I like the look of dark trim with brick: dark taupe, gray-blue, grayed pine green, charcoal gray. Check out "brick exteriors" photos on Houzz for a range of trim colors. White is just ordinary...not bad, but not a WOW either.

If you do a dark door with a dark screen door, the screen door will also have less of a prominent effect. Before I blew up your picture, I actually thought you had double all glass doors because the screen door was all I could see. It's also possible to get modern screen/storm doors with smaller side and bottom profiles so you can see more of your door.

Aside from the front door, I would actually focus on your front walk. It is too visually narrow for a double door and hugs the corner of the garage uncomfortably. A wider walk (6' or so) that extends slightly further into the yard before connecting to the drive. Functionally it would be a lot more comfortable for two or more people to walk up to your door too. Change from concrete to some sort of paver and edge with landscape would definitely upgrade the whole look.

Thanks for the advice! We don't plan on updating anything outside structurally but color. Here is the house in the spring with some color. Thanks again for the comments!

I wouldn't paint the brick. It looks nice and is zero maintenance. I agree about getting a dark door and storm door (I also love a screen door. I use the kind that stores the screen so it's mostly just a glass door) and then painting the trim dark.