Software
Houzz Logo Print
cristina_s37

Will this Cl Pinkie ever do well?

My Cl Pinkie order from ARE arrived last week - but it did not look at all spry out of the box. It is the first rose I have ordered online and at first I thought it is normal for it not to look that great after all the transportation in a box.

However, even after taking it out and watering ...it's been a few days and it still looks disappointing. I haven't planted it yet because it's been raining a lot over the past few days - but I am starting to have doubts this plant will ever do well.

It's thin and spindly, some leaves are still wilted - just not a great looking plant.

One of the cut canes (to the right) is brown and felt a bit soft at the tip yesterday. It looks like it is rotting to me.

Should I ask for a refund?

ARE says they can do a refund if the rose dies within 6 months...but I don't want to wait until then.

Comments (31)

  • 8 years ago

    Give it a chance. It looks totally normal. Take care of it in the pot, or better yet plant it. Roses need a good month or so to start before you judge. Climbing Pinkie is a winner.

  • 8 years ago

    ARE has always sends me really great roses. They might look a bit funny at first (either defoliated or trimmed back to fit in the box), but they are more mature than the own root roses some other companies send out, and will look fabulous in short order. If you give the plant enough sun and the appropriate amount of water, it is going to be wonderful. :)

  • 8 years ago

    P.S. if a cane dies that is OK and to be expected. You can cut away the dead cane.


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    That's a nice looking plant. Own roots can look scary compared to big potted grafted roses you see in stores. Plant it, and watch it take off. They really look scary if they come defoliated, but they leaf out pretty quick. Watch some Paul Zimmerman videos on youtube, and you won't worry so much, and you might laugh too. I don't grow that one, but some canes can be red because they're new. It looks kind of red to me, but I can't tell actual color from a picture on a screen. When I post purples they look pink. If you want to be sure, cut that brown cane above that set of leaves that's growing out of it (first set from the top), and see if it's white inside. It looks like a new cane to me.

  • 8 years ago

    It looks fine. Roses almost always arrive a bit beat up after shipping and they bounce back quickly. You’ll see. In a couple of weeks she’ll be sending out ne shoots and you’ll forget she ever looked ratty. Plus, climbing pinkie is tough.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I have three climbing pinkie and she’s one tough rose. She has thin flexible canes that are easy to train. Plant her in the ground and watch her grow! And I second the Paul Zimmerman videos on YouTube, super informative on how to train climbing roses.

  • 8 years ago

    Thank you all for the encouragement!

    Does all of the above apply even if the plant came with black spot? I have noticed several leaves when it first came, I removed them (this is why you don't see them in the picture) - but this morning I saw more.

    Removed these too...but...

    I am not sure a plant should arrive with black spot. ....

  • 8 years ago

    I don’t thinks it’s uncommon for roses to have some black spot during shipping. Your rose will be fine, you did the right thing by picking off the leaves.

  • 8 years ago

    The dark box and damp plant create the perfect environment for a little black spot. It'll do great in no time at all !

  • 8 years ago

    Black spot is a universal affliction for roses, so don't worry. You can expect that your roses will have a little bit of black spot during the course of their lives. Even if you bring in a plant that has been drenched in anti-fungal spray to kill off every last bit of black spot (hypothetically -- if that is even possible) it would soon come into contact with local black spot in your garden. Usually it is just cosmetic. If it really bothers you, know that as roses mature they often develop some resistance. Some plants like alliums and salvias are supposed to have natural anti-fungal properties, so people use them in rose plantings to combat black spot and powdery mildew. If you are REALLY freaked out about seeing spots on your roses you can, of course, spray them with anti-fungal stuff (but that stuff is nasty, and I'd much rather have slightly spotty roses than have to spray poison -- but that is just my opinion). Picking off the worst leaves and keeping the area below the plant free of dead leaves, as best you can, helps. But don't worry about a little black spot.

  • 8 years ago

    K S,

    You said that the fungicide stuff is "nasty". Would you mind elaborating?

    Based on some advice I received here, I bought some Bonide Cooper Fungicide (organic) and sprayed another newly planted rose preventatively.

    What do people mean when they say that stuff is "nasty"?

    Is it dangerous to the gardener?

    Because if yes - I'd rather have spotted roses (or none at all) than place myself or my family in danger.



  • 8 years ago

    Yes when they say nasty they mean it’s bad for people, insects and the environment. I have the option that roses need to be able to build an immunity to be able to fight off BS and spraying inhibits that along with being bad for people and the environment. I would never spray newly planted baby roses, your roses that have been shipped need time to settle in and recover from the trip and get stronger. I feel like building good soil is the key to healthy roses, and I’m going to add that this is just my opinion so take it as you will. I have had some roses that have bs the first year and after they have had time to grow and mature they are able to shake it off better. Good luck with all your roses and try to enjoy them and don’t sweat the small stuff, you will drive yourself crazy aiming for perfect roses.

  • 8 years ago

    severe_novice, please don't get all upset over this rose. Cl. Pinkie does very well in my BS heaven garden with no intervention ONCE I planted her. Plants often have a lower threshold in pots especially after a long journey in a closed container. Let her acclimate and repot or plant her. She's very vigorous and will rebound, I'm sure. Mine looked much worse last year from ARE and did great by the end of the summer. (Unfortunately, she hasn't liked our on again/off again weather) : ((

    There are also many different things to use for BS, from skim milk to the Cornell mixture, sulphur and Copper to neem and horticultural dormant spray if you don't want to go with a less environmentally-friendly option. I have only just considered spraying because even BS resistant varieties here will BS and defoliate, so if I want roses I'll have to spray something.

  • 8 years ago

    What boncrow said!

    Something is going to kill all of us in the end, so maybe spraying a bit of fungicide on a rose isn't the worst thing any of us will ever do. But even copper is toxic if you get enough of it on you. http://pmep.cce.cornell.edu/profiles/extoxnet/carbaryl-dicrotophos/copper-sulfate-ext.html

    Given the presence of beneficial fungi in the soil, and good soil microorganisms, I try not to spray stuff on my roses if I can help it (but I wouldn't beat myself up about it if I did). That is a personal decision, and, in part, it relates to my own family history (my grandfather was a farmer, and he died at an early age of cancer -- quite possibly linked to the chemicals he used). You aren't likely to hurt anyone by spraying a bit of Bonide on your roses, but it is always good to be careful with those sorts of products -- even if they are labeled "organic."

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Hi Severe Novice. I don’t get a lot of black spot here since it is so dry in my area of NorCal, but I can tell you that my Climbing Pinkie came from ARE about a year a half ago looking very similar to yours. Except here roses come totally defoliated due to CA laws, so mine looked even more sad! Not to worry. A year and half later that little rose is now this...

    I have it on an umbrella trellis so it is going up, then cascading back down over the umbrella.

    The first year it didn’t bloom much or grow much, it was busy growing roots. Look at all those buds now! I cut off MANY canes because of how I’m training it. I hard pruned it in winter and defoliated it. It grows back with force!

    So just plant it in the ground if you can, give it some fresh air and circulation. I bet it will be one of your healthiest roses.

  • 8 years ago

    I should also say I’m mostly organic/permaculture and don’t spray it with anything. No judgement to those who do though.

    The aphids love it because of how fast it grows... but the soldier beetles, lady bugs and hover fly larvae love the aphids, so everyone gets fat and happy in my yard.

  • 8 years ago

    Ah ha! I found a photo of my Climbing Pinkie from May of last year. Big difference! It was maybe 6 months old (from ARE delivery) here. Get yours planted and just give it time.


  • 8 years ago

    Thank you all for the valuable information and for your amazing Pinkie pictures, Cori Ann!! I can't believe the number of buds!

    I am certainly familiar with that nice, dry air - just right for roses. :-) I get it all the time when I go home back in Europe to visit my parents. Their neighbor has the most stunning roses I have ever seen.

    The South can get quite humid, but I heard it can be worse. :-)

    I am not a purist - in that one black spot here and there doesn't bother me for esthetic purposes, as long as I get my blooms.

    I am just afraid that thing can take over the whole plant and retard growth.

  • 8 years ago

    It is not particularly unusual for roses under stress to develop a little disease issue. In our part of the country disease pressure is a fact of life--unless you are willing to have an intensive spray program. Me, not so much. I got my Cl. Pinkie from a friend who had had it in a gallon pot neglected in a shady spot without water or any attention for a year or two. I wasn't even sure it was a alive, but she promised me it was too hard to kill to be dead. I got it in the ground in a tough spot. Lots of sun and a few scoops of manure from the "locals", but pretty much ignored otherwise (including some much needed pruning--you'd think I could get in there and at least get the dead stuff out!) Seems to be doing ok after a couple years:

  • 8 years ago

    subk3,

    What a nice story! Beautiful bush!

    It does sound like this Pinkie is a toughie.

    I wonder how tall it can grow...

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I would say it could probably get as tall as you’re willing to train it. Here’s what mine looked like just in January (after I pruned/defoliated), so all the growth you see after that happened in just the last 3 months. If you wanted it taller/shorter it would all just be up to how much/little you wanted to prune it.

    Enjoy yours! It’s going to be great. it’s a great rose to try as a newbie since it’s so easy to train, thornless and hard to kill. :-)

  • 8 years ago

    Amazing, Cori Ann!

    Do you defoliate like this and prune every year?

  • 8 years ago

    I just started defoliating for the past 2 years, but I have always pruned my roses. Defoliating probably isn't necessary in your colder zone? They don't go dormant here in zone 9, so it's my way of forcing dormancy. :-)

  • 8 years ago

    S_N, I wanted mine to get big, but this winter's freeze/thaw did a number on Cl.P even after she seemed to keep many of her canes in -7 temps. She's a baby still so maybe that affects thing. I just don't now think I'll consistently see this size plant as a hard winter will kill her back to nubbins. : (( I think one zone higher or less crazy weather would be ideal.

  • 8 years ago

    my climbing pinkie is a beast....not all of her can be seen here, she also spreads the whole length of the fence beside the arbor. I'm a very bad gardener and I don't feed my plants well. Only the strong thrive.

  • 8 years ago

    ljsemar,

    Lovely pinkie!

    You may be a bad gardener, but that rose loves you!

    Stockholm syndrome. :-))))


    Vaporvac,

    I think I am planting my Pinkie tomorrow. I plan on placing it in this flower bed to climb on the deck rails. Once it climbs up, I could see it from my kitchen window all the time.

    It would get morning, mid-day (dappled), and even some afternoon sun there - so hopefully it will be a good spot. I may have to remove some of those hostas, especially if I will add a second one at some point.

    I am still a bit worried about the tiny foliage - but then again, I am yet to place it in the ground and it is yet to see much of any sun, after days and days of rain. And there will be more rain tomorrow.

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I just wanted to add I finally planted my Pinkie.

    I looked EVERYWHERE in my garden to see whether I could find a better sub-exposed spot, but to no avail.

    I thought this spot was getting more sun than it actually does. I followed closely today, after planting and the only time it gets full sun is for a couple of hours in the middle of the day, when the sun is at the top. There is some morning sun too. but dappled.

    Urggh...I hope this Pinkie is reasonably shade tolerant. I read a post on Garden web that said the Pinkie was blooming even with only a couple of hours of sun daily.

    I am not holding my breath though...

  • 8 years ago

    I will post a picture tomorrow after taking precise notes on how many hours of direct sun it gets exactly. Does dappled sun count?

    Our back yard is surrounded by tall trees so unless the sun is right at the top, sun-rays are filtered by by leaves of tall trees.


  • 8 years ago

    Hopefully others with more experience will respond, but I think you'll be okay. My climbing Pinkie, new last year, bloomed until Frost in the shade of a north-facing wall. It would get afternoon sun when I first planted her late in the season. As fall progressed it became shade only and she still bloomed. Unfortunately, she didn't like the freeze-thaw and she's twigs at the moment. :-(

  • 8 years ago

    vaporvac,

    Oh, thank you! That gives me some hope!

    I think that being planted right behind and below the deck itself also provides a bit of shade at some point during the day - because there are moments when the deck is in full sun, but right below, behind it (where my Pinkie is now) - not so much.

    But if yours bloomed in the shade of a north-facing window - there's definitely hope.

    I hope none of my roses will succomb to Georgia winters which are generally mild.

    That being said, IT CAN freeze.

    I guess I will have to watch the weather more carefully, and when they announce freeze, I will see what measures I can take and hope it will not last too long.

    I have not read about how to get them through the winter yet - I just want lots of flowers for the summer for the time being. :-)