What color is your roof?

Roof is brown.

I think black would work better with a gray roof. My own choice would be white for the windows. Better yet, a soft white.

your right thinking black might be better with a black or grey roof. Forgot to mention that the siding is a sage green cedar shingle. Color doesn't show up the best in the picture.

Nan, sage green with a soft white trim can look really nice.

Something to think about for sure, now I'm even more confused haha.

With the brown roof, I would use wither white or cream.

The bright white storm door is no longer there, it was on the house when we bought it and has been replaced with one that is close to the color of the current trim, that's an old picture, I disliked it as well :)

Black would look nice. Just be aware they are almost twice as much as white.