Software
Houzz Logo Print
lesliemiikal

Replacing butcher block due to fire

8 years ago
last modified: 8 years ago

Okay, we had a house fire last week. The butcher block we had is no longer available and frankly could care less because it was the butcher block oil that ignited. I liked the look of it in the kitchen but don't know what to pick out. Something of equal value but low maintenance ie:no oil to cause a fire. It was ikea birch butcher block, i dont want fake laminate butcherblock but dont want fake granite look either. Whats a good choice that keeps a farmhouse style?

Comments (22)

  • 8 years ago

    this was before, we're changing the paint colour since we might as well, just doing a neutral

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    What kind of oil were you using on it?

  • 8 years ago

    So sorry for your loss. I hope your recovery goes as smoothly as possible.

    I admit I have trouble with the "farmhouse" label, in that I don't really understand what most people mean by it. But real live farmhouses are about practical durability, so to me a solid colour laminate would be perfectly acceptable in a farmhouse design.

    I don't know if laminate is an appropriate choice with your stovetop.


  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I was thinking that quartz would be a good choice. You can get veined materials that look like marble. I'd never put wood in as a countertop near a sink or a range. If it caught on fire, I think that would make me even more set against it.

  • 8 years ago

    How much are you looking to spend and how much countertop do you need to replace?

    Solid surface, like Corian, is very durable and low maintenance (and definitely won't catch on fire). It comes in a lot of colors and styles, so I'm sure something would go with the look you want.

    Natural stones are always nice and look good with farmhouse style. Granite is practically indestructible and very low maintenance.

  • PRO
    8 years ago
    Jet Mist or Virginia Mist granite with honed surface would be great. Honed surface gives it look of soapstone without the maintenance. Check that out.
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Just saw your picture of "now" and the black island would look fantastic in your kitchen. Let me find a photo for you to give you inspiration.

    Bayview - Kitchen and Mudroom · More Info

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    That granite on your island with your remaining elements would be outstanding look IMO! I actually like the greens, but I would go more yellow green with your flooring.

    paint · More Info
    Here are some examples of the more yellow greens and dark colors with cream.

    lesliemiikal thanked Flo Mangan
  • 8 years ago

    The oil was food grade mineral with beeswax mixed, basically similar to that "Harolds" oil stuff. I had made my own, it was cooling on the cooktop and the cooktop didnt get locked out so the cat turned the burners on high and well that was that. Just a series of unfortunate choices/forgetfulness on my and my husbands part. I am not personally spending money as its covered by insurance but i need to find something thats of equal value to the ikea butcherblock. I will look up sone of the ideas given and thanks for the input thus far! Also like those counters someone posted above there, looks nice!

  • 8 years ago

    Love Flo's idea. Black would look amazing in your kitchen and goes great with the farmhouse look.

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Wow! Did the cat survive!? That is crazy situation. Would make a good State Farm ad! Sorry, but in a way, kind of funny! But not! So it wasn't the wood top that flamed but rather the pot of oil on the range? That makes more sense.

  • 8 years ago

    Yes, it was a pot of oil, burned up the wall.behind the cooktop and damaged so many things. Cat survived as he just jumped up and jumped back down. They're ripping out our upper cabinets, all the drywall on the ceiling, the drywall behind the cooktop, the flooring has to be ripped out, along with the laminate in the rest of our house. So much damage! Its the second claim this year our agent has processed by an animal turning on a cooktop apparently

  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Happy for your pet, although he/she should be banned from kitchen going forward. Boy, you are lucky actually that it wasn't worse. Lucky being relative I guess. But the whole house could have gone up. Any further thoughts on the island countertop?

  • 8 years ago

    Are you doing a backsplash? Are you adding knobs? You could go in any direction with counters and backsplash. I'd definitely remove the green paint since it distracts from your beautiful floors and cabinets....

  • 8 years ago

    The granite will be more than the butcher block as birch butcher block is relatively inexpensive - I had it on my island till I replaced it with quartz. If the black granite is too much, black laminate is not that expensive. Some home center stores might even carry black laminate as a "stock laminate" which would make it even less.

    Some granite has gone down in price - maybe you can make that work.

    Stock black laminate:

    https://www.menards.com/main/kitchen/countertops-laminate/view-all-countertops-laminate/customcraft-countertops-reg-10-miter-standard-laminate-countertop/4851969/p-1452209845576-c-3629.htm?tid=-6966696627198110160&ipos=5

    In often comes in preset lengths and needs to be cut to the right length for your kitchen.

  • 8 years ago

    We havent picked hardware yet, there's no island either. Also, the paint colour looks nothing like in the photo, my camera makes it look almost limey and dark, it definitely is way off in the picture lol. The plan is to do a backsplash I just don't know what yet. We were told by insurance to go look tomorrow morning and pick so we'll see what we end up with, I'm not sure the black is my style but it does lool nice!

  • 8 years ago
    Here's the full kitchen before the fire, mind the dishes, we live here lol. I have toyed with the idea of an island but I'm not sure it would work so much with the french doors and windows. Also, the kickplates obviously didnt work, they were ikea so didn't fit well. I'm definitely going to think hard on new counters, they'll be laminate afterall due to insurance, which is fine by me!
  • 8 years ago
    picked this, it's a nicer premium finish laminate so I'm glad we were able to get it instead of the "base" patterns and finishes. the picture isn't quite true to colour again, its on top of the bodbyn off white face plate, both look much cooler in this picture, they're warmer in person. thanks for your help everyone!
  • 8 years ago
    That looks like a really stunning pattern for laminate. Be sure to check online at what the overall pattern looks like. The small piece sometimes doesn’t give full view of what it looks like. Sometimes you can get larger samples. If it is Wilsonart or Formica you can probably get a larger sample online homedepot.com. 25 cents.

    I don’t recognize the pattern. What is the name?
  • 8 years ago
    I saw the large sample piece in store but took home the chip for finding paint samples. it's called "Typhoon Ice" by Wilsonart. It has some warmth in it that matches the warmth of the bodbyn off white.
  • 8 years ago
    I'm doing a more airy neutral green too which will hopefully all look nice together. this is just the online stock photo "painted"
Sponsored
Urban Upkeep LLC
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars6 Reviews
Columbus High Quality Painting Expert