Software
Houzz Logo Print
mgh_pa

Subdividing on large acreage. Best practice?

8 years ago

My wife and I are buying land from my parents and have the option to buy as little or as much as we want. We will, of course, subdivide from the property the piece we chose to purchase and build on. However, we started thinking about the advantages of possibly just placing our home on a 1 acre piece, and leaving the rest by itself. So if we decided to buy 30 acres, we would have the house and 1 acre on a deed, and the remaining 29 acres on a second.


We’ve been told this help with our ability to obtain better rates for home equity lines, refinancing, etc. in the future as well as make it easier to appraise for sale if we ever decide to.


The issue then becomes having to have it surveyed twice.


Does anyone have any recommendations for the best practice of subdividing large parcels like this? If it matters, we will not be financing the land purchase.

Comments (20)

  • 8 years ago
    I don't have an answer to your question, but I just wanted to make sure that you have consulted with the city or county about this. I only ask because we too are buying acreage from my parents and there are strict restrictions on it. For example, it has to be a minimum of a 2 acre purchase for the purpose of building a house on it..
    Now we aren't dealing with 29 acres, so perhaps your situation doesn't require approval and/or have regulations...
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Contact local surveyors.


  • 8 years ago

    All of the above. Step one - contact the local zoning authority. Where we bought, there is a requirement for a minimum size parcel, linear frontage, and a restriction on how many subdivisions, too. Here, it's two subdivisions per 10 years.

    There is also a question of taxes, and what is able to be considered "homestead" for local property tax exemption.

    So, first find out how it CAN be subdivided, then go ask a lender what's most advantageous. And, as jannicone said, watch out for putting yourself in a position in the future where your lovely view is the side of someone else's polebarn. There are a few parcels here where the original house sits on a small parcel - and the "subdivided" portion surrounds it on three sides. This is sometimes... awkward.


  • PRO
    8 years ago

    What Holly said. Since no one here knows the regulations of your jurisdiction and no one knows the conditions your lenders allow, and no one knows the real estate trends and practices of your area...what Holly said! :-) Good luck!

  • 8 years ago

    Another vote for, Check your local laws. I live in a rural county that wants to maintain the old family farms (and I'm not arguing); thus, they have rules about how many pieces a property can be divided into /how much road frontage must remain with each piece of property. The rules essentially prevent people from chopping an old farm up into a new neighborhood.

    Keep in mind, too, that keeping the majority of the land in one big piece can be a benefit when it comes to property tax. In my area, if you have X number of acres and are actively farming it OR have a forestry plan in place, you can pay a SIGNIFICANTLY SMALLER amount of property tax -- like 10% of the total property tax.

    If I were in your shoes, I'd go see a lawyer who works with real estate in your local area and ask his or her advice. It'd be worth an hour of the lawyer's time to know that you're making good decisions.

  • 8 years ago

    As already said, talk to zoning first. Then talk to the banks you are considering.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    My in-laws did this twice - in areas with 3 acre zoning. They carefully sold parcels of 5.8 acres so they could not be further subdivided.

  • 8 years ago

    In our county, you can get agricultural zoning if your house is on 6 acres or more. You need 5 acres of farm land (we're raising timber), plus an acre for the house. Of course, where you are may have nothing of the kind. Ag zoning saves us a lot of taxes on land we're not using, other than for privacy.

  • 8 years ago

    I trust you've discussed your plans with your parents? It would be terrible for them to think they are getting their daughter and SIL next door, but instead be getting several neighbors in relatively close proximity that they don't know. Perhaps this wouldn't bother them, but I would hate it.

  • 8 years ago

    I would actually recommend talking to an attorney who has done work in land development. There can be additional considerations and nuance to this question.

    For example, many contributors have noted that some areas that want to preserve farmland have a minimum acreage to build, we ran into that situation with a farmhand who we wanted to award a small parcel to build on but the local laws required ten acres to build. We simply sold him 10 acres at an exhorbitant price on a two year note with an option for us to buy back nine acres to forgive the note. He built the house, we got the land back.


  • 8 years ago

    Thanks, everyone. Will talk to the zoning officer first. Very rural area in a township that has minimal restrictions, so I don't expect much in the way of issues.

    @bluesanne, I think you're misinterpreting my question. They own 150 acres next to their 90. I'm going to buy a chunk of the 150 with full intentions of purchasing the remainder of the 150 down the road. I'm not subdividing for a development. I'm subdividing the piece I purchase from the piece my parents own.

  • 8 years ago

    I missed the part in your original post where you mentioned either 90 acres or 150 acres — in fact, I still don't see it. I was referring to your comment about making it "easier to appraise for sale if we ever decide to." I was obviously making assumptions without having all of the information, plus I got your gender wrong. My bad.

  • 8 years ago

    The selling concern was only mentioned as down the road when we are at retirement age when we may decide to head south. I doubt we ever will, but it's good to try to examine all possible scenarios.

  • 8 years ago

    One of the things that I think may have to happen is that both pieces may have to be perc'd- The couple acres you build on and the larger parcel as well. The zoning folks can let you know for sure. This is a fairly common practice in our area and I really didn't know what the reasoning for it was.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Here, requirements are lots are minimum 2 acres, with minimum 200 foot road frontage. You'll find exceptions, but they were grandfathered in .

    Here, this has led to some really impractical lot designs.. there are several empty lots in town of 15 acres.. with two hundred feet of road frontage... and 200 feet width going all the way back. Essentially unsellable. (I declined buying any "pencil lot" when I was land hunting).

    If I were you, I'd consider 5 acres, to ensure your privacy. Check your town's minimums, and design with topography in mind the best division layout, for both you and any potential buyer(s). A professional may help.

  • 8 years ago

    Another thing to keep in the back of your mind... what the zoning board giveth, the zoning board can taketh away.

    In other words, the rulz may not always be what they are now. Locally, flag lots are loathed entirely by the board and just unlikely to be permitted at all. Historically, this was NOT the case and you'll find a lot of them.

    Any rule that is made can be unmade. Making subdivisions of 5.8 acres because the smallest allowed is 3 works... until the smallest allowed is changed to 1.5. Whether this will happen in your area anytime soon depends on a lot of things. Changing demographics and local politics among them. (And I think we all know that no politics gets as down-and-dirty as local politics!)

    Past a certain point, pour yourself a glass of your favorite potent potable and do what you want to do.

  • 8 years ago

    In some states you can claim vacant land as farm land, lower taxes. We claimed 2 acres for home and 18 acres for farm/timber land. Ask your tax office.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Talk with a land planner to learn what's possible. You can follow your local rules to the letter or go through a planning process to creatively unlock the potential of this property.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Of course, do your due diligence pertaining to current zoning regulations and standards. But...keep in mind what Holly posted: zoning regulations and standards can and do get changed frequently and without warning, other than legally required due notice of a proposed change. Nothing, unfortunately, is forever.

    Your future flexibility and options will have a lot to do with the width, depth and road frontage of your property, not to mention any other appropriate restrictions, i.e., minimum parcel size for a well and septic system, road access to the other parcels, etc.

    Without seeing your property, understanding its configuration and knowing the current zoning restrictions in your area, it's almost impossible to be anymore specific.

    If it was my property, I'd be thinking to build on a parcel along the frontage road in one corner of the overall property, and maximize the frontage of the remaining, undeveloped property. I'd make my parcel large enough so that future development on either or both sides would not detract from my own development.

    Good luck on your project.