Software
Houzz Logo Print
a1an

Snow/Insulator/Buds

8 years ago

Just thinking outloud. For those hydra's that are not protected, I can see how snowfall ontop of the buds can be a insulator against the winds.

But let's say in a sunny location, where the sun can cause the snow/moisture to melt, and then midnight temps dip to freeze that water (now inside the crevices of the bud) ?

So what causes buds to go bad in winter. Winter burn or literally ice cracking buds (sorta like how ice on concrete, etc) causes cracks over time

Comments (34)

  • 8 years ago

    You lost me @ hello Luis ;-)

    Excellent breakdown. Going to have to read this again later to digest

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Is it possible to Over-Do overwintering hydra's. Got a couple of new ones in the ground. Concerned about the thin branches which all the ends have buds on them waiting for next year.....

    If I mulch, it sorta creates a nice foundation that locks the stems as support - so snow load won't break the young branches.

    I'm outta leaves though. If I literally mulch the entire shrub, should I be concerned about overwintering moisture....and or moisture and then midnight freezes ?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    How much mulch to use depends on how cold things get in your zone, snowfall amounts (plain, recently fallen snow is a good insulator) and how tall/small the shrub is. So the colder it gets, the more inches of mulch you will need around and above the bush. Around 2-4" past the ends of stems is a good starting point in cold places (you want it higher & wider than the shrub's stems are). Make sure to water before a freeze (if the soil has not frozen yet). Wet soil prevents freeze injury to roots because moist soil holds more heat than dry soil does. If large amts of snow accumulate on top (think: Erie, Penn.!!!) remove some of the snow as needed to prevent stem breakage.

    With large/bulky macs, some people switch from a chicken wire technique to pressing the stems downwards with cardboard to flatten the stems.

    If you are running out of leaves, try using cereal straw or Lucerne hay (from alfalfa) to avoid straw-with-weed-seeds problems... or try composted meadow hay.

    During the normal growing season, maintain 2-4" of mulch up to the drip line.

    Merry Christmas and a happy New Year!

  • 8 years ago

    https://plantaddicts.com/winter-protection-of-hydrangeas/This might be interesting to some, also mention s the bend technique

  • 8 years ago

    thx guys. last night, I picked up a 2 bags of mulch on the way home yesterday. My go to spot for mulch, etc did not warrant a hrs drive each way for 2 bags of mulch. Picked up 2 bag of the big box dyed stuff.........

    Insulated the remaining 3 which I did not touch sofar, aside from mulching around the bed/root zone. Piled it on enough that the mulch in theory should support a snow load. As I walking out to work yesterday, I saw all the buds and the itty bitty thin branches which one day will become nice sturdy canes. Said to myself, it would be a shame to lose all those buds.

  • 8 years ago

    Hyed thank you for the link. We were given a hydrangea (our first!) as a gift, poor bitty thing had a bunch of flowers and was rooted in something the size of a teacup. It survived the summer and then as it got cold (7 degrees this morning!) I wasn’t sure what to do and covered it (About a month ago) with an old plastic double walled planter. It’s probably pretty good protection, but how to know when to remove it, since the plant does not get any light with that on?

  • 8 years ago

    H B, what kind of Hy is it... if a Mac. I would removed the planter in late April (take a peek) watch the forecast , temps falling into twenty’s/teens will kill any buds

  • 8 years ago

    I've never buried/wintered one in straight mulch. Leaves, burlap, yes.

    Can one potentially cause more harm than good ? If the mulch stays too wet. Wild guess but thinking the mulch mound per each shrub is about 18inches or so.

  • 8 years ago

    No... but surprise!!! mulch = leaves. So you already have wintered using mulch. Does not look much like leaves when composted though.

    By definition, mulch is things like leaves, bark etc which is spread around to feed and insulate plants.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Heh, I suppose. But leaves in my mind, when they are wet and mat down, they mat differently - aka, they make little leaf air spaces .

    When I think of spring, I am thinking about all the snow that has melted + the spring rains, and then all the wet soil that takes a good while to dry out. I suppose the same wet mulch can be easily removed in spring though off the shrub. Much easier than raking back mulch .

    Going to wait till it get's colder tonight and I'm going to try to ~shape~ it even more, mulch was a bit moist coming out of the bag. Shape it so it's more a cone, kinda like a rose protection cone I suppose, with the mulch supporting the twig like branches.

    The mounds remind me of this

    https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CNWHkrVUwAAgyxD.jpg

    --------

    I just had a epiphany. If I order these and put a pair on top of my mounds, will it scare the feral cats who have been using my mulch as their litterbeds

    https://cdn-consumercrafts.netdna-ssl.com/content/images/product/large/EYE-6.jpg

  • 8 years ago

    Thx Luis for giving me the extra nudge I needed. In trying to reshape/tweak the mulch today, it was quite frozen ! Heh, literally, this was a good reminder that over-wintering can never be a bad thing.

  • 8 years ago

    Well, may I "join" you then?

    I just saw a weather advisory for my area saying that my temps are heading to 17 and lower 20s for several days so I have been buying materials to winter protect today. When we hit 15 degrees in early January 2017, it killed the flower buds and stems of most of my mopheads... except for some in protected locations. But somehow my brain was stuck thinking of warmer temps and, no matter how much they advertised the temperature drop, it did not sink that they might kill the buds at the least.... until days aaaaafterwards... LOL!!!! Oh, meeeeee..... I am now being proactive and working on this like you are.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Heh. Hindsight vs. foresight. Or on that other thread, where one was discussing about the look of burlap on the hardscape, fashion vs. function ;-) Good luck !

  • 8 years ago

    I have no idea what kind of hydrangea it is, but probably whatever is the least expensive /most common type here in the northeast. We will go to negative numbers tonight I think.

  • 8 years ago

    Way off topic, but I've had snow load and - wrong shrubs, placement, etc- get splayed and destroyed. I've learned to protect things if they matter, as losing grown shrubs takes awhile for even replacements to fill back in.


    For one side of my foundation boxwoods, which feels like they grow like 2 inches a year, I literally put 4 side posts and make a makeshift plywood roof right before a large snowfall is forecasted. I would rather have the roof than lose those boxwoods.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    HNY everyone. Decide to dump snow onto the 30G Hydra I'm overwintering....a light turned on as old man winter settles in and I realize how snow insulates. Aka, even the top is crusted and hard, the snow underneath is still ~snow~. Well, eventually to some degree. Heh, I got lucky as it's rare I get the powdery stuff vs. the wet heavy stuff.

    Was checking out the boxwoods and seeing how the bronzing was faring. Anyhow, has anyone used Wilt Pruf on your hyra's. I've never done it, but maybe there is some benefit to it if one was to spray each bud ? Maybe next year.

  • 8 years ago

    Oops, hate to say this today but, oops, "next year" is today. Hee hee hee.

    I am in the Dallas/Fort Worth Metroplex and we tanked to the teens
    this morning. The temperatures have been crashing since Saturday but,
    they should warm up by Wednesday. Can't wait. Too cold (wah! hee hee
    hee!) and too windy (wind chill of just 2) for what is normal this time
    in our neck of the woods. I may have some bud loss but hey, I gave them some water and hay so it will be up to them.
    :o( Hope you all in colder locales are safe, ok and are enjoying the
    New Year!

  • 8 years ago

    Heh. This freeze has made a name for itself. Bombgenesis if you haven't read todays news.

  • 8 years ago

    Hmm, I wonder what that was supposed to mean? I read where the SE was going to get some ice and snow? Is that where you are? We already got hit with cold in the teens the last few days and are warming to the 40s now.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Back on topic. On the overwintered Hydra I have in a pot, surrounded by pots and leaves, I decided to bury snow ontop as well, since I have some excess snow to place. Got me thinking about this topic. If snowfall is powdery and not wet snow, even a 18 inch thick mass is okay, as the top layer generally crust/ harden up/freeze over night or maybe it might take 2-3 days for it to harden and ice up as the sun melts/creates moisture and then the midnight freeze.

    Over time, day sun does melt into the mass of snow, and slowly the inside soft snow does harden over time with the dipping night temps

    I've never given this much thought until now as I've been doing things to the hardscape, relocating things as well due to snow from roofline, with some hydras that are part of the foundation plantings.

    Is winter snow covering canes/buds more beneficial and or does the moisture/extended freeze create more problems than the canes/buds seeing dry cold winds.

    For those that live in the snow belt, do you see more live buds below your snowline or above your snowline.

    LOL. Maybe a controlled experiment is in order. Remove 2 of them that have protective burlap. Remove leaves. Bury one completely in snow. On the 2nd one, bury it halfway in snow. Observe the blooms in s/s 2018 and then it should confirm what effects snow buried canes have on the cause/effect ?

  • 8 years ago

    I get live buds on the parts of the stems buried in snow on hydrangea macrophylla. If the deep snows come before the worst cold and stays through spring I’ve had live buds 1/3 to 1/2 way up the stems. I only mulch to protect the crown and lowest buds. The best year I’ve had for my endless summer types was after the infamous polar vortex winter. Lots of snow in November that never melted.

  • 8 years ago

    Thx for the feedback Pennlake. Very interesting. Almost sorta tempted to do the test but what if the snow melts and then it doesn't snow anymore till spring ;-)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Pennlake - I was intrigued by your post so I actually buried one of mine in a 7x7 Mound.

    It's a heat wave now. Well, at least from the past 2 weeks. And the snow is melting. I decided to actually take more snow and shovel it ontop of the mound but melting wet snow = Heavy.

    I suppose the ? depends on how sturdy the canes are, but any issues when you purposely pile on snow to act is a insulator and the snow melts and gets heavy. Bent, broken canes due to the weight ?

    I will say this. When I was laying snow as a mound, I did see a couples cane bend a little bit here and there .

  • 8 years ago

    I have done the bend to the ground method with great success.. the canes bounce right back... But when you have a dozen or more Macs it's a lot of work .. Starting to remove most of them...there are too many great hys that don' t need Winter protection

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I recall reading about this flattening. Mind extrapolating how you do it, just short of me visioning you are literally splaying them 360 and then cardboard and something to hold it down .

    I can't put a timeline but the time I would think I would flatten them, alot of the green is closer towards wood.


    I may just dig out the snow when I get home tonight & or I'll let Dwarnisim take over

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    SadFace Pennlake. I've never buried mine in snow. In general as the snow we get is heavy and wet. The recent bomb-genesis snowfall was superlight and I dumped it as a test (knowing full well as it melted, etc, the snow could get really heavy). And it did

    I did look at it that since it was light, it would fill the voids and support the structure instead of toppling. As as it melted, the voids with light snow would become heavy snow. Bad thinking, as it melts from the top. Duh. So the top get's heavy and ends up splaying it.

    It's been years since I've seen 12 inches of fluffy powdery stuff. It's generally depressing wet heavy backbreaking snow.

    ;-(

    It's melted to about 1/3 off the top. I see at least couple canes with green insides that have snapped. Canes with like 8+ buds that are completely broken.There is evidence of buds breakage as the snow has bud shells all over.

    Ehh. You live and learn. Mea Cupla

    I had to test ya know...

  • 8 years ago

    I planted an oakleaf next to my steps thinking I could shovel snow on it. Always did damage even trying to be gentle.

  • 8 years ago

    Puffy dry snow may be better than wet heavy snow.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    It was puffy to begin with ;- /

    I live 1/2 off the water. All I ever see is the heavy wet stuff. The rare chances I see 12" of powder, heh, get's me all confused.

    Snows all melted. Lost about 8 canes down to the base, another half snapped in half and lord knows how many buds came off or the shell due to the wet bed. The canes that I removed...the buds were soggy. Some even lost it's shell. I saw a green bud or 2. I know, I know...Mea Culpa

    In all fairness, I knew better....I'm guilty after decent snowfall, I'm wading in the white stuff and I do dig out the tops of some of the shrubs just to make sure come springtime, I don't get the ~springtime splayed surprise~. Mitigation goes a long way I suppose.

  • 8 years ago

    my conclusion..macrophyllas hate cold climates..I've read endlessly about overwintering..just read hyed's link..I've done what I thought was a careful job of winter protection and still been disappointed..I did a quick job this year using some oakleaf filled garbage bags around the shrubs perimeters and dropped oak leaves on the shrubs..but I see stems sticking out and they'll be goners..but I hated to do nothing at all..can't wait for spring..

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Heh Nicholas. Just short of the PG which are bulletproof in my yard, I am slowly swapping the current macs. to rebloomers. Never did have any rebloomers till this year. I'm going to observe it's characteristics before I decide. It's worst when you have some years where you have a full 6x6 leafy mound with a handful of blossoms, ya know. I've held off of the rebloomers till now, as no more space, and most of my macs. are full grown, and well, sometimes it's like watching paint dry as you wait till a new shrub grows and fills in the shrub it replaced.


    And I know rebloomers may not be the end-all-be- all as I believe Hyed ripped our all of the ES

  • 8 years ago

    Rebloomers like Endless Summer?.reblooming usually happen in Aug.Sept. And your lucky if you get 6 blooms...Just Saying