Software
Houzz Logo Print
hexyl_cinnamal

Hens and Chicks Rotting

8 years ago
From personal experience, my succulents rot from too much water. So I made sure I rarely water my hens and chicks. I give them a light splash of water once a month and they do well. I have them growing indoors with bright light. Well, I went to to go water one of them since I haven't watered it since February 1st, and I noticed it was rotting. Any idea why? I don't think overwatering is the issue since the plant has been dry for so long and has been doing well. And other parts of it are doing just great.

Comments (18)

  • 8 years ago
    The soil also does not retain much moisture. Some people tell me when I water it the soil may retain water for too long but I literally gave the plant 3 tablespoons of water a month ago and the soil was dry within 3 days. And the plant has been thriving for all this time and 3 days ago had no visible rot until today. Can underwatering cause rot? Or maybe not enough light?
  • 8 years ago
    Ok so looks like I will move it outside into a sunny area that's not too hot. Thank you!
  • 8 years ago

    I live in a seasonal climate. Frost , no problem. Only 2 - high uv kills with sunburn, summer rains make them rot. Rain doesnt bother them much in autumn or spring, neither does snow.

  • 8 years ago

    Semps really need bright light, and they look etiolated in these pics- they were likely weakened and not growing well, and succumbed. They can take frost and snow, so keep them outside in direct light if you can. Succulents should also be watered thoroughly and then allowed to dry completely- the water was likely not reaching the entire pot and parts of the roots could have died off, so when there was water it couldn't be taken in. What was the root situation when you dismantled it?

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    They both look like they need to go outside. This appearance is them indicating to you that they need to be outside.

    And yes, too little water can cause them to rot because the roots die and when they are exposed to water again, they don't have any roots to take it in and just soak in it.

  • 8 years ago
    Thank you for the responses! I'm have just put them outside. They don't have too many roots but the ones that exist are large and white.
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That's great news! I hope they do well for you outside. I know you've told us before but what is your general location in the world?

    Oh I just looked at your profile. Florida! Just keep them in a big pot outside and they should do well for you, so long as you don't water them while it's too hot.

  • 8 years ago

    What is your general location and/or growing zone? Did you just put them outdoors directly into much better light? What did you pot them into- soil?

    Biggest mistake ppl make is trying to grow Semps well indoors. These are generally very easy succulents to grow but as all plants - in suitable conditions. I see them for sale in GH without any suggestion that they are hardy...They should have winter rest, and they will grow happily outdoors.

  • 8 years ago
    You all seem to be so experienced with this. When you guys first started did you have problems like me? How are things going now? How long did it take to master succulents? I feel like I am always learning something new.
  • 8 years ago

    Anyone who thinks they know everything is a fool. There's always more to learn. I learned with Semps the hard way.

  • 8 years ago

    Semps are alpine plants and do just fine outdoors. I have them growing outdoors on rocks and pieces of wood - and I never water them. They get what the skies offer, in terms of sun and moisture. Hard conditions produce some amazingly dwarfed plants.

    Al

  • 8 years ago

    There's definitely a learning curve when growing succulent, they want almost the opposite of any other house plant. When I started I couldn't keep any alive over winter but now I grow most of mine from seed. Semps are very forgiving outside and looks like lots of good advice has been given. Here's one of mine in my yard putting on a good show last year, right now it's under 4ft of snow with probably 2 months left before it gets temperatures above freezing over night.

  • 8 years ago

    If you are using common garden soil be sure to mix a 50/50 ratio with sand for really good drainage. Then only water them once to settle the soil around the roots. Mine are in a pot out of the driveway and the rain takes care of them. Just treat them like a cactus.

  • 8 years ago

    FWIW - garden soil + what we commonly think of as sand = poor drainage. Even horticultural sand, which is like BB-size gravel, + garden soil = poor drainage ....... unless the BB-size horticultural sand is overwhelmingly the larger fraction of the soil - as in 85-95%.

    Al

  • 8 years ago

    Chad, thats a saxifraga. Close due to relation, but not a sempervivum. Flowers are a dead giveaway.

  • 8 years ago

    Ahhh gotcha. Thanks for the ID. I've got so many different ones scattered around the yard I never bothered to figure out what they all were, I just assumed they were sempervium.

  • 8 years ago

    Semperivivum has several related genuses, which look closely alike, but are still distinct in some aspects. These are jovibarba, rosularia, orostachys,promethrum. Some of these are rare though.