Software
Houzz Logo Print
lee_l_brittain

Pawpaw or Persimmons?

8 years ago

I am finishing out the fruit tree space on our acreage and can't make up my mind whether I should plant all pawpaws or instead plant some pawpaws and some persimmons. Those of you who have grown both crops, what would you recommend? Which do you find more entertaining to grow? Is the market for pawpaws a lot stronger than persimmons? What concerns would you have managing ~100 pawpaw trees versus ~50 pawpaw trees and ~15 persimmon trees? Thanks.

Comments (19)

  • 8 years ago


    HERE you go Lee B, my old thread about kaki persimmons. This is the Asian persimmon. I assume you are starting an orchard???? Start with grafted plants which aren't cheap. This is kind of a novelty crop.

    The native Common Persimmon is also a great tree, fruit no larger than a golf ball, ripens after frost, many seeded. Also start with grafted, female plants.



  • 8 years ago


    HERE you go Lee B, my old thread about pawpaw. In that thread I concentrate on trees grown from wild and mostly for wildlife habitat. There are in fact several grafted selections which are superior. I assume you are starting an orchard???? This is a novelty crop with a thin skin. It bruises and goes brown easily.

    Pawpaw is native in my area in the mid-Atlantic, where are you posting from?

  • 8 years ago

    I am posting from north central Indiana.

  • 8 years ago

    You have a couple of issues:

    1) what is your use case? Pretty tree? Edible fruit? Sell-able fruit?

    2) cold hardiness - american persimmon should be fine where you are, but asians are less cold hardy - i think like to zone 7 only. Americans are smaller and more tart, so selling them might not be ideal

    3) selling fruit? Paw paws should be doable cold-wise, but the fruit is not durable at all and will never make it to market - that is why it is not mass marketed. You MIGHT be able to do a farmer's market kind of thing, but asian persimmons are far more marketable.

    On the up side, my understanding is both types of fruit are not too pest prone, although critters will get them, and I guess ripe paw paws are like crack to the forest critters. I grow both, but none of my trees are at the fruiting age yet, so can't comment. I would grow both just for diversity, but again, I don't know your goal.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I am starting an orchard (we also have grapes, pears, cherries, and apples, but just enough for family and friends in those crops). We are definitely in zone 5 here, so even the more hardy Asian persimmons like Nikita's Gift are probably not an option. It got down to -15 this week and has gotten down to -20 in prior winters (2012 and 2013). My "use case" is sellable and edible fruit. We want to have more than enough for ourselves and our friends, and then hopefully have enough left to sell at the farmers market a few weeks each year (mainly so I can teach my kids business skills). There is an Amish themed farm market store about a mile from our house that would probably be a good outlet for surplus pawpaws for we couldn't sell on our own at the farmers market or to other larger customers. Between the need for male persimmon trees and my site's unsuitableness for Asian persimmons, it sounds like maybe going all pawpaws is the better route? Would definitely be the higher value crop as I can plant more trees per acre in pawpaws than persimmons. We are on a very open site so wildlife pressure is not a great concern. It is a concern for wind which I've heard pawpaws don't like, however we have planted a green giant arborvitae windbreak so hopefully that windbreak will be functional within a few years.

  • 8 years ago

    There is a fine line between ripe and rotten as far as native persimmons and pawpaws. If you've ever eaten dead ripe figs you know what I'm talking about.

  • 8 years ago


    Lee B, here is my common persimmon 'Meader'. Pic taken late September. This one ripens before the other wild persimmons. When they are ripe I pull them right off the tree and eat them. I don't have a male pollinator per se but there are native persimmons in my area. Coons & possums are after this tree at night and that's a problem. Let me say, the fruit is as sweet as honey and not mealy. When I remove the fruit the calyx stays on the tree, not sure how that would work for marketing. Many of the fruits are quite high and out of reach. Many insist on picking fallen fruit from the ground so I guess each tree is different. It is a novelty fruit for sure, no clue as to how it would work at a farmer's market.

  • 8 years ago

    Sam, I've got a large Meader, and it's just as you say. The fruit tastes great, as long as I beat the varmints to it. The fruit doesn't need a freeze to be edible. I'd be happy with the tree even if it never fruited, it's very attractive and tropical looking. I've got lots of native persimmons for pollination, but I've read that Meader is self fruitful.

  • 8 years ago

    Dave in NoVA, thanks for your pix. They make a point that I hinted at earlier. You use pruners to harvest persimmon, right? That way the calyx stays with the fruit.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Sam, yes, I used pruners to cut off the fruit. When you're on a ladder, and have two hands free, that's the way to go. Or you can grab the fruit and twist it (rotate it) until finally the stem breaks. The stem would never pull out of the fruit though, because the fruit is not usually soft...but you’d tear up your tree branch. Apple pickers don’t work well.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I have several PawPaw trees, and while I do eat the fruit, everyone else that I have let try it doesn't seem to care for the taste or texture. The others are right about them not keeping well, I can pull one off the tree that's semi-ripe, and within two days it's almost rotten.

    The above pic is of a Hachiya Asian persimmon I bought at Publix, and two native persimmons from my woodland trees, quite a difference eh? Personally I'm not crazy about those non astringent ones like Fuyu, I find the flavor just isn't as intense and they seem a bit dry. I planted a 'Giombo' a couple of years ago, and I can't wait until I can start getting fruit from it, those Hachiyas sell for a buck a piece.

  • 8 years ago

    Yeah Lee, I am gonna say for edibles, only the paw paw will fly. Have you considered other cash crops like chestnut or hazelnut?

  • 8 years ago

    My persimmon tree is a half year old in a pot, so I bought 88 persimmons from a store, 4 cases, 22 per case! :-) Everyone loves persimmons. I don’t know anything about pawpaw though, have never tasted one.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Personally, the American Persimmons are my favorite (tastewise), because they are the absolutely sweetest ones. However, they are trickier to eat because they are most ripe after they've fallen off the tree on their own. But because they are so soft and squishy (like jelly inside), they often don't survive that impact very well. And some people don't like their gooey texture, but prefer the Asian Persimmons, which tend to be firmer like a firm tomato or bell pepper. Not to mention much larger...

    However, just based on their taste, ripe American Persimmons are the sweetest of any persimmons I've ever tried, and probably the sweetest fruit I've ever tried, PERIOD! Is it just me, or anyone else agree here??

  • 8 years ago

    My Fuyus are sweet. Not sickeningly sweet, but really nice. The flavor is complex but subtle -- with overtones of vanilla and melon. But you can't really compare it to anything else. And I also like the crunchy texture. There's more to a fruit than 'sweet'. I love grapefruit too. They are not real sweet. To each their own!

  • 8 years ago

    Have you ever eaten a pawpaw? Most folks find them either delectable or disgustingly insipid... and most folks I've shared them with fall into the second camp. I was big on them for quite some time, but anymore, I can eat one pawpaw fruit, and that's enough to last me for a year or two.

    Unless you're going to hand-pollenate, fruit production on pawpaws seems to be somewhat 'iffy'. You'll look long and hard to find many fruits in the wild groves here - but that may be, in part, due to the fact that many of those large clumps are just one large genetic clone. My small planting of a half-dozen or so grafted varieties fruits most years, but certainly doesn't produce enough fruit that I'd consider them a commercially-viable crop, even if I had a market for them... whereas the persimmons produce many gallons of fruit.

    Most Americans, anymore, are 'uncomfortable' with a soft, fragrant fruit that, at peak ripeness is somewhat unattractive - and that description fits for both pawpaws and American persimmons, neither of which are going to have a substantial shelf-life, and may be relegated to either sale as processed/frozen pulp or marketing at a local farmer's market type site.

  • 8 years ago


    This YOUTUBE is about kaki persimmons in Armenia. It is kind of light-hearted but makes a good point. Notice that they harvest them with the stem (calyx) intact. It is safe to say that this is a part of Asian culture dating back many centuries.

  • 8 years ago

    ^ The calyxes are actually used in Chinese medicine to stop hiccups...