Kinda getting bored here because it's the same thing over and over. Or the same comments where folks put things like no pork chop returns (I actually have two pork chops out of the twelve returns on my house......YIKES...... but for purposeful reasons), inboard kitchens, U-stairs, no closets accessed through bathroms (and I had this condition in one of my past houses too for 17 years with no problems). These items are put right up there with indoor plumbing and a roof!

    And it IS scary putting up plans here. I go through a little stomach churning every time one of my folks puts up a design although I encourage it. They've all worked well but I never know where it's headed. The problem is they're an end result snap shot of a final house design without the benefit of anyone seeing the process. Kinda like analyzing one play in a football game with no knowledge of context......like current field position, current score, the play before, current down, yards to go for a first down...... etc. Many times we've explored the exact ideas offered but rejected them for less obvious benefits garnered elsewhere.

    And the "pros" here now don't seem to be supportive of each other as in the past despite having ample time posting to non-pros in stumping about design theory, especially Mark. Ok, Mark is the exception that proves the rule here, always enjoy reading his thoughtful and often funny quips! Thanks Mark!

  • 8 years ago

    I actually don't mind the brick colour however there does seem to be a lot of whiter bricks near the bottom which could have been distributed better. As for the stone, I'm thinking that if you were to see the front of the house it would show us better what the contrast looks like. Our house is getting grey brick and stone as well....hope it is enough of a contrast and not too matchy matchy. The dealer assured us that the brick/stone combo would match well but I'm second guessing our decision.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Why are my ears burning??

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Seldom is the case that two disparate masonry products--natural stone and manufactured brick--harmonize well together, despite the assurances of the masonry distributor. Pick one or the other, but not both, to assure visual harmony.

  • 8 years ago
    C S...would love to see a pic of the front of your house to see how you incorporated the stone with the brick. Doing something similar with our new build.
  • 8 years ago
    Dana....I think CS is long gone.
  • 8 years ago

    I remember a thread that got to this point before - probably like 8 years ago. And I'll repeat my comment from then - go on a car forum for a little while. This forum exudes politeness by comparison. I do believe it is a bit of a gender issue as those forums are very male dominated and this one seems very evenly distributed. Kitchen forum - seems more female dominated and is generally more polite. I don't think polite is right - perhaps civil - but that isn't right either.

    I posted my plan and expected certain things. Wasn't worried. But I can see a new poster being timid. Now I find things less than ideal aesthetically and I usually don't say anything if it is completed. The brick/stone thing here was an example (at least I don't remember piling on). But the criticism helps more than the OP who is gone anyway. There is probably no way to be perfect with criticism on the internet or in life. Best just to have thick skin. Probably a good life lesson in that too.

  • 8 years ago
    I have seen some really ugly houses and this is definitely not one of them. Everyone has different tastes when it comes to what they like and dislike.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Well...since the OP appears out of the building...and David and Dana have raised excellent points...allow me to gently respond to "...Everyone has different tastes when it comes to what they like and dislike..."

    Here's a major part of the issue with some of our discussions. Some folks respond based on what they like or dislike. Which is fine.

    Other folks, frequently the professionals and experienced consumers, respond based on education, training and years, perhaps decades of actual design/architectural/art/construction/building/remodeling experience. Which is fine.

    The difference in these two positions for responses, however, is often profound. On the one hand we have folks who "like" or dislike". On the other hand, we have folks who are responding based on things like scale, proportion, elements of architectural style, site planning and development, interior design and function, budget and years of experience in design and construction/building/remodeling from diverse locations in at least two countries--the U.S. and Canada.

    Predictably, the responses from these two groups may often differ. Sometimes the responses differ very strongly! Sometimes not. But frequently, since the two groups talk with different language and meaning, toes may be unintentionally stepped on. It's sometimes like trying to carry on a conversation with one speaking Chinese while the other is speaking Italian. Both very animated and passionate, but each completely bypassing the other...

    We can tell when the conversation is going south because someone will predictably say, "Well...it's your house and you should do what you want to!", which may be the ultimate response based on frustration with previous comments. At that point the conversational value may be nil.

    If you want to witness real design criticism, try sitting in a university architectural school studio or art studio at the end of a specific project, where the students place their work in front of other students and faculty for critique. Want to see a crit stomp on a student's model? Want to see a model get tossed out a third floor window...?

    The discussions here are mild by comparison, but like the academic critiques there's always truth and learning there for those so inclined. Rant over. Back to our normal programming...

    You should just do what you want--it's your house! :-)

  • 8 years ago

    I want to add, that because several people posted to agree that the stone isn't a good match, I don't think that is piling on or a group attack.

    If I agree with a comment, I will add my vote, to show the OP that it wasn't a random comment and that several people have the same opinion. It might be too late for the OP to do anything about it, but it will certainly help others who are reading and just starting the building process.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Apparently, they leave out this significant piece of architectural history in the college curriculum.

    http://ths.gardenweb.com/discussions/4077280/stone-and-brick-combination?n=20

  • 8 years ago

    Fred S. I personally like the look of stone and brick together and am doing it on our new house. Just a difference in taste I guess but it seems to be the trend now.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Carrère and Hastings, architects of the Gilded Age, typically mixed stone and brick. Doesn't look too shabby to me.

    William Starr Miller residence, 1048 5th Ave., NYC. b. 1914.
    Carrere and Hastings, arch.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Stone detail at lower corners of brick houses is quite common in the more interesting houses of the 1920s, 30s, and 40s around here. My 1933 house has stone around the arched entryway and the remainder is brick. Typical around here is the color shown in the NYC stone at the corners and then darker brick, usually in earth tones of yellow, orange, brown, and some greenish bricks also. Only rarely do I see that detail used with brick of consistent color. Usually that is an expensive upgrade to the details and thus done with contrasting color so it will stand out. I would like it better on the OPs building if stained to a dark charcoal gray.

  • 8 years ago

    Was Fred visiting?

  • 8 years ago

    chispa-

    Yes, a number of people opined on the stone, but just because a number of people agreed about that doesn't mean it's relevant given that the OP was concerned about the appearance of the brick. Even if the OP were convinced to rip it out, it still doesn't resolve the issue she posted about.