Software
Houzz Logo Print
hzdeleted_28126706

Cabinets: Conestoga vs Shiloh ?

8 years ago

Our construction is well underway and we need to focus on ordering cabinets. We budgeted for a good RTA cabinet. We've got pricing on Conestoga but at suggestion of local cabinet company we visited yesterday, they suggested Shiloh. Granted they did that since they sell Shiloh but it did seem to be a well made cabinet. Shiloh looks good but I am really more concerned about how they hold up long term than what looks pretty when the wife looks at photos.


Based on everything we've read here, Conestoga is a pretty solid choice. Can anyone give us any real world comparisons between the two. Builder is looking at ordering in another 4 to 5 weeks.

We selected the granite a while back.


Thanks

Comments (12)

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I’m very happy with my Conestoga. The prices are radically different between the two. I was quoted $57K for Shiloh vs. the $14K I paid for Conestoga and IKEA combo.

    I’m not sure what it is cabinet by cabinet but my Conestoga oven cabinet (huge) fully finished was $1200 vs. $3600 from a custom builder unfinished.

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you, that's a BIG difference. I believe Conestoga was about $23K for the entire house, baths, laundry room and the like. Case closed.

  • 8 years ago

    Another vote for Conestoga here! I didn't get a Shiloh quote, but Conestoga was so much less than the others I did get that even factoring in time for assembly, I felt like it was a good choice.

  • 8 years ago

    I like Conestoga, but I didn't have any price comparisons with Shiloh since they're not sold in my area. Shiloh and Conestoga are both highly regarded on GW. Some things to think about:

    How much is your GC charging to assemble the RTA cabinets? Shiloh should save you some on labor.

    Also do you have a good KD? I used a Conestoga dealer--they recommended a virtual KD and refunded me most of her design fee. She was OK but not amazing. I feel that a more creative KD could have taken more advantage of the Conestoga customization options. But she was inexpensive and helped ensure no mistakes in the cabinet order. If the Shiloh designer seems good, I would place a lot of value on that. Depends on how large the cost difference is.

  • 8 years ago

    I forgot to say that the drawers from Conestoga were exceptional compared to my neighbor’s extremely expensive custom drawers. I don’t remember the Shiloh’s drawers but the Crystal drawers that I looked at were flimsy in comparison and that quote was $150K.

    It’s a lot more work but I went thru their catalog with a fine tooth comb and did everything on a custom basis so that I had zero unnecessary fillers.

    I also ordered my drawers to be deeper in order to avoid the normal 3-5” waste behind the drawers.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    There is a HUGE difference between an RTA cabinet and a semi-custom one. You are truly comparing apples and oranges here. I know nothing about Conestoga, but I do know that RTA cabinets are usually not at all the same quality as a semi-custom cabinet such as Shiloh.

    I put Shiloh in my own kitchen, replacing some 40 yr old RTA cabinets. I could not be happier with the quality and the options available - it really was custom, not semi-custom.

    I'm sure a Kia is a great car for the price, but don't compare it with an Audi and then complain that the Audi costs a lot more. The bottom line is "what can you afford" and how much do you WANT to afford?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Conestoga is an Audi that you design and then assemble yourself. Way difficult to know what you don’t know and to get up to speed on in order for it to be “worth” the incredible hassle of DIYing.

    If you aren’t assembling yourself, you lose a LOT of the economics of ordering RTA. A DIYer can go slow and make dure everything is square, and there’s enough glue in the right places, etc. Your basic Lowball Larry $125 per box guy is going to want to rush on to the next job.

    That’s not an installation price. That’s an assembly price. If you don’t know what you don’t know, andorder something difficult or impossible to install, you get to pay more for install. A whole house install usually is 5-9K. Inset Or frameless is more.

    Do NOT allow your GC’s “I gotta guy” touch cabinets. Cabinets are a specialty.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    While Conestoga is great quality, in the end, you don't save very much over buying a good mid grade already assembled line. Especially if you don't need all of the specialty customizations that are possible. There's also the potential for way too much finger pointing when you have homeowners designing, a cabinet person interpreting the design and inputting the order, and a 3rd person of a contractor assembling and installing.

    You need one person start to finish. Conestoga was originally designed for those in the trades, not homeowners. The companies that have sprung up to bridge the gap don't always do the best job doing that. Even with the best of intentions. There are just too many layers and too much technical knowledge needed.

  • 8 years ago

    We went with Conestoga and are very pleased with the quality. Definitely not a "Kia." We worked with a Conestoga affiliated kitchen designer who created the cabinet order list for usand then had a long phone interview with a Conestoga rep who reviewed the order thoroughly. The cabinets fit the space perfectly and we were able to customize as needed. Having said all that, we would not have gone this way if we weren't experienced DIYers. If you're not comfortable with assembly and installation, then Conestoga is not for you. It suited us fine since we had the skill and time, and saved a lot of money!

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    There's a lot that can go into even a simple small space. This mudroom space isn't very big, but the modifications to the cabinets to get this look are numerous. Someone that doesn't work with cabinets every day, may not even know that some of these modifications are possible, much less how to indicate that you want that to happen.

    The cabinet on the lower left has the following modifications.

    7 modifications, just on that one cabinet, and NOT including the overall cabinet Global attributes which include antiquing, distressing, glazing, and a specific finish on inset cabinets. Very upgraded choices to start with.. Each cabinet in the design has some modification except for the coat rack hooks. There isn't a standard unmodified cabinet in the bunch. This is only 5 cabinets, but this is 2 full pages of specifications. And each modification has to be double checked twice, by the person who is going to assemble, and the person ordering. If I forgot the FE-R, then the whole cabinet would be completely unusable in the design. I'd have to order it correctly again.

    If anyone want's to know what each of those ordering codes means, look at the design, and the fact that there is an outlet on the side there that needs room for the guts inside the cabinet, and the side of the cabinet has to be finished because it's exposed. The "feet" are specified in a particular way, because the cabinet is next to a wall on the left. Each side is specified differently because of that. And there's a power station inside the drawer, to charge phones, etc.

    Multiply these 5 cabinets by an entire kitchen. And you'll see what you need an expert KD to help you with this. But, by the time you pay for that help, and the assembly, It's doubtful that you will have saved much over choosing a good already assembled line would cost. This mudroom done in DuraSupreme, is 13K. It could be half of that without all of that antiquing and distressing. And it could be half that again in the least expensive door style in a full overlay instead of inset. That's the other thing that an experienced KD brings to the table. The knowledge of potential tradeoffs affect on the bottom line. These folks fell in love with a super distressed display, and they really wanted it. And they could afford it.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Am very happy with the quality and value of my Shiloh cabinets.